10 ms·
This is one of the real values of #metoo. A lot of people just don't know how incredibly common this sort of thing is. Catcalling, harassment, sexual demands fo
by UncleMeat 8y ago
This is one of the real values of #metoo. A lot of people just don't know how incredibly common this sort of thing is. Catcalling, harassment, sexual demands for career advancement, rape. It is all really really widespread and it is very likely that almost every adult woman you know has experience some form of sexual degradation.
- totoglazer 8y agoI think you mean a lot of men just didn't care to realize. Women knew.
- AnarchoYeasty 8y agoThat's not even remotely true. Loads of women think that it only happens to them that it's something they are doing. Other women reporting and coming forward was as much for other victims to know they aren't alone as it was for men to wake up to what's happening.
- admiralEyebrows 8y agoIt makes me wonder how the men who have the focus and discipline to get in to those positions of power have not learned the discipline of controlling their sexual urges. Those that are doing the harassing are at fault of course, but something is also wrong if men are acting on potentially career destroying impulses. Is the education system failing at teaching discipline? or philosophy? I've gone through the public education system in the U.S. and neither were taught to me, I had to seek them out myself. Maybe sexual harassment seminars should be less about defining and identifying sexual harassment and more about the type of person you can become when you stop letting pleasure and impulse define your life.
- rocqua 8y agoIt seems there are a few explanations, with the truth probably being some combination of these. * The harassers genuinely believe they aren't doing something wrong / think their victims want it * The harassers can't control their urges in the moment / over long times * The harassers don't care that they are doing something wrong / think they have the right to do wrong. I'm not sure which is worse. And again, it is probably a mix of the above where cognitive dissonance nudges the harassers into after the fact justifications.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- atoav 8y agoThere is a known relationship between power and sexuality. Many businessmen are in control all day, so in their spare time they like beeing dominated. This is common enough to be a wide spread trope throughout art and literature. But for some it is the other way round. They have to dominate in order to get sexually excited. Then, if you are in a position of power, and you feel there is a seemingly consequence-free¹ area in which to abuse it, many of these otherwise mostly rational and educated men give in to the temptation. It is not that we suddenly have a problem with some men sexualy abusing their positions of power. It is just getting a bit more visible than it was before, now that it has become a topic. This certainly feels like illuminating a dark corner with light, to find it filled with bugs fleeing in all directions. That is why "lets just switch off the light" is not a rational option here. ¹ in legal- and job-related terms that is. These actions still have real consequences for their co-workers and subordinates
- admiralEyebrows 8y agoI agree "Let's just switch off the light" is the opposite direction in which we should be going. How do we get from having men avoid these urges and situations at work (which is what is sort of the standard sexual harassment education) to having men want to better themselves and create a work space free of sexual context. A lot of men I know already do this, but not all of them. And for the ones that somehow missed the "don't give in to your sexual urges because it will make you less than what you can be" part of becoming an adult, looking back at my own education there was very little to actually teach that other than life itself.
- faitswulff 8y agoIt seems more like the rules of the business world would aid and abet the same kinds of people who would commit sexual harassment. There are a lot of parallels between rape culture and business culture: - Never take no for an answer - Don't ask for permission, ask for forgiveness - Break the law as long as you get away with it - The bottom line is about the benefits I can extract from any given situation A quick search will surface evidence that corporations as a whole are psychopathic and that CEOs skew heavily psychopathic (1 out of 5, similar to prison populations, according to a study - though I can't find the original paper).
- ealexhudson 8y ago> something is also wrong if men are acting on potentially career destroying impulses I think the lesson here is that empirically, it's not potentially career destroying - in fact, it's highly likely to have pretty much no consequence. I'm pretty confident once these actions do become at least plausibly career destroying, that men as a whole will find ways of being able to rein it in. "Consent", as an example, is a straightforward concept.
- noxToken 8y ago> It makes me wonder how the men who have the focus and discipline to get in to those positions of power have not learned the discipline of controlling their sexual urges. I have nothing to back this up, but I think it's one of two things. 1.) It's the culture of their day. This is applicable to older CEOs where it was the norm. They never grew out of it, because they never needed to grow out of it. 2.) They're powerful enough that it doesn't matter. Of course, if tens or hundreds of women come forward accusing a CEO of sexual misconduct, then it's going to be a problem. But in the day-to-day, it's only going to be a problem if the culture in the company allows it to be a problem. Either of those cases has nothing to do with the inability to control urges. The problem is that those men are being overly aggressive with their sexual misconduct because they can.
- vnorilo 8y agoI've observed some behavior from older male teachers toward young female students that seemed inappropriate and clearly unpleasant to the recipient from a sideline (male) pov. My belief is that these guys somehow convince themselves that their attentions are welcome. Alcohol seems to help them do it. The same fellows did it again and again, it was often reported, but repercussions were a mild slap on the wrist at best, nothing at worst. I believe this dynamic increases with the position of power (and imbalance).
- dominotw 8y agoThis is like suggesting obesity and inactive lifestyle can be eliminated by "education. That reptile brain can simply be dominated and put in it's place by rational educated part of the brain.
- scythe 8y ago> It makes me wonder how the men who have the focus and discipline to get in to those positions of power have not learned the discipline of controlling their sexual urges. I think there might be (at least) two kinds of discipline: the discipline of doing and the discipline of not-doing. Does getting up early and putting in long hours running a business really use the same mental skills as not throwing your trash on the sidewalk or coming to a complete stop on the white line next to the red octagon? We might call these initiative discipline and reactive discipline: in one case, you go out and find the situation where you're supposed to do something, but in the second, the mountain comes to Muhammad, so to speak.
