9 ms·
So, some biology 101: The lymphatic system is powered in part by the circulatory system and in part by physical activity (aka "exercise"). Fluid from the blood
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
So, some biology 101:
The lymphatic system is powered in part by the circulatory system and in part by physical activity (aka "exercise"). Fluid from the blood, minus certain blood products, goes out into the tissues and becomes interstitial fluid. Muscle action dramatically increases the rate at which it gets returned from the tissues to the blood.
This is the mechanism by which the body cleans up most tissues. Except for the brain. The brain has a separate mechanism whereby lymphatic fluid (aka interstitial fluid) gets flushed out, taking wastes with it, only during sleep. This is a primary function of sleep.
Personal firsthand experience suggests that exercise is frequently followed by napping precisely because these are separate systems. Exercise may start this process by flushing out other tissues, but your brain won't get flushed of wastes until you sleep.
If you want to benefit from this research, you will need to have good sleep hygiene in addition to exercising. From what I gather, aerobic exercise is likely to do more good from the perspective of powering the lymphatic system than weight lifting.
- jfaucett 8y ago> From what I gather, aerobic exercise... That was my impression as well after doing some research in this area a while back. Although I looked specifically at longevity and cardiovascular studies there was a peak benefit at about 2hrs per week after which virtually no more benefits were observed.
- copperx 8y ago2 hrs a week of intensive aerobic exercise sounds like an easy to remember target if that's what research shows.
- taeric 8y agoWhat constitutes "intensive"? I finally got a heart monitor. So far, I get into "zone 4" for a few minutes every day. Zone 5? Not so much...
- copperx 8y agoPersonally, I define vigorous exercise when I hit 95% of my maximum heart rate (220-age) non-stop for 30 minutes. 100% is doable but a bit too extreme. I think I've seen similar definitions in health literature.
- lostapathy 8y agoWorth noting that the various "max heart rate formulas" are just guidelines. Plenty of people routinely hit above their predicted rate, and plenty of people cannot get there.
- taeric 8y agoYeah, the "based on age" makes it tough. I would love for there to be something more prescriptive. That said, I suspect just trying already puts me in a decent position.
- bitexploder 8y agoI am pretty sure that is very extreme and 70-80% of MHR is fine to consider "vigorous", especially for someone who is untrained.
- strig 8y agoMayo clinic says 70-85% of your max heart rate [1] counts as "vigorous". Not sure what the zones on your monitor are set at. [1]: https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/fitness/in-depth/exercise-intensity/art-20046887 https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/fitness/in-dept...
- taeric 8y agoThat would mean heart rate around 126 to 153 for me, evidently. Which, actually sounds low. Which I guess is good for me? :) I was using "zones" per the Strava app lingo. I rarely make zone 5, which would be 174+ heart rate. I spend a fair bit of time in the 160 range, though.
- wild_preference 8y agoI wouldn't stop at two hours just because there's no additional benefit that manifested in a study on some super-specific outcome. You probably care about other benefits as well.
- copperx 8y agoSure. But there are also risks associated with exercise; you want to minimize those too.
- 09bjb 8y agoWeight training tends to be moderately cardiovascular. Not an out-and-out replacement for cardio, but your heart will be pumping hard at higher weights/reps. Same thing for a long session in a hot sauna. Just throwing some nearly-as-good alternatives out there for people who hate treadmills.
- soperj 8y agoI hate treadmills, but going for a bike ride or a walk is awesome. I don't know why people go to the gym to run...
- tdesilva 8y agoSometimes the weather blows.
- wild_preference 8y agoProbably for the same reason people go to the gym to exercise yet don't do any pushups at home: we pathologically avoid exercise, so we often must compartmentalize it away from our life to actually do it.
- makemoniesonlin 8y agoYou can watch TV on a treadmill, something that is much harder (and more dangerous) while running outside.
