6 ms·
As the saying goes, hindsight is 20/20. Up until deep into the 21st century were people finally convinced that online retail made sense. Back in the 80s and 9
by colordrops 8y ago
As the saying goes, hindsight is 20/20. Up until deep into the 21st century were people finally convinced that online retail made sense. Back in the 80s and 90s people barely understood the internet let alone the idea of selling things on it.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoThere were some good and bad reasons for this. Remember that when the web launched the idea of encryption, PCI compliance, input sanitization, etc. was all pretty foreign. Your typical web store was vulnerable to a remote execution vulnerability, probably stored all its data (including passwords and credit card numbers) in flat files (unencrypted plain-text) without even using a database (which at least meant it wasn't vulnerable to SQL injection), and didn't use ssl. It took a few years for things to improve to a basic level of security but even then the widespread public perception was that giving your credit card to "the internet" was about one million times worse than walking through a dark alley in the worst part of town while carrying a basket full of all your life savings in cash. Bit by bit things started to change, but it took years.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoThe general public had no conception of any of these things.
- apatters 8y agoMaybe not, but there was certainly a trust issue. At the dawn of ecommerce many people were afraid of using their credit card online -- they didn't know the technical details but it just seemed new and scary.
- bluGill 8y agoWhich should have given sears extra help: they were a known and trusted entity that you could give your credit card to unlike that tiny fly-by-night startup bookstore Amazon. They had everything needed to take advantage of the internet just a few years before: a trusted name, a large catalog, experience in online sales (progigy might have failed, but the experience would have been a big help), and a large distribution network.
- apatters 8y agoI agree. After observing a few generations of these businesses you realize that their shareholders prioritize large, gradually declining revenue streams over new opportunities. That's totally fine and that's why the system needs to be very friendly to new business creation. We don't need Sears to innovate at a time when its shareholders want to retire. We need to give new innovators the space to do their thing.
- wahern 8y agoSSL 3.0 came out in 1996. The entire reason for SSL was to pave the way for online retail and credit card purchases. Everybody understood that no later than 1996. (But earlier considering SSL 2.0 was published 1995.) Gates famously underestimated the web, but Windows 95[1] came with a TCP/IP stack out-of-the-box. That was a rapid and significant about face. While much was unknown in 1993 (Netscape wasn't until 1994), nobody should get a pass for shutting down the Sears Catalog with such potential possibly on the horizon. Especially executives making many millions of dollars for their business acumen. Sears decided to jettison their initiatives at the very moment Wal-Mart overtook them, beating them at their own game. I realize they felt burned by Prodigy, but committing to their existing model was the one and only thing that could ensure their ultimate demise, and that's the path they deliberately took. They stupidly decided to try to regain leadership by racing Wal-Mart to the bottom. [1] Or perhaps an immediate succeeding bug fix release? I can't remember as I had gone from Windows 3.11 to Linux but I feel like the original Windows 95 lacked a stack.
- colordrops 8y agoIf Bill gates didn't get it, how would an executive from a brick and mortar get it. Unlike today, the types that created SSL had little to no overlap with traditional MBA types.
- wahern 8y agoSears had Prodigy, so they had the resources to understand the technology and potential going forward. Here's an interesting Wire article from 1993: https://www.wired.com/1993/06/prodigy/ https://www.wired.com/1993/06/prodigy/ Long story short, their attempt to push online shopping on Prodigy was proving a failure. That kind of cuts both ways because that shows they did understand the technological potential. Also, by 1993 it was becoming clear to many people that web advertising was going to be huge. (I remember wanting to get into BBS advertising at that time, before I realized the Internet existed, coincidentally about a year or two before Link Exchange was invented.) The Sears Catalog was first and foremost an advertising platform. Like AOL, Prodigy failed because it was a walled garden. But I don't think walled gardens were ever considered greats platforms for advertising to the exclusion of wider potential markets. So Sears could have realized the fatal flaw in Prodigy and the future potential on the web for advertising, if not for shopping.
- paulie_a 8y ago>Your typical web store was vulnerable to a remote execution vulnerability Not much has changed honestly.
- at-fates-hands 8y ago> Back in the 80s and 90s people barely understood the internet let alone the idea of selling things on it. Ironic was the movie "The Net" in 1995 with Sandra Bullock. The opening scene of her ordering pizza online was such a leap of faith for people at the time. The other interesting thing is how the movie basically predicted where we are now with all of our personal information online.
- macintux 8y ago> The opening scene of her ordering pizza online was such a leap of faith for people at the time. In 1994, when the Internet was opening to commercial use, someone gave a demo at my university of a pizza ordering system. I thought to myself it would never work, because all the stores would need to be wired up, and how was that going to happen? I've been wrong about technology far, far more often than not.
- _mdpn 8y agoThe stores wouldn't even need to be wired up to the Internet. All they would need is a call center to dispatch pizza orders to the stores or a fax machine if they wanted to dispatch orders without a voice call, both mature, widely deployed tech at the time.
- macintux 8y agoYep, I later realized that flaw in my skepticism. In fact I had done some delivery from a store that used a call center, so it should have been obvious.
- colordrops 8y agoNice point. I recall vividly going to see The Net with a bunch of other CS students and we all laughed at the absurdity of it all. "Animation and sound on a web page? You've got to be kidding!" Sometimes you are too close to something to see the trend.
- joezydeco 8y agoIs the internet really the key? Sears had telephone ordering for catalog items for decades before the internet. Here's a Sears project to produce the catalog on interactive laserdisc: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptW0-87C6as https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptW0-87C6as It's from 1981.
- colordrops 8y agoYes the internet was the key. Everyone has been taking advantage of new technology to sell products since the dawn of commerce. What made Amazon great was an understanding of how the internet could be exploited.