10 ms·
On Cash
- pteredactyl 8y agoI'm with you 100%. Makes me feel more connected to local businesses. Also, I know they get more when I pay cash. I've carried thousands of dollars around and no one was none the wiser. So while the security argument is true. It's overblown. At most someone will probably steal $100 from me. And that's never happened, thankfully. (I live in a dodgy part of SF)
- Symbiote 8y ago> Also, I know they get more when I pay cash. Maybe, maybe not. I've been asked to pay by card by a street food vendor in Copenhagen, after I offered cash. I don't think he wanted the increased expense of going to a bank to deposit the money, getting change, or having the (small in Denmark) risk of theft. For a larger business, there is also the risk of theft by employees.
- pdkl95 8y ago> while the security argument is true The security argument is mostly orthogonal to the benefits of carrying cash. Obviously there is wisdom in having multiple options for moving money, which will inevitably have different strengths and weaknesses. Cash is important to have because the other methods occasionally fail in very problematic ways[1], while the security (and bookkeeping) advantages of electronic payments become more attractive when the transactions size is large. [1] Cash works when the power/internet/banking-infrastructure isn't available. Cash also has inherently limited risk: you can only lose what you are carrying. Credit cards, debit, and any other method where someone else controls your access to the money carry a risk of losing access to the entire account if the controlling bank decides (possibly in error) to freeze your account.
- bostik 8y ago> I've carried thousands of dollars around and no one was none the wiser. With reasonably good probability you are (or were) exhibiting outlier behaviour. I do not have much faith in humanity, so if a high proportion of people routinely carried that much cash with them, the incentives for random muggings would be also higher. In essence, it's because people don't generally carry that much cash with them, that you could do it without having to consider your safety. Before anyone claims that carrying large amounts of cash around is not a problem, think about this: The people who fill ATMs go around armed[ß]. Either personally or they have a guard with them. It isn't that different from herd immunity. I like cash, but I make a point of carrying only small amounts with me. Moreover, I also make sure that the bank account linked to my card has only limited funds on it, and move the money around between accounts as needed. ß: A good proportion do, at least.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoSimilarly, when I pay electronically, I know the business owners have one less option for tax fraud.
- ken 8y agoI've been told that the unwritten rule of small businesses is that nobody pays all the taxes they owe. Nobody would be able to afford to stay in business if they did. They depend on cash for this. There's a small business (owner and 1-2 employees) here in Seattle that regularly gives me a huge cash discount. He'll print an exact price on the bill, to the penny, and when I pull out cash, he'll notice and just make up a much smaller number, rounded to the $10. On a $50-$150 purchase, it's usually a 30-50% discount. They've been in business for many years so I assume he knows what he's doing. (I wonder if this comment will get people to start offering cash at Seattle area small businesses, in the hopes of getting a discount!)
- pteredactyl 8y agoYes, the government is definitely better at spending money than the small business owner. I'd rather have my money spent on bombs and failing, corrupt infrastructure projects...
- osrec 8y agoI really like the points made about the international payments cartel. Something needs to happen to challenge them, as they really are holding back a tonne of potentially viable businesses, a lot of which could seriously change our world for the better. I don't think companies like Stripe are the answer either, as they sort of pander to the cartel. It's funny that the electronic payment industry is a direct result of innovation, but because of the stranglehold it now has on society, it's begun to limit the potential for new innovation.
- wycs 8y agoYou would need Wechat for America. I actually think Apple is well placed to do this, but it would go against their hardware-first culture. If they released iMessage and ApplePay on Android, added a Wechat style P2P payment system, and started cannibalizing the AppStore/Playstore through a WeChat style API I think they could pull it off.
- metildaa 8y agoVenmo and Zelle already dominate this market vertical though, if Zelle could get their butt in gear for writing integrations with bank and credit union backends, they coukd easily take a similar place to mobile payments in China. Instant, free bank to bank transfers aare a powerful tool!
- qwertay 8y agoWe don't need another centralized locked down system to replace the current one. Apples system would be even worse. If I don't own an Apple or Android device I just can't make payments anymore?
