9 ms·
Brutalist Architecture Masterpieces (2016)
- YorkshireSeason 8y agoSummary: The article doesn't really answer the question why the buildings in question are masterpieces, or why they should be reconsidered. Likewise, it doesn't engage in a meaningful sense with the question why brutalism is so widely disliked. Instead 22 photos are presented, over half of which are not of buildings, but of detail (e.g. a door handle, or grafitti).
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoSo generic listicle image gallery on a generic content farm?
- expathacker 8y agoWhat's more interesting to me, is why HN is so attracted to Brutalism? Is it a sense of minimalist aesthetic, an expectation of structural integrity, the economics of minimalism, a detachment from previous architectural genres, or perhaps an affinity for the writings of Ayn Rand (whose characters espouse the virtues of Brutalism, and whose book, "The Fountainhead" was about a brutalist architect). I spend a lot of time exploring and studying music in former Yugoslav countries, and while I find the Brutalism fascinating in it's relationship to Soviet/Yugoslav poverty & austerity, beauty is not a word I would ever use positively in the same sentence.
- YorkshireSeason 8y agoI can think of three main reasons for this. (A) It's a form or contrarianism, in that it's an negation of mainstream preference, hence unusual. Even better, this negation of mainstream preference isn't really threatening anybody, hence good way of attracting mainstream attention. (B) Brutalism is often associated with left-wing / communist large-scale social engineering, and the left reflexively celebrates anything done by the left. (Aside, the association of brutalism with the left is historically quite false, e.g. people like Le Corbusier didn't meet a dictator he didn't like.) So where brutalism is celebrated by somebody who's explicitly and self-consciously political, it's a Gramscian hegemonic strategy [1]. An example of such a writer is Owen Hatherley [2]. (C) Cities with a lot of brutalist architecture, prevalent in the former Soviet block, use it to market themselves are tourist destinations. This ties in with (A), for why would you go and visit a city unless it had something unusual to offer, something Instagrammable, something to talk about when you are back? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_hegemony https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_hegemony [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Owen_Hatherley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Owen_Hatherley
- beaconstudios 8y agoI think brutalism is more generally associated with authoritarianism, including use in modern government buildings. I think free people choose to incorporate aesthetics into their buildings where bureaucrats prefer utilitarian functional designs because they don't have to live with them or attempt to justify the value of aesthetics.
- walrus01 8y agoFBI HQ , Boston city hall, are two good examples.
- krapp 8y agoThe aggressively dehumanizing aesthetic does seem to express the... brutality of the more fascistic interpretations of collectivism quite well. These buildings all seem to come from a dystopian future.
- beaconstudios 8y agothe design reflects the mentality of the designer. Brutalism is totally utilitarian and reflects the perspective of occupant as unit on a spreadsheet. It's the ultimate expression of "you are a number, not a person".
- walrus01 8y agoIf you look at how much a condo in Montreal's habitat 67 is selling for now, they're certainly not for the common "worker". North of $900k.
- jhbadger 8y agoTrue. But that's because it's the only example of the style and people like it (even many people who generally dislike Brutalism think habitat 67 is nice). The original idea was that it was going to be a prototype for future housing projects but that never happened.
- 8y ago
- aikah 8y agoThe following is strictly my opinion. Misplaced romanticism. AFAIK historically Americans didn't park their poor people or immigrant workers into these huge brutalist apartment complexes like in Europe, or if they did it is somehow a new phenomenon. And I can assure you it's the same in western Europe. Not a lot of people value that architectural style given what it represents: a lot of political and social failure that carries so much shame and embarrassment we are trying to remove any trace of it.
- punchclockhero 8y agoBulgarian here, Randian types around here prefer interbellum modernist architecture to the full blown Brutalism. As for the more extreme postwar architecture, it feels quite homey to me. Although I like it best when it's subverted by the inhabitants, humans living and leaving their mark, think flowers growing in a concrete crack.
- coldtea 8y ago>What's more interesting to me, is why HN is so attracted to Brutalism? It's just a term that got into fame (from a brutalist web design trend and manifesto) recently (a few years ago), and as thus it's in our mid-term memories from our web surfing, so folks on HN periodically rediscover it and post links about it here. No special attraction to Brutalism.
- ablation 8y agoWhat a really unpleasant website to use. Horrible slideshow functionality, interstitial adverts breaking screen flow, rise-up article suggestions. Ugh.
- jmkd 8y agoDespite a strong interest in Brutalism I couldn't make it through because of all this
- John_KZ 8y agoSame. I tried to mess with the grid in dev tools in a last attempt to make the damn carousel resize appropriately but to no avail.
