16 ms·
I like how we have an article explaining the rationale behind dark matter and the scientific principles that lead to the conclusion that it exists, but most of
by krapp 8y ago
I like how we have an article explaining the rationale behind dark matter and the scientific principles that lead to the conclusion that it exists, but most of the threads here are simple declarations that no, they must all simply be wrong or not considering some simple alternative.
Can people maybe, just maybe not assume that scientists are idiots or, as once dead commenter puts it, charlatans?
If you disagree with the consensus, then offer some alternative more convincing (and more useful for civil and interesting discussion) or dispute the article rather than than just writing it all off as "fake science."
- dTal 8y agoI was about to post something similar. Before you act on the urge to go pontificating about how the scientists have clearly got it wrong for this reason or that reason, ask yourself - do you really think they haven't thought of that? Don't you think that, if there is mileage in your idea, there would certainly be scientists pushing it? Addendum: Science (and more generally, specialization) requires that we trust that that the experts in the areas outside of our own chosen fields do in fact know what they are doing. It's become less fashionable to do so lately (one politician in the UK famously said a few years back that "the people of this country have had enough of experts"), but that is to our cost - the extreme end of this is flat-earth conspiracy.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think the backlash against "experts" comes from the fact that way too many things get mixed into "science". When you look at fields like social sciences, nutrition and economics there are a lot of "scientists" that get publicity for results of very undisciplined work. They don't crosscheck their result for contradictions and often just seem to look for confirmation of their own biases. This contrasts to most physics I read about. Physicists seem to make a big effort to reconcile all their measurements and if they contradict they admit that and say "we don't know yet". So physics and other hard sciences suffer from being put together with a lot of other bad science in the public.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThere are also people - usually rich and/or corporate - deliberately muddying the water in fields such as climate change, pharma testing, and so on. The public doesn't understand science, but it understands corporate PR even less. The corporate PR industry has no plans to change this. One of the biggest and most destructive wins for corporate PR has been the steady erosion of scientific credibility with FUD and character assassination, combined with science-for-hire commercial shilling. This has done huge damage to the credibility of tentative research, and made it very hard to get away with saying "We just don't know yet. So we need to keep looking, because looking where we don't have answers yet is our job." But... not only does the public not understand how corporate PR operates. The scientific community often doesn't either. There's a presumption of good faith in scientific debate. No matter how personal the to-and-fro gets, there's an assumption that everyone is doing the same job for recognisably similar reasons. That presumption is wholly wrong in any situation with significant political and/or financial consequences outside of science.
- fermienrico 8y agoContrary to your argument, there is also the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect Note that I am not saying it is the case here, but simply pointing out that the "experts" authority can also be challenged. Furthermore, this happens rarely, but notably that someone with no serious "expert" qualifications, they produce revolutionary work (Ramanujan, etc.)
- gmjoe 8y agoAgreed 100%. Indeed, this is one of the best articles I've come across which covers several of the reasons we believe dark matter exists, as opposed to us just needing to modify the theory of gravity. For whatever reason, dark matter seems to repeatedly rub people the wrong way today, more so than any other scientific concept I can think of. I actually wonder if it's something psychological -- if the universe is only 1/6 normal matter, it makes us feel even more insignificant than we already do, in the vast, seemingly infinite universe? Or maybe it's just the name, sounding too much out of fictional Star Trek.
- jccalhoun 8y ago>For whatever reason, dark matter seems to repeatedly rub people the wrong way today, more so than any other scientific concept I can think of. I think that it is because it is so hard to understand. You can't see it or touch it but it is supposed to make up the majority of mater in the universe. So what is it then? For a lot of people that's a hard thing to get and it would be easier if the answer was something we understood like the scientists being wrong. In that way it isn't any different than creationists or flat-earthers. Of course dark matter "deniers" don't have the same religious convictions of creationists.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoConsider something. What is it that makes god did [x] an improbable hypothesis? The fundamental reason is that there is no direct evidence of said god. There is indirect evidence and logical arguments that can favor a god, but that means nothing when you cannot observe a god, you cannot measure a god, and there is no direct evidence for that god. Dark matter still holds more in common with the divine than the practical, for now. We've developed and carried out a slew of extremely clever experiments to try to affirm its existence, yet each and every experiment has returned a resounding negative. This is one of the biggest problems with the gulf between experimental and theoretical physics that's been rapidly expanding over the past several decades.
