6 ms·
A Genocide Incited on Facebook, With Posts From Myanmar’s Military
- aptidude187 8y agoInteresting how people were 'outraged' about 1 missing Journalist and flooded HN with articles about how evil the government of Saudi Arabia is ( which I agree with ) , but a more serious crime like genocide leaves HN disinterested. Would this be the same, if the perpetrators and victims were reversed ? I highly doubt it.
- dingdingdang 8y agoUltimately it has to do with how close political ties are maintained. After all it's more concerning if a family member whom you share living space with suddenly becomes unpredictable or violent as opposed to a neighbour 3 houses down the street.
- realusername 8y agoWe had a lot of coverage of the Myanmar genocide facilitated by Facebook and the comments were always very negative against Facebook here. You won't find much sympathy of the company on HN.
- krapp 8y ago>We had a lot of coverage of the Myanmar genocide facilitated by Facebook and the comments were always very negative against Facebook here. Not always. A surprising number of HN commenters in those threads supported both Facebook and the genocide. Either way, HN was anything but disinterested.
- doktrin 8y ago> A surprising number of HN commenters in those threads supported both Facebook and the genocide. I'm skeptical that there actually were non-grey comments in support of the genocide
- krapp 8y agoEvery one of them probably wound up being downvoted and flagged, but that doesn't require a majority of users. My point is that the sentiment was still expressed, so it exists as a facet of HN culture. You won't find many threads where Islam, Muslims or immigrants are mentioned in which at least some anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant bias doesn't appear, including this one.
- jackvalentine 8y agoWhich specific comments in this thread as it stands indicate anti-muslim or anti-immigrant bias? Edit: what did saana say that got them flagged out? Is this the one?
- bilbo0s 8y agoThe Saana comment was pretty far out there. Yes. It's safe to say that comment had anti-muslim, anti-immigrant, anti-minority bias. There are many people like that in the world though. It's unreasonable to require them to not exist before we discuss topics like this. In fact, in a very real way, they are the entire reason we find ourselves needing to discuss topics like this.
- lostlogin 8y agoWhat a weird what-about-ism. There have been a few other atrocities too, why are you not mentioning them?
- DyslexicAtheist 8y ago"Tech execs will never come to a full realization of their platforms' roles in genocide and the rise in authoritarianism, in part because doing it would require an overwhelmingly traumatic personal reckoning." -- https://twitter.com/oneunderscore__/status/1051856327952269312 https://twitter.com/oneunderscore__/status/10518563279522693...
- dustfinger 8y agoArticles about politics are off-topic [1] on HN. Neither article should have made the front page nor aroused much attention. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- escape_goat 8y agoThe manipulation of social networking platforms such as Facebook by political actors (Myanmar's military) for the purpose of spreading disinformation with clear real-world consequences is patently 'on topic'.
- dustfinger 8y agoYou make a good point so long as that is the focus of the discussion. If on the otherhand, the discussion spins off into politics which it is already doing, then it is still off-topic because it is arousing off topic discussion.
- escape_goat 8y agoThis thread of conversation is more exactly and explicitly off-topic than conversations about 'politics', however.
- saana 8y agoAn idle observation: all around the world, nobody seems to like Muslims. Take from that what you will.
- RobertoG 8y agoAll around the world, nobody seems to like minorities, take from that what kind of animal humans are. Some people even go out of his way to criticize the victims of a genocide in a public forum about technology.
- saana 8y ago>All around the world, nobody seems to like minorities, That's an even better observation. Maybe the problem is the obsession some people seem to have with shoving minorities down everybody's throats.
- wccrawford 8y agoThey also don't seem to like Americans. There are tons of other things you can pick out that people don't like, for various reasons, too. None of it justifies prejudice.
- truculent 8y agowhat the fuck
- pc86 8y agoJust downvote/flag and move on, this type of comment does not belong here.
- Const-me 8y agoRussians do similar stuff, the most famous case is probably this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crucified_Boy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crucified_Boy They incited war this way, still ongoing.
- bilbo0s 8y agoSerious question. Why is there so much "whataboutism" whenever anyone brings up these issues? Sure Russia has rights violations. China has censorship and Uighurs. The US has all kinds of toddlers in internment camps. Etc etc etc. Lots of bad things happening in lots of other places. But right now we're talking about the number they're doing on the Rohingya. Sheez. If you want to talk about Russia, or Brazilian death squads, or immigrant toddlers, or whatever submit a link and we can talk about it.