- gnode 8y agoFittingly, if it were intentional it might deserve a place in: http://brutalistwebsites.com/ http://brutalistwebsites.com/
- lunias 8y agoIf I click next on a slideshow and anything happens other than progression to the next slide then I click the 'x' on the tab. Now if only everyone did that; then something might change. Maybe. Probably not.
- tw1010 8y agoBlindly hating brutalism is just as mimetic as blindly loving it.
- Nursie 8y agoA large number of the brutalist housing developments in the UK turned into hellholes. Robin Hood Gardens was a famous one, but most of them look grim, were grim and dark places to live, placed a shadow over the landscape and the lives of the people there. This is not to say that some brutalist architecture can't rise above that. But the major works by the major architects behind the movement often turned out to fail miserably at their stated purposes, putting the lie to the form-as-function ethos. This tends to be blamed on the lack of 'proper' maintenance, or the people just not grokking it properly. What we in the UK are left with in the main is ugly grey-brown hulks that scream poverty, deprivation, violence and depression.
- IshKebab 8y agoI don't think anyone blindly hates it. I mean... use your eyes! It's easy to see what people hate about it. It's ugly. Simple as that. The very best examples rise to "ok that's an interesting design" but they're still undeniably ugly. The Barbican is a very interesting design, but anyone who has actually been there would agree that it is ugly. Contrast them with something like a modern glass skyscrapers (e.g. the walky talky). They may be rather bland and boring but I don't think many people would say they are ugly.
- whywhywhywhy 8y ago> The Barbican is a very interesting design, but anyone who has actually been there would agree that it is ugly I find it one of the most beautiful and peaceful places in London. Some of us actually like these sort of forms and concrete as a material. > walky talky I find that thing grotesque, it's like a bad joke on the London skyline. Some skyscrapers are nice like 30 St Mary Axe but when they're done bad the fact they're made of glass doesn't make them any more attractive. In the end its all completely subjective.
- 8y ago
- rtpg 8y ago> Proponents praised its explicit functionality If it were about functionality you wouldn’t build massive structures at weird angles like the Wotruba Church. You wouldn’t build physics-defying overhangs to compensate your wanting for a nonexistant first floor like the Giesel library. There’s no functional basis for the design of the buildings outlined here. Only some superficial notion of functionalism because of the revealing of the underlying structure. Meanwhile, so many creators of brutalist structures are on the record for hating humans for messing with their grand designs. The world would be a better place without this blight masquerading as some purity of design.
- YorkshireSeason 8y agofunctionality Functionality has multiple dimensions. Often brutalist buildings were rather functional on a micro level (e.g. central heating, indoor toilet etc) which was usually better than what they replaced. But on a macro level they were often terrible, e.g. the extreme focus on being car friendly (e.g. you had to cross an 8-lane motorway to meet your frriend in the neighbouring building). The former has nothing to do with brutalist architecture and is now available for all styles of architecture. The latter was a crazy mistake.
- netcan 8y agoBrutalism (and modernism in general) was/is a fundamentalist way of thinking. They wanted buildings to embody principles, that could be rationally justified. Generally speaking, fundamentalism is usually a bad word. We use it when people seem to view the world through a narrow framework, and can't even engage with ideas, facts or truths from outside that framework. We tend to think of authorotarian religions, strict political doctrines and such. But... there are other examples of fundamentalism, that we call out more rarely. Science, for examaple, is very fundamentalist. It is, after all, a narrow framework for determining truth that ignores anything which can't fit into it's framework. Anyway.... the modernist movement(s) failed, in terms of proving it's principles but it did have some significant influence. Personally, I think the biggest reason was economics. Architects (especially the more ideological types) often hate having commercial decisions impact their work in any way. Ultimately, I don't think you can (philosophically) have a truly rational "theory of buildings" that ignore economics. Economy of space, materials, labour... money. Still... I think there's some value in purity, embodying ideas as fully as we can. Not everything that fails is a failure. Imagine a town that's fundamentally democratic. It probably won't work, but we need someone to try it so that we can learn.
- walrus01 8y agoIf you're in the Vancouver area there are two noteworthy brutalist examples. One is the MacMillan Bloedel building: https://www.google.ca/search?q=macblo+building+vancouver&oq=macblo+buil&aqs=chrome.1.69i57j0l2.3584j0j7&sourceid=chrome-mobile&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.ca/search?q=macblo+building+vancouver&oq=... The macblo building is also CGIed into the New York City Nazi party HQ in Amazon's adaptation of The Man in the High Castle. The other is pretty much the entire SFU campus.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoAnyone who studied CS at Edinburgh University grew fond of Brutalist Architecture through repeated exposure to this monstrosity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appleton_Tower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appleton_Tower
- fergie 8y agoMade all the more jarring by the general Harry Potterness of the surrounding city.
