10 ms·
Android Creator’s Startup Essential Products Cuts About 30% of Staff
- matchbok 8y agoSad to see. It seems there really isn't a market for these types of Android phones.
- nradov 8y agoWhat type of Android phone is that? It seemed to differ from other Android devices only in trivial details; there was no significant differentiation or innovation.
- notyourday 8y agoSoftware upgrades within a week or so of Google releasing new Android, no bloatware, fast, excellent battery life.
- lozaning 8y agoI'll say the same about my Pixel.
- nradov 8y agoThe battery is only 3040mAh and isn't even removable. Not impressive at all.
- EpicEng 8y agoI don't think any of those features are related to their failure. They launched with a sub-par product in the $700 price range.
- p1necone 8y agoSounds like the Nokia phones to me - I have a Nokia 6.1 and it ticks most of those boxes. (I don't know if the battery counts as excellent - it lasts ~36 hours if I'm not using it constantly but that seems about average for a new battery in most mid range phones)
- omnimus 8y agoAndroid One phones will do it on software side.
- notyourday 8y agoAnd given enough thrust pigs will fly. I'm sure it would be magical when it actually happens but it has not happened so far.
- Steltek 8y agoA classy phone not from a giant tech company or with questionable governmental ties? No forced bloatware? Fast, reliable updates? There's really no market for that? The market is stupid and wrong. This isn't a failure of technology. This is a failure of marketing and getting the message out.
- andun 8y agoOr maybe people don't care about being spied upon, getting updates, and don't even know what bloatware is.
- Steko 8y ago> people don't care about being spied upon Perhaps "sign in to google" isn't the bulletproof privacy phone some commenters are implying it is.
- nine_k 8y agoThe market is there, of course! It just appears to be narrower that what's required to sustain a company like this, at least at the price point they chose. I can imagine such a phone as a no-compromises ultra-premium product for the select few who want utter privacy and safety, and would pay at e.g. the iPhone's price point for a comparable level of assurance. I can imagine such a phone at a low-end, cheaper segment for the privacy-conscious but not very well-off who could tolerate a number of compromises in features. At a mass-market segment it, unfortunately, did not seem to work too well, though.
- notyourday 8y agoIt was overpriced. They sold what? 50k phones at about $500 a pop average before cutting the price to $350? That's $25m in revenue after raising $300m. They should have continued working on a line of phones. Instead they switched gears, dropped the price on a phone and started doing a fire sale.
- radicaldreamer 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arthurcolle 8y agoI don't understand why Essential suicided itself by immediately putting itself up for sale. Such a lost opportunity
- sigfubar 8y agoPride. Wishful thinking. Belief in magic. Pick any three.
- bdcravens 8y agoRemember that Android, Inc was purchased by Google in less than 2 years after being founded, and before it even launched a product.
- arthurcolle 8y agowhat are you getting at? he's not The Messiah?
- bdcravens 8y agoThat his previous success came via a quick exit/acquihire, which is what's he's trying to do again.
- Latteland 8y agoGoogle should buy this company, add a jack and wireless charging, sell it for $400 and declare victory.
- arbie 8y agoWhy would they sabotage the Pixel's pricing strategy like that?
- Latteland 8y agoI think it's basically as good as a pixel. Is there anything that comes from the pointless "neural network" chip in it? Nothing that I can see, but it's possible there's something new that I don't know about. Really, just add a jack to it and declare victory.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThe differentiator is not clear enough. If you're up against massive entities who can produce on the cheap, the value prop in consumerland has to be obvious and poignant, i.e. it should be easy to create a narrative that 'this phone is the best for X' and a lot of people want X. It can be aspirational or functional or both or whatever but it has to pop.
- nakedrobot2 8y agoOr maybe their phone sucked. Which, apparently, it did. Especially the camera.
- Steltek 8y agoNot familiar with any issues besides the camera.
- sf_rob 8y agoMine was the buggiest Android device I've ever owned (headphones not detected, random reboots, volume rocker not responding, etc). I returned it rather than exchange. That said I have friends who love theirs.
- SamWhited 8y agoIt's also completely impossible to repair and the screen cracks if you breath on it wrong (contrary to all their claims about toughness they advertised so heavily when they came out with it). By impossible to repair, I mean quite literally no one including them will repair it, if something goes wrong they will send you a new one at a slight discount, but given how expensive it is that's not much comfort since you can still buy another brand of phone cheaper (I think it was $200 off, which is a bit better now that they've dropped the price, but still insane for a "repair"). It's a serious waste of money. Looks nice though. EDIT: I say it looks nice, but the polished back was a stupid idea; everyone complains about their phone being covered in fingerprints, so if you do mirrored metal guess what happens… it's the worst phone I've ever had for looking dirty.