- ntlk 8y agoBecause it’s easy to set targets and measure them while in the gym, but it’s not easy to fit that kind of exercise into the day to day. People often live too close to work for the bike ride to really be considered exercise, or too far, where they couldn’t feasibly fit it into their day. I get it, doing exercise for free seems like a no-brainier, but not everyone’s life and exercise needs converge neatly to make it easy.
- photojosh 8y ago> easy to set targets and measure them while in the gym The cost of the gym will pay for a GPS watch and heart-rate monitor pretty quickly. But I understand that some places might be too high density or unsafe to run, or the weather is too hostile. I'm fortunate enough to live 10km from work, so I switch up between running AND riding the distance.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rhombocombus 8y agoNot to mention the fact that good sleep hygiene provides immediate payoffs as well. The single best thing I have done for my health was giving myself the gift of a regular sleep schedule and sticking to it. I perform better in every aspect of my life. Even if I feel like I have less time than I did before, I feel much better every day than I did when I was getting < 7 hours of sleep every day.
- Ensorceled 8y agoInterestingly, I feel I have more time that I did before, mostly because I'm mentally alert and more productive for more hours.
- EminIsrafil 8y agoI couldn't agree more. I work a lot and long hours, but I almost always insist on getting 7 hours of sleep a day.
- bulldoa 8y agoI am curious, what is consider good sleep hygiene academic wise.
- flocial 8y agoIn a nutshell setting aside 8 hours, going to sleep and waking at the same time even on weekends and holidays, refrain from stimulants and depressants 8 hours before bed. Recommended reading: Why We Sleep
- dralley 8y agoHear that Elon?
- rsync 8y ago"This is the mechanism by which the body cleans up most tissues. Except for the brain. The brain has a separate mechanism whereby lymphatic fluid (aka interstitial fluid) gets flushed out, taking wastes with it, only during sleep." I've been thinking about this myself and I theorize that this all comes back, full circle, to your heart. That is, both bodily and brain lymphatic fluid flushing mechanisms are driven by circulation - and the more efficient and powerful your blood circulation is, the more efficient and cleansing your lymphatic flushing will be. And thus, your brains lymphatic flushing, while not directly driven by exercise, still benefits greatly from exercise due to the improvement in total circulation.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI think circulatory health and blood health are hugely important, for a lot of things, for a long list of reasons. I also think total load on the system matters. If your system has a backlog of built up wastes generally, that backlog is going to be a barrier to efficiency in any particular system.
- agumonkey 8y agoNote long ago someone listed some papers about the relationship between exercise and circadian rhythm : https://www.reddit.com/r/workout/comments/9n6f6p/the_greatest_time_to_exercise/e7q6t22/ https://www.reddit.com/r/workout/comments/9n6f6p/the_greates... it might be related to your comment too
- cimmanom 8y agoThank you for explaining this - I learned something today!
- cma 8y agoBio 101 after 2015 got an update. Researchers found out about lymphatic vessels in the brain: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/lymphatic-vessels-discovered-central-nervous-system https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/lymphat...
- mohammedbin 8y agoThis is something very new to me, thank you! One question- what is it specifically about sleep? Have we figured that out yet? And when you say "only", you mean "only" or you mean 99.9% of time?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anonu 8y ago> aerobic exercise is likely to do more good from the perspective of powering the lymphatic system than weight lifting. This is conjecture? I do hope its true though! A frequent debate I have with a friend is whether weight-lifting or running has better effects. He claims 1 hour of weight-lifting raises your metabolism by many multiples vs more aerobic exercise. Its always a bit hard to have these debates though since we are mostly armed with anecdotes and not facts. I suspect the answer is always moderation - somewhere in between.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm fairly certain it's true. But that knowledge comes from 17+ years of firsthand experience (aka "anecdata") and reading (where I may not be able to cite my source anymore because I read it eons ago for personal reasons, not to try to win an internet debate). So I qualified it in hopes of keeping people off my back about citations etc. So if you need citations for some reason, you will need to find them on your own. You might start with googling info about the benefits of walking and sources on how the lymphatic system works.