5 ms·
> Magic Leap is almost entirely built on the visions of grown men wanting to immerse themselves in fantasy worlds. Its chief focus is entertainment, games, dive
by Apocryphon 8y ago
> Magic Leap is almost entirely built on the visions of grown men wanting to immerse themselves in fantasy worlds. Its chief focus is entertainment, games, diversions—cinematic reality, sure; pushing the frontiers of computing? Not as much.
I’ll repeat my half-baked idea: the future of VR and AR is digital workplaces for better teleconferencing. Make it truly seamless to talk to colleagues while working remote. Disrupt office work as we know it and fix the externalities of commuting and being tied to a physical workplace. Why escape into fantasy worlds when you can make living in the real world more bearable?
- kmlx 8y ago"Make it truly seamless to talk to colleagues while working remote." Some of us work remotely in order to avoid constant disruption (especially software development). As such the queueing of IM conversations from colleagues is a good thing in this scenario. The quality of the code that I write grows exponentially the less people ping me on Skype. While in the office code development was tertiary to various meetings, presentations, the occasional interview, even birthdays.
- Apocryphon 8y agoI admit, part of this is productivity theater. If you can simulate face time, seamless visibility at a meeting, sparking ideas spontaneously around the water cooler, etc., then maybe those dictating corporate conduct might actually be more willing to entertain mass adoption of remote work. As of now remote work is certainly feasible, but it’s definitely steps removed from the actual experience of being in person. Also, my proposal isn’t meant to benefit engineers exclusively- teleconferencing through virtual workplaces should ideally help anyone who works in an office, not just those who are accorded more responsibilities that don’t involve social interaction.
- sgt101 8y agoYeah, you'll have to have a way to record yourself and encode/decode/transmit in real time though.... Maybe in twenty years...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- espadrine 8y agoThe peak of teleconferencing are the Hangouts and Facetime of this world, and they struggle to deliver almost-still-frame 1080p 2D video streams and high-quality audio. We've seen Oculus and others try to push the idea that 3D will help. The focus is wrong. The bulk of the pain is in understanding, for which the brain relies on two factors: audio and face/mouth position. Audio requires good microphones, which are too expensive to be commodity. At least, very good and fast STT autocues would help, especially with non-native speakers. Faces could use dedicated compression algorithms. Ideally, everyone would have Wacom-style devices on an online whiteboard, but that is only complementary. And it is still 2D.
- solarkraft 8y ago> Audio requires good microphones, which are too expensive to be commodity Huh? MEMS mics cost cents and multiple of them are frequently used in phones to get a pretty acceptable-quality (almost good!) signal.
- espadrine 8y agoWe maybe don't have the same scale to measure audio. What I find acceptable is “I hear the person just as well as if they were here”. Hearing is a continuum. What the top 25% of hearing people consider OK quality is often what the lower 50% really struggles with, barely keeping up with the conversation. Even in same-room audio conditions, most people ask for something to be repeated at least once in half the conversations I witness. Any further degradation rapidly increases this statistic. And I bet there are cases where people don't bother asking.
- mgkimsal 8y agoWhat webex/facetime/goto/hangouts needs is live transcripts, or... pretty live. Each person's mic/setup has much better audio of what was said, and can be configured (eventually) to learn that person's accent. When 2-3 voices talk over each other, I have to ask people to stop/repeat, wasting time, losing momentum, when the computers themselves can likely give me a good indication of what was said via text as well as audio. And if a transcription is bad, the person can 'correct' it on their end, or just verbally - "no, that's not the word I used", etc.
- kopo 8y agoAlso practical things like live conversation speech to text for deaf people. Pretty sure it will be cheaper than what gets spent on hearing aids.
- i_made_a_booboo 8y ago10/10 I don't want to put on my rift to do work. Ever.
- Apocryphon 8y agoI imagine the ultimate form factor would be eyecaps that are the visual equivalent to earbuds.
- i_made_a_booboo 8y agoSomebody promote this guy.
- papa_bear 8y agoI remember one of the first hololens trailers featured someone trying to fix their own sink plumbing, and an expert skyping in and highlighting exactly what to do. Making AR even slightly accessible is going to drastically change all of the trade skill industries. Any kind of simple job with something like plumbing, electrician, or car problems, you could call up a remote expert (or knowledgable friend/relative) and have them guide you through the job without forcing them to drive to your house. This would probably lead to training AIs to help with those same simple jobs, and eventually more complicated ones, but probably not for a good many years(?). Maybe it's a lot easier said than done, but I feel like there are tons of more physical "remote work" opportunities that Magic Leap can open up, and they're not focusing on them nearly enough. Microsoft is pushing hard with using the hololens in industrial environments for training or collaborating, but even for just personal use, I could see myself buying AR goggles if it made learning basic handyman chores around the house easier to get started with, and hopefully feel less like a chore.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThis is the application I'm waiting for. I hope whoever is working on this will make sure it won't remain forever locked down in corporate works. Professional specialization is not absolute, I don't want to become e.g. professional corporate electrician to get access to AR that would tell me how to fix or put together some electronics.
- donavanm 8y agoSo very skeptical this will meaningfully impact the trades. Useful as a bit of DIY coaching, sure. A better Family Handyman or This Old House Ill grant. But skilled trades are not just knowledge. They rely heavily on experience, skill, and equipment. For example which angle and torque to use with that spark plug, not just highlighting the plug on cylinder #3. A lot of this speaks to why there are apprenticeships instead of study sessions. Theres also the UI and sensory problems in the hololens and your example. Transmitting fixed position AV misses out on a lot of contextual and situational awareness true presence delivers.
- davnicwil 8y agoI feel like you're making a pretty big assumption here: that people care or want to think about the details of these types of jobs at all, let alone do anything themselves. Part of the reason why a plumber or mechanic is so expensive is that you're buying not only the solution to the problem, but also your own time and energy that you would have spent thinking about and implementing that solution.
- knolan 8y agoI’ve never believed this idea that we will all be somehow teleconferencing with AR goggles in the near future. Primarily because I think a lot of teleconferences end up being a waste of productive time but also why would I want to see AR repsentations of people also with their faces covered with a HMD? The solution is a digital avatar of them which is equally daft. /grumble
- aj7 8y agoI agree. Teleconferencing does not need extra reality for the same reason you text people rather than call. Remoteness is often good. Do I want that meeting asshole more real?