- ilamont 8y agoBoston City Hall is not only ugly on the outside, it's ugly on the inside. For one of the meeting areas (city council, I believe) they have this wooden furniture and some tapestries and old paintings on the concrete walls, but it can't make that cold space warm. Outside, Government Center plaza channels the wind coming off the nearby harbor. It's also the site of one of the most infamous images from the 1970s bussing crisis (https://www.npr.org/2016/09/18/494442131/life-after-iconic-photo-todays-parallels-of-american-flags-role-in-racial-protes https://www.npr.org/2016/09/18/494442131/life-after-iconic-p...) which tainted that space early in its existence.
- xefer 8y agoI heartily agree with this statement. I had a business meeting in there years ago and it was the first time I had ever really been inside. I couldn't believe how miserable and depressing the place was. There's always a discussion going on about what to do with Government Center and City Hall. To me the best thing to do would be to admit the entire enterprise was a tragic mistake, and restore the original street layout. I'm not suggesting they restore the old look - sadly that's lost forever, but at least give the place some actual street life. If the City Hall building really must be saved, then deconstruct it instead of just demolishing it, and rebuild it out in some industrial park in the suburbs where it would blend in with its natural environment.
- thrower123 8y agoIt's a profoundly ugly building. The whole hulking slabs of inevitably discolored and gross-looking concrete look is really not good for a government building; it just looks seedy and corrupt and authoritarian. It gives off too many dystopian vibes, and makes me think of the police station in Mad Max or City 17 from HL2. Particularly in Boston, which has its own style and so many beautiful old buildings.
- paleotrope 8y agoIt's even more evocative of a totalitarian state with the giant face of John Collins on the side of the building.
- fredley 8y agoThe architectural school it's trendy to hate at the moment is Façadism[1], whereby the façade of an older building is preserved, the main structure demolished behind it and a modern building built, eventually connecting with the façade so that the new building is 'invisible'. It's trendy to hate because it supresses opportunities for new interesting architecture to preserve older (but not neccessarily interesting or even good) façades, simply to prevent people moaning about ugly new buildings. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facadism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facadism
- jefurii 8y agoI'm surprised there was nothing by Tadao Ando on that list. He is a master of smooth supple concrete, and of light and shadow.
- gadders 8y agoToo much of this architecture in London. I wish the South Bank centre and the Barbican would be demolished and re-developed. Fun fact about the Barbican: The central heating is controlled centrally. Tenants get a notification about which day it will be turned on for winter.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoI'm not disturbed by the Barbican as such (it can be argued that it really is a masterpiece), but by the exhibition venues, which, in my opinion are really utter crap. Unfortunately they sometimes run really good exhibitions. Compare that to the Centre Pompidou in Paris [1], on which arguments about the building will probably never cease (personally I think it's brilliant), which went up at about the same time. But it's hard to argue about its quality as an exhibition venue (or rather venues). [1] https://blog.artsper.com/en/a-closer-look/five-facts-about-the-construction-of-the-pompidou-centre/ https://blog.artsper.com/en/a-closer-look/five-facts-about-t...
- gadders 8y agoYeah, I guess the Barbican flats don't look as bad as the theatre bit etc. I prefer the Lloyds building to the Pompidou. Less Fisher-Price colours.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoThe colors are not arbitrary, since they encode functionality. From [1] One of the distinctive features of the Centre Pompidou is the striking presence of colour. Four strong colours – blue, red, yellow and green – clothe the structure and enliven the façade, their use governed by a code laid down by the architects: blue for circulating air (air conditioning) yellow for circulating electricity green for circulating water red for circulating people (escalators and lifts). [1] https://www.centrepompidou.fr/en/The-Centre-Pompidou/The-Building https://www.centrepompidou.fr/en/The-Centre-Pompidou/The-Bui...
- 8y ago
- anonu 8y agoThe website is super non functional similar to the buildings: ads everywhere, side bars that open up as you scroll, popups to subscribe. It's hard to see where the content is. I'm on mobile on my home WiFi. I also run pihole and the website was still a sh*@hole.
- mothsonasloth 8y agoI see your masterpieces and raise you Cumbernauld Shopping Centre in Scotland. https://flic.kr/p/7VgANo https://flic.kr/p/7VgANo This place is horrible!
- scns 8y agoeven though i am an atheist i think the shape of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cologne_Central_Mosque https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cologne_Central_Mosque is beatiful. Don't know if it would qualify as brutalist though.