- throw940day 8y agoMy only problem with WeChat is how difficult they make it for foreigners to use unless you have a Chinese bank account. I had to resort to giving my Chinese friends cash, and then they can send me "red envelopes" to use. Ideally, I would like to be able to buy top-up cards at convenient stores or even use my credit card to add money to my WeChat account.
- kasey_junk 8y agoJust as a anecdotal point, I’m in the states and I largely only use the touch pay stuff.
- galonk 8y agoThat's actually interesting, I wonder where you are, because I was in freakin' NYC last year and every store STILL didn't even take chip cards, much less tap. Don't even get me started on having to deal with pennies ;)
- kasey_junk 8y agoChicago. Most of the time I get swipes now it’s on square or one of the other old style mobile apps.
- sontek 8y agoI'm in Puerto Rico and almost all of shops that take card take chip. I feel like you may have been frequenting some odd places if you were having a hard time finding chip in NYC :P
- akvadrako 8y agoWhat does Puerto Rico have to do with chip in NYC ? Americans have one of the most antiquated banking systems in the world.
- clamprecht 8y agoFor me, Cash is freedom. No one can block my transaction, record what I purchase, or tell me who I can and can't give money to. I live part of the year in Argentina, and when I'm there I don't even carry a wallet. Just a pocket full of cash, maybe my bus card if I need it. I love it.
- sxg 8y agoCash is also a liability. It makes you a target for muggings if anyone notices you have a significant wad of cash on you. If you misplace your cash, you have no recourse like if you misplaced a credit card. With cash, it's difficult to track your own transactions and budget appropriately. I live by YNAB to monitor my spending and saving habits, and it wouldn't be possible to use as effectively with cash.
- clamprecht 8y agoFreedom has risks and responsibilities, I accept them. Edit: BTW, I'm not saying one needs to be 100% cash. I use credit cards too. The important thing is that I have a choice.
- aesh2Xa1 8y agoI find this position generally attractive because I believe that good principles and ethics requires some effort on everyone's part, especially when the benefit is towards not oneself. Technically, though, I would not believe a claim that anonymous electronic currency is impossible to implement. You can have the benefits of cash and the convenience of technologies.
- sokoloff 8y ago> You can have the benefits of cash and the convenience of technologies. Cash is instant, does not require power, does not require connectivity, and no one takes of cut of the transaction. Cash also leaves a trail so faint that it requires a substantial investment in resources to trace it. I think those hurdles will be difficult to overcome in order to match the benefits of cash in an electronic currency.
- hprotagonist 8y agoCarrying cash makes it easier to give to people who ask for it. On the other hand, I've had some interesting meals with people because i couldn't give them cash so I picked up the tab instead.
- dna_polymerase 8y agoIMHO the only worthwhile competition to the "international payments cartel", as the author puts it, could be something Blockchain based. Decentralized and by some algorithm protected from a sudden surge in fees. I know lots of people have an opinion on what cryptocurrency could be the one but I think we simply aren't there yet. Personally I feel that Vitalik Buterin of Ethereum has the best project at hand to accomplish anything as big as an VISA/Mastercard killer (in terms of scalability) but at the moment we are not there. Decentralisation however just makes so much sense in order to protect both sides from shady behaviour from the middleman. Just take a look at the adult entertainment industry, who are mostly unable to process credit cards without giving up enormous chunks of their revenue, just because the big two refuse their business. That said, cash will always have the advantage of relative easy and effective anonymity. I find it troubling that people are so eager to give up on such an essential feature of their money.
- decentralised 8y agoI agree with you, if you look at the work being done around Zero Knowledge proofs the future of private transactions on-chain seems really very promising.