- 8y ago
- claydavisss 8y agoStill can't figure out what space they are looking to occupy. The Pixel phones have staked out the expensive-but-good market for "pure" Android snobs. Samsung has staked out the best-hardware-early market with deep ties to cell providers. OnePlus has staked out the cheaper-but-surprisingly-good market previously held by the Nexus line. Where does Essential fit? Rubin never answered this question. Outside of a few tech people, no one knows Essential exists...even OnePlus runs ads. I suspect Rubin thought he could just build some brand buzz and flip the whole company?
- bdcravens 8y ago> I suspect Rubin thought he could just build some brand buzz and flip the whole company? That's what happened last time (Android Inc was sold in less than 2 years, and hadn't even launched a phone yet)
- pjmlp 8y agoOnly because Google decided to go shopping.
- bdcravens 8y agoWhich was probably triggered by Apple (see Android prototypes pre- and post-acquisition and this becomes clear). Like many, he thought he could replicate previous success, but he may have hit one home run by being in the right place at the right time.
- pjmlp 8y agoAnd even then it wasn't really that innovative, I holded off to Symbian until Nokia lost it.
- danpalmer 8y agoI’m not sure the Pixel phones are expensive but good. They have been notorious for hardware problems, and the hardware quality has been ok, but not quite like a Samsung or Apple device. I’d say that Google don’t know how to make a fantastic Android phone, they know how to make a Googly phone, and I’m not convinced that’s what hardcore Android users want. Historically that meant “stock Android”, but now it means it’s more and more Googly. I think it may no longer be possible for a new entrant into the market to compete on quality. Samsung and Apple are operating at such a high economies of scale that no one else can match them at a price point anywhere near.
- xd1936 8y agoI'm super interested in the rumors that Essential is working on "an anti-smartphone with a small screen that relies primarily on voice commands."[1] The world needs more sub-5" phones now that Sony isn't making the Compact phones, and Apple isn't making a successor to the iPhone SE. 1. https://www.androidpolice.com/2018/10/10/essential-ai-phone-that-operates-mainly-through-voice-commands/ https://www.androidpolice.com/2018/10/10/essential-ai-phone-...
- desireco42 8y agoAgreed. I feel like they are all trying to hard to invent something new instead of just listening and talking to users. Small format phone practically doesn't exist. Palm concept is nice for example but way to expensive for second phone. Also, not nearly as much focused on essential services you would use this phone for.
- trevyn 8y agoI’d love a square phone; the iPhone Xs Max feels to me too tall but not wide enough.
- pyb 8y agoA smartwatch?
- sitepodmatt 8y agoImpractical to many, you still look like an idiot talking to your rist, just a 3.5" android from a major OEM (good battery and build, no spyware) will suffice.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Impractical to many, you still look like an idiot talking to your rist No more or less than you look like an idiot talking to a device in your hand (of course, if he function can be served with voice response, and you have earbuds/headset, you don't have to talk “to” either device in a visually apparently the way, so it's moot.)
- samfisher83 8y agoWhy don't we have xiaomi in the US. One plus has crept their price up. I think if we have a company that can go make a pocofone would do well here. If you can get 90% of flagship features for less than 1/2 of the price I think you could do well in the US.
- axaxs 8y agoI'm a bit sad to see this, but it wasn't hard to predict. Essential launched its PH1, which was design-wise ahead of the curve. But, they didn't really seem to listen to or predict the market. First, there was no headphone jack. That's controversial, but you've probably lost what I'd guess at least 10% of your potential market by doing so(potentially as high as 40%). Second, the camera at launch was not good. That's probably what is most important to most people. I've heard it's gotten better, but a bit late. Last, and most importantly, it was absolutely overpriced. It brought nothing to the table to warrant its price, and probably should have been sub $500 at launch. Each of these points can be nitpicked by saying "well Samsung/Apple/LG/Oneplus did it", but Essential is not that. They are an unknown startup company with no consumer trust. You cannot expect people to give up features and pay Samsung prices before they know who you are. /rant
- radicaldreamer 8y agoI doubt the headphone jack had much of an impact on the market, but the go-to-market strategy just wasn't there (Sprint isn't a tier 1 carrier), the camera got poor reviews, and their first accessory, the 360 camera, just wasn't compelling enough, even for the enthusiast market.
- Latteland 8y agoThere is no reasonable medium to top end phone that is almost pure android and has a headphone jack. it's just stupid to drop it, those who want the headphone jack would buy such a unicorn phone that would lead to it being a real competitive advantage.
- diminish 8y agoI still believe there's room for another premium US smartphone besides Pixel, Apple. China has Xiaomi and Europe has totally lost the smartphone race. Open source software, hardware initiatives have also failed to attract attention (Ubuntu, Firefoxos, ..) Essential or anyone needs some innovative new features or 'feel' to it.
- 8y ago
- vsviridov 8y ago/r/titlegore Took me a while to decypher that it meant "Android creator's startup Essential Products cuts about 30% of staff"
- thaumasiotes 8y agoIt's so easy to fix: Android Creator's Startup, Essential Products, Cuts About 30% of Staff
- NullPrefix 8y agoEssential Products, founded by Android creator, cuts about 30% of staff.