- everdev 8y agoAlmost all of our current scientific knowledge has come from challenging the consensus of the times. Scientific skepticism is always healthy and should be welcomed. Even if the original theory is correct, that doubt will simply help science better explain and prove the current understanding. I'd actually be more worried if everyone agreed about something. Even gravity we thought was fully solved until Einstein doubted that we understood it fully. Let's be careful of putting anything in the category of "beyond doubt", especially theories that haven't been tested or confirmed directly.
- krapp 8y agoI'm not asking anyone to put the consensus on dark matter beyond doubt, only for people to realize that the consensus exists for a reason. Even the Wikipedia page for dark matter mentions alternatives, so it's not even an absolute consensus, and scientists have considered possibilities like "gravity is just different at large scales." The problem is, none of those alternatives can yet explain the data as well as the dark matter hypothesis. But unless we apply the principle of charity to fields that may lie outside our areas of expertise, then discussion won't move beyond the typical middlebrow dismissals HN seems to be fond of.
- gbrown 8y agoThat's precisely why we should be open to new theories and novel experiments... something which happens all the time in the scientific community. It's not a case for wild and uninformed speculation (as is happening all over this thread).
- fumbrella 8y agoI think this is true, but I would add that the challenge usually came from someone who was thoroughly familiar with the consensus of the time. I think it's important to distinguish between healthy scientific scepticism from well informed observers/participants and a general out of hand dismissiveness, an extreme example being climate change. It's very difficult to critically evaluate the claims in many fields without having a good handle on the literature. (To be clear I'm not saying this requires having a PhD in the subject.)
- 8y ago
- gbrown 8y agoPeople somehow feel uniquely qualified to speculate wildly about theoretical physics. It's bizarre in a forum full of technical-minded people.
- spiritcat 8y agoits the only worthwhile thing left to speculate about. well that and i guess like number theory. aka life, universe, everything in it. and even if someone figures it out i probably won't understand it :/
- delecti 8y agoI don't know what it is about us technically minded people that makes us so confident in our knowledge in so many fields like that (note that I'm including myself in that generalization). It seems to go beyond your garden variety Dunning–Kruger effect. My personal supposition is that most people don't know very much if anything about most subjects, and tech people tend to know a bit more than that quite low average (though still not anywhere near expert level) in an above average number of subjects, and that "novice polymath" status amplifies the Dunning-Kruger effect. Of course it's entirely possible that demonstrating the Dunning-Kruger effect by even thinking we tend to have an above average exposure to an above average number of fields.
- gbrown 8y agoWell said, that captures exactly the effect I was thinking about.
- D-Coder 8y agoWe're tired of debating double-linked lists versus hashed sets.
- raattgift 8y agoIf it's any consolation, forums full of theoretical physicists can have discussions on topics like law, economics, or computer programming, and those tend to fill up with shocking displays of ignorance. Of course, one can find that in discussions touching on law and economics here too. :-) ETA: you also get experts in one subdiscipline getting another subdiscipline terribly wrong, analogous to experts in programming language design making crazy statements about wide area networking.
- iandanforth 8y agoThe article invites that kind of response by presenting arguments for the existence of dark matter as if they are undeniable. In reality the road to consensus was anything but smooth. Science works best when you are skeptical of claims, test alternatives, and find evidence that contradict the alternative hypothesis. If you want to discuss controversial science you need to anticipate objections, show the work has been done to test the alternatives, and then leave the reader with the sense that your hypothesis is undeniable (because they can't think up any more objections.) This absurdly high burden is what makes science both hard and effective. For dark matter a large number of the initial objections have been tested thoroughly, but since they weren't covered people unfamiliar with the subject (and I don't claim to be an expert) will naturally dredge up their own objections.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- draw_down 8y agoYou don’t need to be an idiot or charlatan to be wrong or to be missing something important. All the people who didn’t know about germ theory, or who thought the earth was flat before we could prove otherwise, were they all idiots? No. But, human ignorance is not to be underestimated, and the amount of knowledge we have about the universe is not to be overestimated.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThere is something else you should also consider here. As theoretical physics and experimental physics have started to grow further and further apart, there are people who have devoted their entire careers, in many cases their entire lives, to purely theoretical pursuits which may in the end simply be invalid. But at some point you reach a point of no return in your career - in that you would need to effectively reboot your entire life, which may be quite decorated by this point, in some entirely new direction leaving you going from leading expert to mid (or older) aged neophyte. There is a reason Max Planck famously said, "Science advances one funeral at a time." And that was back when experimental and theoretical were still very closely intertwined! One problem with dark matter is that there have been an increasingly large number of quite clever experiments to try to detect various concepts of it, WIMPs in particular. And each and every one has been a negative. This should, in and of itself, begin to cast down on the hypothesis even lacking a better alternative.
