4 ms·
Given all the animosity between the countries at the moment (Made in America, NAFTA 2, Bombardier, boarder delays, the Saudi fiasco, pending legalization of pot
by sandworm101 8y ago
Given all the animosity between the countries at the moment (Made in America, NAFTA 2, Bombardier, boarder delays, the Saudi fiasco, pending legalization of pot) now is not the best time for the US to urge Canada to impose any new restrictions. Canada laughed the last time the US described it as a national security threat (aluminum/steel tariffs) it will laugh at this one too.
Canada needs improved cellular services and it needs them now. Canada's cell networks are much more regulated than those of the US. They cover vastly larger areas and are much more expensive to access. The insertion of national security politics will only slow progress.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoI see the Chinese mobile market as a serious threat to US cellular markets & phone manufacturers, something USA (with lobbying & special interest money) & its trade war is likely trying to prevent with propaganda campaigns. I would like to see CA laugh this off.
- duxup 8y agoI get the conflict, but that doesn't mean it wouldn't possibly still be in Canada's best interest. Basing the response on school yard type diplomacy would be unwise.
- sandworm101 8y agoCanada's best interests are different than those of the US. Improved Canada-Chinese relations are much more of a priority as Canada looks for new markets. Security takes a back seat to trade as their top trading partner (US) becomes more and more erratic.
- 99052882514569 8y agoIf you think the US is erratic, check out how China bullies its neighbours and always seeks to control the infrastructure of the countries that supply it with raw materials it needs. The way I see it, the US may be erratic, but it's still a country with the rule of law. China is a massive unknown because it's a dictatorship run by competent but unconstrained (and therefore sketchy and unpredictable) group of people. Even worse now that Xi is going to a full single-man dictatorial model.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>If you think the US is erratic, check out how China bullies its neighbours and always seeks to control the infrastructure of the countries that supply it with raw materials it needs. I see you've ignored nearly the entire Middle East and what the USA has done almost everywhere in the world throughout its history.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoUSA doesn't go around giving loans to build infrastructure in countries that have no realistic way of paying them back, then leasing said infrastructure back. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magampura_Mahinda_Rajapaksa_Port https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magampura_Mahinda_Rajapaksa_Po...
- adventured 8y ago> I see you've ignored nearly the entire Middle East and what the USA has done almost everywhere in the world throughout its history. Everywhere in the world throughout its history? That's a pretty amusing statement, given the US barely left its shores for the first 140 years of its history. The US didn't even have a serious standing military until after WW1, and more realistically just before WW2. Demonstrably the US has done dramatically more good in the world than it has ill. In the era of the US superpower, the world has never been better off. It's just as absurd to ignore the vast good the US has been responsible for, as it is to ignore the mistakes it has made.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>Demonstrably the US has done dramatically more good in the world than it has ill. So having killed way more innocent people than Hitler, Stalin, Lenin could've ever imagined, hundreds of years of slave trades & slavery, creating slave trades in Libya now, plenty of illegal wars killing millions (even just since WW1!), dumping chemical weapons and viruses over Canada for testing purposes, the only nuclear detonations on civilians ever. The list goes on and on and on. I see the US as the most evil country that has ever existed, by far. Its good far outweighed by the bad. I think you're ignorant about the realities of US intervention and merciless killing around the world for nearly its entire existence in pursuit of power and capital.
- claydavisss 8y ago> Canada's best interests are different than those of the US. Not really. Canada's economy can be described as trade with the US and some other stuff.
- olliej 8y agoThe problem is that the US government has stated it considers Canada as the enemy. The correct response is for Canada to remove its dependence on the US. The behavior of the current US government basically destroys their “soft power” for a very long time - who will trust treaties with the US when the next admistration can arbitrarily end them? How much of a sweet deal will countries be willing to give the US in treaties anyway? I suspect the current behavior of the us administration is going to have very long term consequences - the biggest being a long term reduction in global influence as countries (like Canada) seek to reduce their dependence. I say this with the assuredness of a random commenter on HN ;)
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> The correct response is for Canada to remove its dependence on the US This would be reckless. Geography dictates the U.S. and Canada will be major trading partners. Population, resource distribution and topography dictate, for the foreseeable future, the U.S. will be the big sister in that relationship. Smarter would be to hang low and wait for fairer weather. > who will trust treaties with the US when the next admistration can arbitrarily end them? I agree. Since "the U.S. has not withdrawn from a trade agreement since 1866" [1], there is disagreement over whether Trump can unilaterally kill NAFTA or if he requires Congressional approval [2][3]. Either way, it's not a good show. [1] https://money.cnn.com/2016/07/06/news/economy/trump-nafta/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2016/07/06/news/economy/trump-nafta/in... [2] https://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/international-affairs/346744-trump-cant-withdraw-from-nafta-without-a-yes-from https://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/international-affairs... [3] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-30/trump-boasts-he-can-kill-nafta-congress-may-think-differently https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-30/trump-boa...
- 8y ago
- make3 8y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 8y agoThen it’s too bad the United States cried wolf and now no one will take them seriously when it comes to real threats.
- otoburb 8y ago>>Canada needs improved cellular services and it needs them now. In what way does Canada require improved cellular service? I'm nodding my head to the other points you've made but this one puzzles me. If you're talking about pricing, then I would agree there given more numerous and more transparent wireless competition in other countries. Canada's mobile networks are generally comparable to advanced (but not cutting edge) cellular networks around the world.
- sandworm101 8y agoYes, in Toronto and Vancouver. But drop a random pin on a map of Canada and it is a different story. There are towns only 50km from downtown Vancouver that lack any reliable cell coverage. I've been involved in a few SAR events, at major tourist spots beside highways, where the lack of cell coverage was a huge issue. Canada's distances also mean that there remain a great many communities without wired internet services. Satellite is very expensive, and increasingly difficult at higher latitudes. Cellular-based broadband is the only realistic option. http://www.comparecellular.com/images/assets/coverage-maps/bell-coverage-map-english.png http://www.comparecellular.com/images/assets/coverage-maps/b... Setting aside the north, take a look at how much of BC lacks any real cell coverage.
- otoburb 8y agoThere's huge demand for cellular-based broadband. I wasn't aware that TELUS' wireless coverage in the Interior was so bad, and slightly surprised that there isn't more negative news coverage when TELUS and Bell tout "national coverage". I'm sure the CRTC's roaming caps[1] will change some of the profitability scenarios per set of cell-sites. I will note that Saskatchewan (through SaskTel) seems to cover the province quite well even outside of Regina and Saskatoon. Re. cellular-based broadband - while there is huge demand in rural regions, the pricing is challenging. Basically, cellular-based "broadband" usually operates at a loss, but at least it's a loss that more carriers are willing to shoulder, in (small) part due to the CRTC's renewed call for action to review "universal broadband service"[2] in 2019. [1] https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2018/2018-99.pdf https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2018/2018-99.pdf [2] https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/internet/internet.htm https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/internet/internet.htm