- hakfoo 8y agoI always pictured there would be some "assertive" state actor involved to create a true Visa/MC/etc-killer. You could say something like "our central bank offers a basic push and pull payment API, and there's an account created for every citizen/resident. It's going to be used to disburse social security and accept tax payments, so everyone's going to have to learn to work with it." Maybe add some sort of plastic-card based infrastructure for convenient transactions without smartphones or PCs. Adding credit-based products on top of that feels like a fairly trivial endeavour. This would seemingly be a feasible sell to many governments with the right spin (reduction in processing costs for their own payments, fraud control, data gathering, reducing reliance on foreign-controlled payment services, adding another means of capital control) It also seems reasonable within the same sort of "government needs to provide the basic infrastructure for a modern financial system" scope that allows for government "lenders of last resort", bank insurance, and clearing houses for cheques. Then the question for Visa/MC/etc becomes "what can you offer these consumers and retailers that the local service doesn't except higher fees?" aside from the corner case of "you can use it abroad more easily".
- niftich 8y agoThough it's hardly the author's point, carrying a bit of cash for outages, emergencies, and incidentals is probably smart, and then you have a bit for the exceptional busker. You can still do your day-to-day spending from a card. Or cards, whichever gives better perks for the store in question. And there's the rub: most payment networks charge the merchant, and through the elaborate tendrils of corporate ownership kick a proportionally smaller amount back to the customer. Still, it's a reward that's nice to have, and coupled with fraud protection, three weeks of delay in due dates, single-item usability, and a built-in credit line, credit cards are winning out among those who can obtain them. Card surcharges are one way a merchant can pass on the cost of credit card acceptance to the customer, and are currently a state-by-state issue, but big retailers don't want to surcharge lest they create friction and lose shoppers to a competitor. This furthers the price pressure on small merchants or moves them further upmarket where price is less of a factor. Companies like Square (physical) and Stripe (online) able to make headway by simpler fee structures, ease of use, and a welcoming attitude towards small businesses. Meanwhile, Google's much-rebranded payment network, Apple Pay, and Samsung's me-too Pay are an attempt to leverage the market penetration of cell phones to gradually ease people into different payment habits. It's not hard to envision a situation where in a few years, the cellphone-making companies of the world have cut out the likes of Visa and Mastercard from payments, giving them negotiating power with banks, merchants, and other payment networks. This is a particularly plausible outcome for Amazon, who is extremely intent on being a complete end-to-end solution for customers for anything that they'd want to buy. In a world like that, cash becomes an instrument of those for whom lenders don't want to extend a line of credit, or those who can afford to use other payment instruments, but are paying extra for their privacy.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Still, it's a reward that's nice to have, and coupled with fraud protection, three weeks of delay in due dates, single-item usability, and a built-in credit line, credit cards are winning out among those who can obtain them. Fraud is a cost of credit cards, not a benefit. Even with "protection" it's an ordeal when it happens -- or when it doesn't but the credit card company wrongly suspects it has and abruptly disables your card. And putting off the payment for three weeks can also be problematic. If you're just spending money which is already in your checking account it makes little difference which day the transfer posts, but if you're spending money you don't have, what happens when you still don't have it by the due date? Or even if you do have the money, wait until first time you forget to make a payment and all the supposed financial benefits of credit cards instantly evaporate into a nasty late fee and 15+% APR. > Card surcharges are one way a merchant can pass on the cost of credit card acceptance to the customer, and are currently a state-by-state issue, but big retailers don't want to surcharge lest they create friction and lose shoppers to a competitor. The alternative is a cash discount. The advertised price would be no higher than it would be by charging the same price for cash and credit, you just give two thirds of the credit card fee to the customer (instead of the one third the credit card company does) and pocket the other third. And take more customers from the competition once they realize you're offering the discount.
- latchkey 8y agoA huge issue with getting rid of cash is tourism. In China, cash is becoming more rare. It is all WeChat. Except that I can't put my credit card into WeChat... they only accept Chinese cards.
- throw940day 8y agoYes, this was very annoying when visiting China. I had to resort to giving my friends cash so they could send "red envelopes (virtual credits)" to my account. I really hope WeChat does better on this. Either letting us use our foreign cards or have some type of top off card where you can buy at convenience stores or the airport and load that into WeChat account. I know there are some services that can do this, but I'm not sure how reliable they are.
