10 ms·
I continue every month to be more convinced that the fundamental problem is that any platform where anybody, unsolicited, can for free send messages to anybody
by jerf 8y ago
I continue every month to be more convinced that the fundamental problem is that any platform where anybody, unsolicited, can for free send messages to anybody else, will forever have the "thundering hordes of assholes"[1] problem once it hits even modest scale. Having to hire people by the hundreds to "moderate" is desperately trying to salvage a fundamentally unworkable system, not a solution, even before we get into the interesting second-order effects such "solutions" can create, and what it does to the moderators themselves psychologically. You can't build a solution based around A: hoping the assholes just don't show up or B: that you will be smarter or more dedicated than the assholes.
I don't necessarily have a perfect solution all lined up, but just correctly identifying the problem is step one. I've mentally noodled with a number of models. But the thing they have in common is that none of them start with a new user being able to fling whatever they want to whomever they want for free.
[1]: I don't actually consider it a failure of the system if you encounter an asshole every so often. That's life. But when you start a video stream and you end up with so many assholes typing asshole comments so quickly that you literally can't even read them before they scroll away, even if you want to, that's a structural problem, not just a social problem.
- tracker1 8y agoIs the solution more anonymity, or less? Are reputation systems a good idea in general? On the one hand you have google/facebook pushing people to reveal their real names on accounts... on the other you have sites similar to this one where you don't have to reveal much, but rely on karma/reputation a bit more. In the end, it's a matter of dealing with the best and worst of mankind. As sad as it is, bullying didn't start with the internet, and it won't end with it. It sucks to be on the receiving end, and although I, personally, haven't always been the best at dealing with it, people need to learn that skill. The world, despite best optimistic intentions, is not a kind, fair place to be.
- kazinator 8y agoThe solution is to disable communication by default. Nobody can post anything to any feed on anyone's profile, nor send any private message, unless they are in the list of approved users. To get linked, you initiate a the "add me to your group" request. This request is just a flag which asserts "X is interested in linking with Y". It cannot be repeatedly asserted, and no text or images may be attached to it. (If someone wants to harass you with these contact requests, they will have to keep creating new profiles, and fill those profiles themselves with hateful content targeting you.) The system could use Bayesian filtering on profile content to determine which kinds of accounts you don't like linking with.
- marcodave 8y agowhat you propose might work, or it might work against the core purpose of the social network. As far as I know (no Instagram user), Instagram works (for a certain demographic) on the basis that its users are ok with random semi-anonymous strangers liking their photos and following and linking their profile. If you take away or limit that, what are you left with? will your users be content? and more importantly, will advertisers keep spending the same or more money on your platform?
- haldean 8y agoIf you could only comment on posts by mutuals, that would go a long way. I would happily set my profile to "public but only my mutuals can comment".
- tracker1 8y agoI don't think that any such system would work, or gain much traction. It may work for a workplace, where you need to be added to groups, etc... but not for an open system of the world at large. How do you propose to have any conversation, even like this one, if you don't see anyone responding to you, and they in turn don't see you?
- siruncledrew 8y agoI think your sentiment is pretty realistic overall. Unless we as a society start trending towards some kind of dystopian hellscape where every single person has a "worthiness" score and all the assholes who fall below a certain threshold are purged from society, then the sad truth is we are stuck living in world with assholes. Given the unlikelihood this kind of "asshole holocaust" will ever come to fruition, the most we can do is strive to lead exemplary lives and continue to reject the behavior of assholes and instead seek to correct it.
- noobermin 8y agoThis is HN, the glorified peanut gallery, but seriously, what are your ideas? I'm curious to have a discussion about them and see what others think too.
- jerf 8y agoOne is the original weblog model, with either no comments enabled or with some sort of whitelist comment participation. You can write whatever you want, and some asshole over there can write about how stupid you are, and it doesn't have to bother you unless you deliberately visit the asshole. Back before social media, there were cases where there were entire weblogs devoted to replying to literally every post some other weblog made, but nobody cared except the few who deliberately sought that out, because you had to go out of your way to visit. I suppose I should point out explicitly that my goal is not to create a 100% comfortable world in which you never encounter an asshole, but to create something a bit more like the real world where by the time you're an adult and you've found a place for yourself in the world, by and large you probably don't have a problem dealing with lots of people-you-consider-assholes personally. (You may professionally, but that's a different sort of problem.) Even if you maybe have a problem with one or two people in particular, you almost certainly do not set a foot outside your bedroom door and immediately get several thousand people screaming at you at the top of your lungs. But you're going to encounter a few, sure. More on the Reddit model, I outlined something here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16570017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16570017 The observation that it is computationally expensive is true, but I'm not convinced it's intractably so. There the idea is that if some anklebiter starts replying to your every comment, by default you at most see something greyed out or collapsed if you did not have any previous connection to them, and they can't bother you. I think to jumpstart the system you'd always have to have a couple of random comments show up, and some of them may be assholes, but it wouldn't be the case I was describing where you can get this unrelenting torrent of abuse. (I think such a system would have more manipulation resistance, too. $MEDDLER could go to some political forum that works that way, and maybe they could convince a few people or a subcommunity to upvote them, but they wouldn't be able to completely take over an entire topic by sheer mass the way they can on Reddit. You can't get a world where $MEDDLERs don't exist, but you don't have to have a world in which only $MEDDLERs and $MEDDLER-approved accounts exist on your forum.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- erjjones 8y ago> I don't necessarily have a perfect solution all lined up The "metaverse" . Where you can be what you want people to see w/o others knowing what you are. #highfidelity
- gaius 8y agoThe "metaverse" . Where you can be what you want people to see w/o others knowing what you are That is a nice idea but I'm not sure it will work because consider Stack Overflow: most users there are little more than a number and a geometric shape, as far as what others see, and yet they still felt they needed to formalise a code of conduct based on survey results that certain demographics felt unwelcome.
- mwfunk 8y agoI agree, and have always thought that most online communities have baked-in expiration dates based on what I think of as asshole entropy. Over time, such platforms will always tend towards more assholes, as asshole behavior triggers more asshole behavior, and drives away non-assholes. The only question is how long does it take to reach that point. Another way to look at it is, good comments are capable of inspiring more good comments, but low-quality comments always seem to lead to more low-quality comments. So comment quality in general is also subject to entropy in most forums and social networks that I've seen. Some combination of moderation and lacking appeal to general audiences allows specialized forums like HN to reach a steady state, with probably more assholes than desired and fewer good comments than desired, but at least it's not continually hurtling towards collapse.
- russdpale 8y agoAsshole Entropy.. I like that term. You may enjoy this old but very relavent article titles a group is its own worst enemy http://shirky.com/writings/group_enemy.html http://shirky.com/writings/group_enemy.html
- bcOpus 8y agoMaybe the answer would be that such communities should be restricted in their growth in terms of how many they can manage without the “thundering horde” taking over, rather than how many they can sign up.