3 ms·
The science of climate change doesn't only depend on computer models. The broad strokes just rest on geologic history, along with some basic physics. The models
by DennisP 8y ago
The science of climate change doesn't only depend on computer models. The broad strokes just rest on geologic history, along with some basic physics. The models are just to fill in the details.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoYes. I agree. Where we disagree is I don't see leaving out data / data source as a viable means to filling in the gaps.
- nostrebored 8y agoThe field of climate science is entirely underpinned by models...
- pdonis 8y ago> The field of climate science is entirely underpinned by models... This is not correct. There is plenty of data in climate science. There just isn't a good enough understanding of the underlying mechanisms to make predictions that are accurate enough to drive multi-trillion-dollar public policy decisions.
- nostrebored 8y agoThat's the implication that I was going for. As someone who's studied data science and modeling I agree with this wholeheartedly.
- DennisP 8y agoRead Hansen's book sometime. There's plenty of direct geological evidence that puts a pretty good bound on climate sensitivity, without depending on computer models at all. This is because the climate has gone through major changes before, and we can see how much of an initial push it took, and what happened afterwards.
- nostrebored 8y agoI'll check it out, but the second portion of your comment seems questionable. Trending to a local minimum or maximum in modeling can be caused by small changes at certain points dependent on time and be completely negligible at other points. Without understanding the model: 1. We can't even pretend to understand causality 2. We can't infer the complex state at an individual time or even the magnitude of a push.
- pdonis 8y ago> The science of climate change doesn't only depend on computer models. The predictions of doom that are driving the public policy changes being demanded by climate change alarmists do. And the models are wrong.