- henrikschroder 8y agoAnother point is that cash allows you to buy unethical things and illegal things. It allows economical activity on the edges of society. Some of those edges are bad, but some are good. How could you run a gay bar, in a place where gay bars are illegal, and the government could just block your payments? How could you sell marijuana and build the legalize movement, if government could just block those payments? How could you run a whistleblower leak site on the internet through donations, if the government can just block all payments to you? Deciding what people can buy and cannot buy sounds great if you're the one in power. But if you're not, it will pretty quickly turn into another form of tyranny.
- microcolonel 8y ago> Another point is that cash allows you to buy unethical things and illegal things. Or even perfectly legal, not-unethical things which are not liked by your payment processor. Many will not process payments for firearms or firearm parts, and a whole host of other things which are perfectly legal; MasterCard (whatever your opinion on the validity of their choice) has coerced Patreon into shutting down the accounts of people whose speech they don't like. A "cashless" system is one which requires a hell of a lot more regulation on payment processors, or a true virtual equivalent of fiat cash which doesn't involve the policy or whims of processors (or maybe a considerable deregulation, which allows individuals and upstarts to afford to process payments).
- jimmywanger 8y agoI was talking to a guy who worked at a hydroponic store. He said they had to have armored guards at the store, because the thieves knew there was a good chance the customers were paying cash so the store carried a lot of cash and the customers did also. I personally like cash, but there are some risks. Especially if you're in somewhat marginalized portions of society, cash is replete so robbers are attracted.
- adriand 8y agoI've been pondering the plight of homeless people and buskers and panhandlers lately too, for the same precise reason, which is now that tap to pay is almost universally accepted I find I'm rarely carrying cash. I went in a different direction than the OP, however: I've been thinking that buskers and panhandlers should consider signing up for Square's tap to pay reader so they can easily accept card payments. I know it might seem odd, especially in the case of panhandlers, who may have difficulty persuading people that the transaction is secure in addition to the fact that some people will be judgmental and assume that if they can afford a smartphone, a card reader, and a bank account, they must not need the money. But what's the real alternative? It sure isn't trying to persuade people to carry cash because of "The Man" or so that they can keep buskers and panhandlers in business. If people who earn money on the street can't accept card payments, they're screwed, plain and simple. There might even be a non-profit startup idea here: something like Square, but optimized for panhandlers and buskers. Something that people get used to, that clearly communicates that the transaction will be secure and small (e.g. $1 or $2 every time), that charges absolutely minimal fees (or none if possible), and perhaps that works without a real bank account - e.g. money goes onto the device, and then the device itself can also be used to pay for things, like Apple Pay.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThere might even be a non-profit startup idea here: something like Square, but optimized for panhandlers That sounds to me kind of like this (only available in Seattle currently, iirc): https://www.samaritan.city https://www.samaritan.city I was homeless for nearly six years. Instead of panhandling, I worked at developing an online income. I'm trying to support and promote that approach for others. Some of my work: https://www.pocketputer.com https://www.pocketputer.com https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com http://writepay.blogspot.com http://writepay.blogspot.com
- nowarninglabel 8y agoSamaritan is doing good work and making it easy to get digital credit or other credit to people rather than directly handle cash. Where things really shine though I think is with surfacing the stories of the people you are giving to.
- Osiris 8y agoI hate using cash because I hate change (coins). Also, what do you do for big purchases? Most ATMs have a $200 limit.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I hate using cash because I hate change (coins). Coinstar has a deal where you can exchange your coins for an Amazon gift code with no fee. So just dump them in a bucket and go exchange them once a year, then use the gift code for whatever you would have bought on Amazon regardless -- and use your credit card even less. > Also, what do you do for big purchases? Most ATMs have a $200 limit. Most ATMs have a $500 limit. For some banks it's $1500 or more. And you can get more by going inside the bank. How often do you make such a large in-person purchase anyway?