- cygx 8y agoThis should, in and of itself, begin to cast down on the hypothesis even lacking a better alternative. Only if your search was exhaustive: Scooping up a spoonful of ocean is not enough to conclude fish do not exist...
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThat's really the problem here though. You cannot falsify dark matter, and you cannot prove a negative. Imagine I say there is a 5 headed green deer that weighs 2000 pounds and can speak Gaelic, but it's really good at avoiding being spotted - so good in fact that you can even look at right at it and might not see it. And you can even touch it and not even know you're touching it! What would you could consider an exhaustive proof of its lack of existence? You can leave carrots everywhere, but perhaps it doesn't like carrots. Or maybe you didn't spot it eating those carrots. Maybe you left them in the wrong spot, or at the wrong time. Maybe you need bigger carrots. Maybe you need smaller carrots. Maybe it likes cooked carrots instead of raw carrots. Maybe you need a better camera. Maybe the reason you camera didn't catch it is because you weren't using a flash, or maybe you need to setup an infrared camera, maybe you need to play a Gaelic greeting on loop, etc, etc. You can compile a literally infinite number of ideas to try to detect our dear deer. Instead with non falsifiable theories, all you can do is approach them from an abundance of failures. You've tried carrots, you've tried infrared, you've tried ..., and it's still not coming out. Each failure makes it more and more likely that our deer simply does not exist. Of course this does not mean it definitively does not, but nothing will ever mean that.
- Pharmakon 8y agoThe problem is that some of the big questions in physics appear very simple if your knowledge of the subject lacks any depth. It is also very difficult for some people to gauge the depth of their knowledge. All of this is exacerbated by endless popular science shows which give people the sense of understanding, without the necessary substance. In short, it is not enough to understand by analogy, you need the math and the science. Most people who aren’t in the field lack that, but are culturally inclined to comment.
- tokyodude 8y agoBecause in one sense it sounds as bad as alchemist (who were once considered scientists). We're riding on the back on a turtle We're the center of the universe All things are made from earth, air, water, fire Space is filled with ether Dark Matter "feels" like it's going to be yet another of those things that will be added to the list of things scientists used to believe. I fully acknowledge they aren't stupid and that I am not remotely knowledgeable about any of it but go read the transcript from this Nova episode about actual scientists predictions about what we'd find on Venus http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/2210venus.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/2210venus.html The scientists in 1995 we're not stupid either but their predictions certainly sound stupid in 2018. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-dark-matter-real/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-dark-matter-re...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mmusson 8y agoThere is not scientific consensus on this issue. The article is written as if particle dark matter is the only viable option. I would recommend reading another expert on this issue for comparison. https://tritonstation.wordpress.com https://tritonstation.wordpress.com Dark matter and Lambda-CDM have fundamental problems too.
- mmusson 8y agoThere is not scientific consensus on this issue. I would recommend reading another expert on this issue for comparison. https://tritonstation.wordpress.com https://tritonstation.wordpress.com Dark matter and Lamda-CDM have some fundamental problems.
- dogma1138 8y agoI think you misunderstand the threads. Dark Matter isn’t a thing it’s a place holder it has many candidates some more probable than others it might be that there is only one class of dark matter it might be that there are multiple classes of dark matter. It might be that all the dark matter will be new forms of matter it might be that some or all of it will end up being baryonic matter. It also might be that we won’t find it at all in which case we might need to say that our understanding of gravity and the geometry of space time isn’t nearly as representative of reality as we thought maybe dark matter is gravity leaking in from other universes maybe it’s the affect of additional dimensions of space time maybe quantum gravity causes some wired emerging phenomenon that affects the geometry of space time that we attribute to missing mass. There isn’t a consensus amongst scientists on anything related to dark matter other than based on observations we are missing a truckload of mass in the universe. And currently people are trying to explain it by looking for new forms of matter, normal matter that is very cold and so we can’t see it, and even attempting at modifying the theories of gravity to account for the observations we see with new relativistic and classical modified gravity models.