- pdpi 8y agoOn the contrary, the sort of attitude where you see others as disposable, as means to get what you want, and generally doing anything you think you can get away with, is precisely the sort of profile that rises to the top
- wmeredith 8y agoThe sad answer is these behaviors just aren’t all that high risk, despite what “#himtoo” would have you believe. Take the most extreme form of sexual assault: rape. The best statistics we have(1) say that only 31% of all rape is even reported at all. Out of 1000 rape occurrences 994 (!) times the perpetrator will see ZERO jail time. It’s hard to find equivalent statistics for murder, but compare that to a murder “close” rate of 56% in the US, as reported by the FBI. There are obviously a hundred shades of gray between rape and an unwanted compliment. So if rape is the most extreme, and the most risky, and you have a 70% chance of literally nothing happening and the chance of seeing actual jail time is statistically zero... this whole category of behaviors is definitely not “high risk”. 1. Statistics compiled by the RAINN institute which uses the US Justice Department’s reporting for its main data sources. More info here: https://www.rainn.org/statistics/criminal-justice-system https://www.rainn.org/statistics/criminal-justice-system
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt makes me wonder how the men who have the focus and discipline to get in to those positions of power have not learned the discipline of controlling their sexual urges. I will suggest that a lot of powerful men are only just now in recent years beginning to see women "in their league." It's highly problematic for them to respond to that with propositioning these women, but it's possibly not entirely fair to say they simply haven't learned to control themselves. In some cases, they may control themselves just fine most of the time. Then they meet some very happening lady who blows them away under circumstances where they aren't used to seeing women at all and they find themselves in new territory they aren't entirely prepared for. FWIW, I happen to be a woman. No, this is not an "apologist" position. This is my framing for how to navigate the social/business landscape without stuff blowing up in my face.
- atoav 8y agoMost of my friends are female and something most male persons don't realize, is how incredibly common certain types of behaviour is. The thing is, if somebody gives you inappropriate remarks on your appearance once a year on average it is something completely different, than if this thing happens to you multiple times a week, and sometimes even multiple times a day. If you get robbed once, bad luck. If you get robbed multiple times a month, you will develop your ways of dealing with it.
- jhfhhhf 8y ago"Catcalling, harassment, sexual demands for career advancement, rape" - those are not nearly in the same category. And it is presumably offers of career advancement in exchange for sex, not sexual demands. I'm sorry - I don't approve of sexual harassment, but with all the hysteria, I am still not sure how often women simply consider sexual interest to be harassment. It seems to me sexual interest is a normal aspect of human life. And being attractive also has advantages, that the #metoo crowd never mentions. We don't really know how many women actually benefited from being attractive. Weinstein claimed many women took him up on his offer, after all.
- api 8y ago> I am still not sure how often women simply consider sexual interest to be harassment. In this setting it's at a minimum incredibly unprofessional, especially between people who don't know each other well and are potentially customer/client or investor/investee. Imagine doing this stuff in a sales meeting.
- neom 8y agoI'm curious why they're not all in the same category, what categorization system are we using?
- ianamartin 8y agoIf we're using a system that puts catcalling in the same bucket as actual rape, that's a little bit of a problem. Catcalling is offensive, tasteless, and disgusting, but it's not the same as forcing someone to have sex with you. I support laws against catcalling, or enforcing existing harassment laws to include catcalling. But you really lose me when you try to put saying anything--no matter how offensive or even illegal--in the same bucket as doing physical violence to another person. I think this is where the #metoo movement and other groups that promote women's safety and well-being lose a lot of support from people who would otherwise be in agreement with them. I can go really far supporting laws to protect women from all kinds of awful things. But I can't really stretch reality far enough to say that saying something is the same as raping someone.
- screye 8y agoCertainly was the case for me. I was completely blown away at how often women around me were harassed. I didn't see a reason for #metoo to be as loud as it was, until these stories started coming out. My assumptions about most men having respect for women's basic rights was really misplaced.
- DenisM 8y ago> My assumptions about most men having respect for women's basic rights was really misplaced Are you saying that from most women having been harassed it follows that most men have been harassing women?
- AnarchoYeasty 8y agoWhile that statement isn't necessarily true, I would argue that most men do act inappropriately towards women. The problem is most men don't see what they are doing as wrong. What they consider flirting is often harassment. So most men aren't rapists, most men most likely do act inappropriately towards women.
- TomVDB 8y agoNow that’s a claim for which I would like to see more proof. Because if most men would do this (and most implies: a majority of them), then even the current deluge of reports would be nothing compared to what you’d expect it to be. I’ve have asked female colleagues about this and while they did complain about sexism, it was always isolated cases. Not most men.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoThe current volume of reports is almost certainly a small fraction of the actual occcurrences.
- TomVDB 8y agoWould the volume be much higher than the numbers that are reported by surveys like this one, in which women are asked about it explicitly? If so, why? Of all the respondents, 20% report sexual harassment of some sort. That’s a very high number. There is no reason to doubt its veracity. But if 50%+ of all men were like that, you’d expect this number to be way higher.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoNot to belittle the situation for women, and I'm very well aware that it's worse for them than men, but it's not exclusive to women. It's just incredibly common in general. I've been sexually harassed as a man, and I'm not even a particularly attractive bloke. Obviously it's different, I didn't have to worry about being followed home and pinned down by someone that's a foot taller and 50 lb heavier than me. If someone's being inappropriate with me, I can tell them to fuck off with little fear of repercussions, I don't have to be polite and worry about them retaliating, meanwhile I have a friend who was punched in the face at a nightclub because she rejected some guy's advances.