- projektfu 8y agoYeah, I recently bought a motorcycle with cash. Price obviously too high for ATM so I went to bank drive-through. Apparently too high for the drive through so they asked me to come into the store. There they gave me the cash, I felt nervous carrying it the rest of the day, and then I picked up the motorcycle and counted out the bills. This was after we couldn't find a working venmo, Zelle, PopMoney or PayPal solution. That much is increasingly rare.
- qwertay 8y agoThis is a valid point that is getting downvoted. Counting coins is a huge pain. Using notes isn't too bad but then you end up with all these scrap coins. The banks here in Australia have a solution for that though. They have a machine you can pour your coins in to and you get notes back.
- quickthrower2 8y agoI use the self service checkouts at supermarkets to get rid of a lot of coins. Not only does the save counting coins, but you get 100% of the value unlike coinstar etc. ATMs allow $1000AUD per card in Australia, so with multiple cards you are sweet. Anything more than a couple of 1000 I'd prefer to use bank transfers anyway.
- thinkloop 8y agoCash can be expensive to use. There is a hidden tax on all goods and services of a few percent to offset the payment fees merchants have to pay to processors and to support the loyalty programs arms race. By using cash, you miss out on the 1%-2% rewards/cashback that offset the elevated prices. That's supposed to be your prize for having helped pressure the merchants into accepting your payment method.
- shorttime 8y agoNot true. It's illegal for something to cost more if you use cash.
- jefftk 8y agoIt effectively costs more, since you pay the same but don't get cash back. If I buy something for $100 cash it would have cost me $98 (after cash back) via credit card.
- ken 8y agoI've noticed the opposite. A surprising number and variety of businesses will give a discount (and more than 1-2%) for using cash.
- rrrazdan 8y agoCash also causes corruption. Part of the way India is trying to curb corruption is to move people off of cash. Not that it is working.
- khuey 8y agoCash enables petty corruption perhaps, but not the big stuff.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoI live in developing country that does quite poorly on the Transparency International Corruption Index. You have no idea what you're talking about. Cash enables big corruption, too.
- shorttime 8y agoI always carry cash. I'm surprised when people don't. Came in handy when the hurricane hit, gas stations only took cash. Cash is also good for negotiation.
- metildaa 8y agoAvoiding payment fees, negotiating a discount by having cash ready to fork over, etc. Its always good to have $100 or so in your pocket, quick way to smooth over small fender benders/paint nicks if you accidentally damage someone else's car in a minor way. I say this as someone who lives in part of the US where shops and medical practices are starting to go card only. Having cash is still really handy, though many people here can get by without touching cash for months.
- irrational 8y ago"quick way to smooth over small fender benders/paint nicks if you accidentally damage someone else's car in a minor way" Anytime I've had a body shop repair dents or paint nicks it has cost so much more than $100 that I would literally laugh in the face of anyone that tried that with me.
- metildaa 8y agoIf your driving a car 5+ years old that was $30k or less, a small nick such as the one I mentioned isn't apt to be repaired. All one is trying to do is satiate the party that had their car damaged, and that is generally possible for a fairly reasonable cost.
- metildaa 8y agoAvoiding tracking (which credit/debit networks, banks & credit unions actively leverage against you) is another reasonable use for cash. I don't want Chase knowing I shop at Goodwill, if they choose to pass that along to one of the credit agencies (there are hundreds of small ones in the USA FYI), it would nreflect poorly. Same for using anything bbesides cash when buying liquor, cigarettes or other low class/socially questionable items. Edit: Using credit cards at thrift stores may affect your credit report: http://www.wistv.com/story/10670982/warning-shopping-at-thrift-stores-could-affect-your-credit-rating http://www.wistv.com/story/10670982/warning-shopping-at-thri...
- throwaway76543 8y agoUsing credit cards at thrift stores cannot affect your credit score. That article is poorly written and is discussing impact to credit issued by the credit card issuer. It may impact models run by the bank which issues your credit card but it will not impact lending from any other source and will not impact your credit score. No one can share individual purchase data with other lenders, that sort of data sharing is prohibited.
