4 ms·
I wonder how much of this result is self-perception. For instance, people in Denmark are constantly told what a trusting society they live in, and that that tru
by lordnacho 8y ago
I wonder how much of this result is self-perception. For instance, people in Denmark are constantly told what a trusting society they live in, and that that trust is part of the reason why they are so wealthy. So a researcher comes by with an obviously contrived game, and the Danes play like they are supposed to.
For the same reason I wonder about the periodic happiness survey that makes headlines each year.
- pjc50 8y agoSelf-perception of norms is culture, surely? Society is, after all, socially constructed.
- lordnacho 8y agoBut the question is how do people play the game when they're not playing a game? Pretty hard to answer. You'd have to look at some sort of natural experiment and adjust for a bunch of factors.
- cirgue 8y agoAgreed. All ‘commons’-style games are inherently iterative to infinity from the point of view of most actors, and that has game-theoretic implications that aren’t really present in a lab, to say nothing of the fact that communication is a constant backdrop for all of them in the real world.
- emilfihlman 8y ago>So a researcher comes by with an obviously contrived game, and the Danes play like they are supposed to. Wtf? How is it a contrived game in any way? It's an extremely nice indicator of how developed the place is. Trusting and equality are hugely important factors so you start with that, as is logical. If someone freerides, you punish them. It's the real world example of tit-for-tat strategy, which is (apparently almost) the optimal one.
- lordnacho 8y agoHow is it contrived? Have you ever run into a natural situation where someone invited you to pay a negotiation game with strangers for a limited amount of time?
- ansible 8y ago> How is it contrived? Have you ever run into a natural situation where someone invited you to pay a negotiation game with strangers for a limited amount of time? I run into these situations every day. Like the littering scenario mentioned in the article. And this is a tiny version of real-life when dealing with pollution (which crosses national boundaries), climate change, and more.
- piyh 8y agoPlaying PUBG in a squad with strangers. Having to deal with the tens of people involved in my home buying process and deciding how well to treat them based on their impact to the process and personal bias. Playing Euchre/board games with an unfamiliar group of people. Trying to get laid in a bar.