3 ms·
Lots of fringe people were predicting an imminent real estate implosion in 2005-2006 as the market got crazy. The real collapse didn't occur for several years.
by adventured 8y ago
Lots of fringe people were predicting an imminent real estate implosion in 2005-2006 as the market got crazy.
The real collapse didn't occur for several years.
They were wrong on the timing, which is fairly common, while being right about the cause and ultimate outcome.
China of 10 or 15 years ago is not China of today, as it pertains to their debt situation. Going from a 130% debt to GDP ratio, to 300% (or higher if you count shadow debt), puts you in a fiscal place that few nations have ever navigated successfully. Now China is reversing course on deleveraging and proceeding to leverage up further, likely making the situation worse.
300% debt to GDP may be sustainable with 8% real growth. How about at 5.5% growth? 4.8%? How about 450% debt to GDP, at 5.5% GDP growth? There are limits to this sort of approach to propping up an economy with very large sums of debt and slowing growth. How much does their growth drop off if they can no longer continue to expand the debt so dramatically? And when that happens, can they still service their debts well? The question is exactly where the limits are and what the consequences will be as they're hit. That varies from country to country, depending on the unique circumstances, and depending on the type of debt. What you can be certain about with China, and what it's doing, is that it's not good. Even if that immense pile of total debt - which continues to grow rapidly - doesn't implode their economy, it is very likely to stagnate it at a minimum by robbing the economy of the growth capital it needs (diverting it to rather incredible debt interest payment sums, as is the case now). As that debt goes higher, more and more of each incremental dollar of GDP growth is going to maintain it.
While all of that is happening: China has large pension funding problems, very high real corporate tax rates that are smothering its economy, a weak social safety net, a shrinking small business market and expanding government-corporate sector that is far less efficient than the private sector, a rapidly aging demographics problem, contracting labor force, and soon to be contracting population. Now juggle all of that with their debt load, before they get rich/affluent at the median, and before they even build out a meaningful social safety net for the bottom billion people (social safety nets & welfare policies being the usual primary cause of large debt accumulation in the developed world).
- zjaffee 8y agoExcept China can't be measured in the same terms that a Western economy can be. The US can't just decide to forget all of it's debt, in the way China can given they have a command economy with the government playing a role in every business. Communist parties have nationalized entire economies in the past, and to suggest they won't do the same again is ignoring many of the actions that Xi Jinping has taken to bring back Marxist thought into the country. Should the CCP decide to reset all debt, they could likely get away with it through measures that insure a lack of debt collection doesn't cause a dominoeing effect.
- jhabdas 8y agoCommunism... what's that? They're a Democratic Republic with a Constitution and a Bill of Rights.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoOn paper, yes. In practice, no. A one-party "democratic republic" is not a democratic republic. A country that's doing what China is doing in Xinjiang to the Uighurs isn't a country with a bill of rights that matters. I'll agree that China is not at the moment particularly communist/marxist. That doesn't make them a democracy.
- amphibian87 8y agoA democratic republic with a president for life? They're communist.
- trepanne 8y ago> They're a Democratic Republic with a Constitution and a Bill of Rights. You seem to be unaware of the role of the Communist Party in Chinese government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_China Xi is currently consolidating power into more of a straight dictatorship, though. It's pretty interesting to watch.
- adventured 8y agoChina can and should be measured by the same terms as Western economies, they're bound by the same constraints. There's nothing literally magical about China and their government isn't omnipotent, no more than the Soviets were. The primary debt problem in the US, is the public debt of the US Government. The US Govt can decide to 'forget' their debt, they're going to use inflation to do it over time (that is, quantitative easing, debt monetization). US Government debt will increasingly be held internally as a percentage, as it expands by $700b-$1t per year. There are no external buyers for that much debt and they can't afford the high interest rates it will take to attract that much private capital over time (it'd rapidly swamp the US budget), only the Fed will be able to keep up with it. They'll follow the Japan recipe, holding rates artificially low perpetually to keep debt cheap, while debasing the dollar to stealth default on the debt in order to reduce its real value vs the economy and government finances. That's how Western nations forget their debts.