- sroussey 8y ago1. Square, for example, does both payment processing and lending. 2. The idea of what you can or can not do varies quite a bit based on jurisdiction. For example, just searching for things related to democracy can lower your credit score in China.
- throwaway76543 8y agoI'm not sure what you mean with the first bullet point. All banks which do payment processing do lending. It's inherent in the nature of the service, that's what the above article is about.
- metildaa 8y agoThe data is up for sale, notably Google buys this data (see link below). If Google can buy it, so can one of the hundreds of credit agencies out there, ditto for potential lenders. It is obviously priced low enough for non-lenders to buy transaction history in bulk, seeing as Google is willing to plunk down for a massive amount of transaction data: https://slate.com/technology/2018/08/google-mastercard-data-track-offline-purchases.html https://slate.com/technology/2018/08/google-mastercard-data-...
- Animats 8y agoAt least in Silicon Valley, Google Pay and Apple Pay came and went. Is Google even still serious about Google Pay, or is that on life support like Google Fiber and Google Phone?
- samontar 8y agoIs Google Pay the contactless payment solution on my phone? I use that every day! It’s great. Not as good as a contactless card, but pretty good.
- overeater 8y agoHere on the east coast, I use it as my main form of payment. Fast food, grocery stores, gas stations sometimes. I don't carry a wallet anymore, just a sleeve on my phone case for my driver's license.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoI use Google Pay but only because it is the only option on my device. It's another one of those Google products with PMs looking for the next big thing instead of making all the little things work. For example, there is no way to name your cards, so I have a few cards named Visa [last four digits]. There is no way to say that you prefer to use particular cards at particular merchants. I used to be able to load library cards into Google Wallet and name them, but now there are only a few fixed name options for loyalty cards, they are all named Library Card, which isn't helpful to people like me who use multiple library systems.
- irrational 8y agoWhat do you mean Apple Pay came and went? Where I live (not SV) I pay for everything with Apple Pay. I haven't found any stores or restaurants that don't accept it.
- newscracker 8y agoI keep sharing this article on Aeon, titled "In praise of cash" [1], and encourage people to use cash. This was discussed then (March 2017) on HN. [2] It is almost impossible in many countries to use cash for large purchases, but many routine purchases that people do can easily be done through cash (this may vary by country, as there are some countries that have adapted to being hostile to using cash). Within the constraints of a government issued and recognized fiat value exchange system, cash is freedom. Period. Everything else is a bunch of people sitting between you and the seller, taking a cut on every transaction and imposing more restrictions on what you can do with your knowledge or labor. [1]: https://aeon.co/essays/if-plastic-replaces-cash-much-that-is-good-will-be-lost https://aeon.co/essays/if-plastic-replaces-cash-much-that-is... [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13782561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13782561
- forapurpose 8y agoIf we only had electronic payment methods (credit cards, etc.) and someone invented cash, we'd be very impressed: No communication with a server, no approval (for either party), no contracts and agreements, no cut taken from the seller (and partly passed on to the buyer), no third party involved at all - just a direct transaction between buyer and seller, no chips, not even electricity is needed. Imagine just handing someone a piece of paper. Nobody is excluded, no matter their income or background. It's frictionless, anonymous, and it's very simple (for the user); the complexity is all handled by the cash-issuing party. Of course some will complain about government intruding into the payment processing marketplace.
- mpweiher 8y agoDistributed server-less anonymous payments with off-line capability! Inclusive and diverse! What's not to like?
- ken 8y agoWe would also hate it. I have to do math at every transaction? There's different denominations (which make no sense), and some are paper and some are metal? How do I authenticate that it's a real bill? What happens when it wears out? Are you really going to keep inventing new designs every couple years as criminals learn to make their own? What if I want to buy something and I have enough cash but the vendor can't "make change" (actually happened to me the other day)? Cash is one of those great ideas, like bicycles and music, that I'm glad we invented long ago, because I doubt it'd ever get invented/discovered in today's ROI-above-all-else environment.