- grecy 8y agoYou question is valid, ignore the downvotes. I think it comes about as a way for people to "explain away" or "brush off" things that happen in our modern world that we are just too lazy/busy/preoccupied or otherwise can't be bothered to fix. It doesn't really matter what the thing that happens is, someone will always chime in with "yeah, that's just like when xyz happened" - which is a completely useless thing to say, but I think it helps people feel better that the world is not utter chaos, and things are not entirely isolated or have no precedent. Of course, as you say, it would be much more productive to spend time trying to solve or eliminate said things, but gossip and media and reality TV aren't about that.
- toyg 8y agoNo, it’s that human rights have long been used as instruments of aggressive foreign policy by some countries; so now, when issues are raised, there is an instinctive reaction from some quarters that basically means “oh no, you will not use that to bully Country X, because you are no saint either”. It’s the diplomatic equivalent of “Why do you see the speck in your brother’s eye, but fail to see the beam of wood in your own?”
- 8y ago
- joonaa 8y agoI don't get how Mark can live with the monster he has created. He made billions from this, why doesn't he retire and move to a desert island with his wealth. From there he can start to work on an open protocol alternative to FB.
- bilbo0s 8y agoEven if he did, Facebook doesn't go away. It's here to stay now. If you're dining with Satan, you can't decline dessert. You have to eat everything Satan prepares for the evening. You can try to run away, but I'm not sure you would get very far.
- joonaa 8y agoMaybe that's the case for him, but I'm of the oppinion that open protocols will win in the end. You often hear about the network effect of social netorks, however it is important to remember that FB is a subset of the greater network that is the Internet, which is built on open protocols.
- bilbo0s 8y agoI don't think you're understanding. Let's suppose that you had open protocols. How would that stop the spread of false and incendiary information about the Rohingya in this case? I mean, these people just happen to use Facebook to spread that information because Facebook is available. Who's to say they wouldn't just use the open protocol servers to spread the information if Facebook had not been available? This sort of thing is simply a consequence of being able to spread information. So Zuckerberg can run, we hackers can come up with open protocols, and whatever else, but this problem would still exist. This is just my opinion, but I don't think open protocols solve this problem, because this is a human problem at its root. The problem is the people, not really the tools.
- joonaa 8y agoI agree that is't a human (moral) problem at it's root, but the problem may be aggravated by the current technical solution.
- pjc50 8y agoAs in previous threads on this, I'd like to remind people of the role of radio stations in the Rwandan genocide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9vision_Libre_des_Mille_Collines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9vision_Lib... These and other tragedies lie in the past. We would do well to look for the warning signs of these in the future: what media organisations are publishing propaganda about ethnic minorities? What incitement to and tacit endorsement of violence is currently being broadcast or circulated on Facebook and other places?
- sehugg 8y agoNot just endorsement of violence, but organizing it: https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2018/08/02/facebooks-fight-club-how-proud-boys-use-social-media-platform-vet-their-fighters https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2018/08/02/facebooks-fig...
- sprash 8y agoEverybody who knows anything about the history and teachings of Islam knows that Myanmar's Military does its job namely protecting their own citizens who are mostly peaceful Buddhist from aggressive Muslim invaders. There is no facebook incited genocide. This is laughable concept and the nytimes does not correctly asses the situation at all. Afghanistan was Buddhist before, not anymore. Rich and beautiful cultures, the people of Byzantine or Berbers, all destroyed. Did you ever wonder how the Sphinx lost its nose? Muslims were always the aggressors and dragged all the conquered countries into an eternal dark age without hope for recovery. Myanmar and its culture has a choice. Defend itself or die like the rest. Personally I have zero sympathy with the Rohingya.
- dang 8y agoReligious flamewar will get you banned here. Please never post like this to HN again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bigbluedots 8y agoThe only way to combat propaganda and 'fake news' is for its audience to apply some critical thinking. As far as I'm aware the Internet in Myanmar is not restricted/censored, so people there have every opportunity to check facts - that they do not appear to may be a symptom of Internet access being such a new phenomenon there.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sohex 8y agoWhile Myanmar no longer has a restricted internet enforced via firewall that's a relatively recent development, only having changed in 2011. There isn't official state censorship at this point in time, however there is still a large degree of self-censorship occurring due to concerns over being jailed or otherwise penalized for voicing a dissident opinion online. Freedom House has a more comprehensive report on the state of internet there available here https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2017/myanmar https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2017/myanmar The current state of affairs is such that only those voices that conform to the government's official narrative will be heard and promoted while those that do exercise critical thought can't verbalize it online without fear of violence and intimidation.
- craftyguy 8y ago> that they do not appear to may be a symptom of Internet access being such a new phenomenon there. It would seem that there are many citizens in nations (e.g. US) where internet access is not a new phenomenon do not do this either, so I don't think that is a valid excuse.