- acqq 8y ago> it might be that some or all of it will end up being baryonic matter It can’t be. It’s already known that 5/6 ths of all the matter in the observable Universe can’t be baryonic. > There isn’t a consensus amongst scientists Only for completely useless definitions of the “concensus.”
- dogma1138 8y ago>It can’t be. It’s already known that 5/6 ths of all the matter in the observable Universe can’t be baryonic. No it's not known, it's highly unlikely that the "final" dark matter candidate will be completely made up of baryonic matter but it's not been exclusively proven. Only Siths deal in absolutes. >Only for completely useless definitions of the “concensus.” Do you have a more useful definition of consensus for this matter? if so please share it.
- gmjoe 8y ago
- philwelch 8y agoI’ve written about this here before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16703193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16703193 It feels unintuitive to think about “dark matter” that can’t be directly observed outside of its indirect gravitational effects, but that carries with it an implicit assumption that we should be able to directly observe all the matter in the universe, with the further implication that all the matter in the universe obeys the four fundamental forces that our matter does. Except we already know of other particles that don’t quite do that, like neutrinos, which we can just barely detect directly. If you take at face value the observation that most observed mass in the universe (via the effects of gravity) is dark, then it appears that our fundamental understanding of reality only describes a minority of the universe and that what’s truly special isn’t the “dark matter”, but rather the “anthropic matter” that we can more easily observe. The dark matter may simply be multiple entirely alien classes of matter with their own fundamental forces, stuff that doesn’t interact with our matter at all outside of gravity and contains, perhaps, observers of its own trying to figure out what the hell we are and whether we exist, since we don’t respond to their fundamental forces.
- gus_massa 8y ago> with the further implication that all the matter in the universe obeys the four fundamental forces that our matter does. Except we already know of other particles that don’t quite do that, like neutrinos, which we can just barely detect directly. Left-handed neutrinos interact mainly by the weak force and also by gravity. We have a lot of knowledge about them. You can create a neutrino ray and a neutrino detector, and (if wired properly) measure their speed. We know that there are three types of neutrinos (or perhaps there is a fourth neutrino). We know that they can change midflight from a kind of neutrino to another kind of neutrino. The change takes some time, so you can create a neutrino ray of one kind and a neutrino detector of the other kind and measure how many of the neutrinos changed midflight. So the neutrinos are well understood and there are many labs that can measure them. (Right-handed neutrinos are more difficult to measure because they interact only by gravity. Some people think that they don't even exist. Some people think that they may be part of the dark mater. I think this is still not settled. Anyway, all the neutrinos we know are left-handed neutrinos.)
- vbezhenar 8y agoThat's why it's dangerous to pretend like really complex things actually are not that complex. Laymen think that they understand something about it and they are starting to have opinion which usually is wrong, because complex things are actually complex and opinion based on limited interpretation is wrong.
- mnl 8y agoThis happens all the time here when it comes to physics. Other greatest hits are bickering endlessly about interpretations of QM deeming unacceptable the shut-up-and-calculate approach that 90% of physicists have no problem with and to a minor extent the failure of the LHC to make up new physics ex nihilo. People should be able to recognize they haven't put the effort to learn the basics of what they're talking about and that maybe there are very good reasons for all this they can't be aware of because of it and should ask about... and start from there.
- dnautics 8y ago> Can people maybe, just maybe not assume that scientists are idiots or, as once dead commenter puts it, charlatans? Have you met scientists? Or more accurately, PIs? Unfortunately, our system of being awarded grants and academic advancement does not necessarily reward the intelligent, those with the best scientific judgement, and rapidly burns out those who would in the ideal make the best scientists.
- Steko 8y agoI like how the linked article is a laundry list of reasons to believe in dark matter but doesn't mention any problems with particle dark matter, MOND alternatives, or that the consensus on dark matter is far from settled, etc. And oh yeah anyone who questions this onesided cheerleading is strawmanned into an antiscience quack.