6 ms·
Blockchain was once about using technology to solve a problem in a new and exciting way. Then people started to make money off of it. Lots of money. Then it bec
by dragontamer 8y ago
Blockchain was once about using technology to solve a problem in a new and exciting way. Then people started to make money off of it. Lots of money. Then it became greed, and the technological progress halted.
Hopefully, enough people lose money so that the technical aspects can return to focus.
- nwah1 8y agoThat is curious, because with every other exciting new technology, having gobs of money thrown at it generally helps it get realized. Makes you wonder if there's something more fundamentally wrong about the assumptions going into it.
- trab 8y agoYes curious like the money that got poured into the .com tech in 2000 helped it get realized.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Fradow 8y agoThe problem is that it's not money thrown at it directly. When you pay a company, they can use that money directly. When you buy some coins, the developers/the company generally do not benefit directly. Some developers don't even have stake in the coins they create to avoid conflict of interest. Who profit then? People who already have some of those coins, because you drive up the valuation, and they can resell their coin for higher. Those people can be scammers (pump & dump scheme), cryptocurrencies, your average joe, or the devs, if they got some. You could say, apart from the last category, that they add nothing of value. Some cryptocurrencies try to have a part of the generated currency pay toward development effort, but that's not the standard.
- ballenf 8y agoThe fallacy with your argument, imo, is that cryptocurrencies are only marginally about technology. They aren't a new battery chemistry or transistor fab tech. They are a pretty simple alternative solution to a longstanding societal need. But one that needs critical mass and low volatility to succeed (arguably).
- api 8y agoIs that true? Gobs of money transformed the Internet from an engine of open communication and information sharing to an engine of privacy invasion, mass manipulation, and disinformation. The web was created at CERN and TCP/IP was created by DARPA long before the dot.com bubble and for significantly less money. The people who got rich during and after the dot.com bubble did so not by greatly improving on these technologies but by using them to commoditize human beings and monetize peoples' data. The biggest growth industry on the Internet today is the leveraging of that data toward active deception and con artistry. I'm speaking of the Internet as most people experience it. You can still of course use the pipes for productive things, but the bulk of the user-facing Internet is now a giant surveillance and manipulation machine targeted at the average user.
- nwah1 8y agoYour point is true, but internet technology is now certainly proven, and money has been instrumental in proving it. Blockchain technology is unproven for use cases beyond speculation or fraudulent/illegal activity.
- tim333 8y agoBeyond proving it a lot of money was needed for servers, cables, 4G masts and the like.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoHow much technological progress can we really squeeze out of blockchain, though? It’s my understanding that it is essential for cryptocurrencies, useful for certain niche applications, but otherwise just one tool among many suitable solutions for problems at hand. Honestly, what is something blockchain could unequivocally do better than anything else for a large scale application that isn’t cryptocurrencies?
- dragontamer 8y agoI think there's a lot of potential in "smart contracts", even though that phrase is kind of meaningless now a days. A simple example of what can happen in the cryptocurrency world: a simple combination of Shamir's Secret Sharing [1] and the public/private key model leads to very easy to use escrow services. For example, you can create a new wallet with 3-keys, and require 2-of-3 keys to transfer money out. Alice, Bob, and Escrow get the three keys. Anyone can transfer money INTO the wallet and check its value through the public key. Under normal circumstances, Alice transfers money into the new wallet. Bob then gives Alice a real physical good. Finally, Alice and Bob provide two keys to allow the wallet to transfer money to Bob. Escrow comes in if any disputes come up. Escrow provides a 2nd key to break any disputes. If Escrow sides with Alice, Escrow + Alice can together use the two keys to transfer the money back to Alice. While if Escrow sides with Bob, they together can provide two keys to transfer the money to Bob. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing ---------- True, escrow services do exist in the real world. And arguably, a "real" enforcement mechanism backed up by courts, police, and the government... are far more important than a silly crypto-game. But the silly-crypto game is automatic, and way cheaper to invoke compared to a full court case. It should be seen as a way to provide escrow services at a cost far cheaper than one backed by courts and lawyers. For example, "Escrow" can be an automatic email system that gives the 2nd key to Alice after 30 days (encrypted with Alice's public key, of course). Perhaps that's not sufficient for buying a car... but it'd be sufficient Escrow for your typical $20 video game purchase from Steam. As you can see, Bitcoin / Blockchain CAN automate things that used to take courts to invoke. Yes, its of lower quality, but almost any transaction can benefit from an Escrow service (even an Escrow service with default terms) ------------- The main problem with this scheme (and probably why it isn't popular, even if its technologically possible...) is that BTC or Ethereum's price could change dramatically, even in just 30 days. Cryptocoins simply aren't stable enough for this kind of mechanism to be useful.