5 ms·
"By obligating handset makers to load the free apps along with the Android operating system, regulators said Google had boxed out competitors." This is some sl
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
"By obligating handset makers to load the free apps along with the Android operating system, regulators said Google had boxed out competitors."
This is some sloppy reporting. The 'Android operating system' is licensed under the Apache 2.0 licence[0]. Nothing in that licence obligates handset manufacturers to 'load the free apps'.
[0] https://source.android.com/setup/start/licenses https://source.android.com/setup/start/licenses
- dannyr 8y agoGoogle makes separate agreements with device manufacturers. That's what the article is referring too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dahfizz 8y agoCan you expand on this? There is nothing stopping a manufacturer from putting "pure" android on their devices. The reason they freely choose to bundle G apps is because the G apps enhance the final product.
- kryptiskt 8y agoThey ship Google apps because they must do so to be able to put in Google Play. That's not freely chosen.
- dahfizz 8y agoBut they don't need Google Play Services either. They choose to bundle it in because it makes their phones better.
- hadrien01 8y agoThey choose to bundle Google Play. Because if you don't have it (with Facebook, and Twitter, and Snapchat, and other essential apps for many people), your device won't sell. But to get the Google Play store, you also need to include Google Play services, Google Play Music, YouTube, Chrome, Google Maps, Location Services, Google Keep, Google Docs, other stores (Movies, NewsStand, Books), etc. This ruling finally forces Google to decouple at least some of its apps from the package, and to sell some devices (but not all of them) with or without Google apps.
- freeone3000 8y agoYou need Google Play Services if you want to run the average app. There is no difference, in the consumer's mind, between Play Services and Android. Deliberately, on the part of Google - new geo services are Play Services only, for instance.
- Markoff 8y agonot really, i have phone full of apps without gapps and i am fine - WhatsApp, signal, brave, nine, spotify, boost for Reddit... all work fine, the issue are really only apps depending on maps like Uber
- bubblethink 8y agoUber has other dependencies on play services beyond the location api. The Uber mobile site works though.
- GeekyBear 8y agoGiven that modern Android applications require access to API's that are only installed with Google Play Services, it hardly seems optional.
- ce4 8y agoYou have to become a member of the open handset alliance to ship Google Play. By becoming a member of the OHA you sign a contract with Google that ties you to A) not selling non OHA approved Android devices B) installing Apps X,Y,Z Amazon is one of the few Companies thats not a member of the OHA and can ship their own modified FireOS.
- dahfizz 8y agoBut nobody is forcing manufacturers to bundle in Google Play. Nothing at all is stopping manufacturers from shipping "pure" android. They freely choose to enter into these agreements because being able to bundle Google Play makes their phones a better product.
- ce4 8y agoNobody is forcing you to sell Andtoid devices either. If you do, you want to have access to the Google ecosystem. You will fail without PlayStore access. See Amazon phones.
- simion314 8y agoBecause more and more apps depend on Google play, It is like you can buy and install windows on your machine, MS does not force you to install vc++,directx or .NET but most of the apps will depend on this so you are kinda forced to install those.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoSaying it's a "free choice" when you can't have a successful phone in the US and Europe without it is dubious at best.
- kodablah 8y ago> you can't have a successful phone in the US and Europe without it I'm not convinced this is the case. Depends on definitions of successful. The absence of competition is not the same as the absence of the ability to compete, and regulating the latter under that assumption improperly assumes it will fix the former. There is more to success than the playing field.
- hrktb 8y agoGoogle has a defacto monopoly on android app delivery, and a majority of apps use their framework and it’s using that dominant position to force the other Google services on the maker. Does it make more sense put this way ?
- simion314 8y agoI want to add that they moved a lot of stuff from the open source Android into the closed source Google play, so many apps depend on Google play. so not only you need a third party "store" you need to re implement the APIs that the apps depend.1
- drewmol 8y agoexpanding on that, from microG's site: "While the core operating system is still released as part of the Android Open Source Project, the majority of core apps are not. It gets worse: More and more libraries and APIs are only available on phones that run various Google apps pre-installed, effectively locking third-party apps to the Google ecosystem. For these reasons Android is described as being a “look but don’t touch” kind of open." MicroG is a project aimed at developing open source alternatives to those android components. https://microg.org/ https://microg.org/
- Someone1234 8y agoThe article is correct, you're mistaken. While AOSP is licensed under Apache 2.0, in order to bundle the Play Store and associated Google services you have to agree to MADA[0]. No major manufacturer, except Amazon, ships an AOSP variant without Google's Services. Arguably many of Android's core APIs now flow through Play Store Services (e.g. Location Services). [0] PDF warning: http://www.benedelman.org/docs/htc-mada.pdf http://www.benedelman.org/docs/htc-mada.pdf
- bdcs 8y ago>No major manufacturer, except Amazon, ships an AOSP variant without Google's Services. In Europe and the US. Worldwide, the majority do (cf. Xiaomi)
- rahimnathwani 8y agoIIRC, it's only the phones Xiaomi sells in China that come without Google Services. I might be wrong.
- solarkraft 8y agoI believe you're correct. China has almost no Google presence.
- llampx 8y agoIts related to the laws and regulations there. Once Google makes nice with the Xiao Jinping, the same OHA restrictions will apply to Xiaomi, Huawei etc.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoIf you buy a Xiaomi phone in Europe it comes with the global ROM which has all the Google stuff.
- jjeaff 8y agoThe play store is not the same thing as the Android operating system.
- kryptiskt 8y agoAndroid as shipped is way bigger than AOSP. A lot of functionality only exists in Google Play Services nowadays.
- gandalfian 8y agoReading the article if you want Google play you have to include the apps too. The idea is if you now pay for the play app then you no longer have to bundle the others. So you could sell a phone with Google play and the opera browser that defaulted to the bing search engine. I agree that the headline confused this.
- neolefty 8y agoThat sounds smart, as a first step towards making room for competition. "Which Android experience do you want? Google, Tencent, Baidu, Microsoft, or EFF?"
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"Nothing in that licence obligates handset manufacturers to 'load the free apps'." The Play Store is not included in that license. And given the stranglehold it has on the app distribution scene in the US and Europe, shipping a phone without it is suicide.