- forapurpose 8y ago> I have to do math at every transaction? There's different denominations (which make no sense), and some are paper and some are metal? How do I authenticate that it's a real bill? What happens when it wears out? Are you really going to keep inventing new designs every couple years as criminals learn to make their own? What if I want to buy something and I have enough cash but the vendor can't "make change" (actually happened to me the other day)? In practice, these won't be significant problems for the user. I haven't seen the focus group testing, but I'm comfortable predicting that. Some of those issues are problems for the cash-issuer, not the user.
- billfruit 8y agoIn higher interest rate countries it may be better to use credit cards for payments, since you get to accrue interest on cash you would have otherwise spent, for the 50 day interest free duration of the credit card, so it is like the credit card helps to earn a bit of money. Also credit cards offer rewards program, so in effect, most purchases are tiny bit cheaper with a credit card than cash, and over a long term these tiny savings can add up.
- beefield 8y agoTo me, biggest issue with cash is that it prohibits central banks making sound monetary policy (i.e. negative interest rates) in certain situations where that would be needed.
- uncle_d 8y agoNegative interest rates and sound monetary policy - allow me to invoke the Chinese ambassador talking to Nixon on that one..
- LiamPa 8y agoIn London it’s not uncommon to see buskers with contactless readers for donations. There is even an app to donate to homeless people which details who they are and where the money will go. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/stories-45102437/would-you-scan-a-homeless-person-s-barcode-to-give-them-money https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/stories-45102437/would-you-sca...
- decentralised 8y agoRelevant as to why cryptocurrencies are the natural evolution of cash: https://phys.org/news/2018-10-bitcoin-dollar.html https://phys.org/news/2018-10-bitcoin-dollar.html
- nkjoep 8y agoIn Berlin, and in Germany in general, cash-only is the normality for most of the shops. I thought it was a bad and inconvenient idea at the beginning, maybe I should rethink.
- antonkm 8y agoI make decent pay each month, and when the money shows up on my account, I go "sweet" for 1 second then get back to normal. I once withdrew my whole salary in cash, and wow, the relationship to money is quite different. I didn't spend as much. I felt insanely rich. And I had bucks for the buskers and homeless. Digital money isn't money. It's just Numbers with no relationship to reality to me (and many others).
- buckminster 8y agoThere is a hierarchy of payment convenience. Barter < cash < card with signature < card with PIN < tap card < tap phone. As you move up people think less about the reality of their payments and spend more. When tap to pay was introduced in the UK the banks predicted and saw a small uptick in bad debt amongst the poorest for this reason. More transactions are good for the economy but not necessarily for the individual. I use cash because it's easier to not spend it.
- stuaxo 8y agoFunny, I've been conciously carrying cash for the same reasons. Still i should probably be more disciplined about using it as opposed to contactless.
- botverse 8y agoLiving in UK I can tell this situation is even more extreme. I always wondered why decentralised payments apps in crypto aren’t a bigger thing. This would: workaround big player’s commissions for small payments and stop the tracking of the transactions. An example is status.im
- the_imp 8y agoThe current Finnish solution for this problem is to use one of the two mobile payment services that allow person-to-person payments using a phone number as the identifier: https://siirto.fi/ https://siirto.fi/ https://www.mobilepay.fi/ https://www.mobilepay.fi/ Admittedly these aren't anonymous as the recipient will get your name and phone number, but the convenience is arguably even greater than what's possible with cash.
- esotericn 8y agoThe primary benefit I see with cash is that it's simply trivial to accept. A store owner, market stall holder, hawker, beggar - anyone can accept cash, trivially. You hold out your hand, someone gives you some coins, done. None of the other payment mechanisms are that simple. Generally at a minimum a lengthy sign up procedure would be required involving identification; accepting credit card payments is going to further require purchasing or owning physical hardware. Cryptocurrencies come close (no registration, authentication, etc and so on required), but they don't (yet?) have the market penetration required to function as cash does. I'd say this is reflected in the cost of cash-only establishments vs. non-cash-only. All of the cheap takeaway-style establishments are cash only for good reason - it's the only way to just transfer funds without associated baggage.