6 ms·
Nixon was suffering from mental illness and taking daily mediation without a prescription. He was under heavy stress from the Watergate scandal. Schlesinger (
by nabla9 8y ago
Nixon was suffering from mental illness and taking daily mediation without a prescription. He was under heavy stress from the Watergate scandal.
Schlesinger (Secretary of Defence) ordered military not to react to orders from the White House unless he cleared them first. Nixon ordered bombing raids that were silently canceled by Kissinger.
- duxup 8y agoWell that is terrifying / rumor has it not unlike our current POTUS with the military rumored to be ignoring orders. Comforting at least that there are people responsible enough to ignore those orders.
- mionhe 8y agoDo you have any sources for that? I haven't personally run across any rumors to that effect...
- duxup 8y agoI think it was in the book that came out or one of the many sources from inside the white house where supposedly Trump ordered Asad killed and the order was simply ignored. That was the most dramatic, but not the only report of his own people working around his orders. There have been quite a few such news reports.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThis is a more accurate summary. It was reported in Fear by Bob Woodward. “Let’s fucking kill him! Let’s go in. Let’s kill the fucking lot of them,” Trump said, according to Woodward. Mattis reportedly assured Trump that he would look into it, but then told a senior aide: “We’re not going to do any of that. We’re going to be much more measured.” At Mattis’s direction, national security officials allegedly drew up options for a more conventional response, including the cruise missile strike on a Syrian military installation that Trump eventually approved. https://dailycaller.com/2018/09/04/mattis-trump-demand-assassinate-assad/ https://dailycaller.com/2018/09/04/mattis-trump-demand-assas...
- philwelch 8y agoI read that book the other day. At one point they seemed to land on a policy where only signed memoranda were accepted as actual Presidential orders by the rest of the executive branch, meaning that Trump’s tweets and stray utterances could be ignored if he was distracted long enough not to formally turn them into orders. Once an order was delivered, they could also selectively slow down implementation of it.
- brokenmachine 8y agoThis scares me so much. A buffoon with his finger on the button.
- philwelch 8y agoIf it comforts you, “the button” (the nuclear launch protocol doesn’t involve a literal button) requires confirmation from the Secretary of Defense, and the current Secretary of Defense, James Mattis, is one of the most reliable and trustworthy people you could even imagine to be in that position. And everything written about him in Woodward’s book only supports that impression. The DoD was even one of the more prominent examples of an executive agency choosing to buffer Trump’s impulses—when Trump announced a ban on transgendered people serving in the military (which was, according to Woodward, in response to a more nuanced discussion about whether the military should pay for or perform reassignment surgeries—Trump was in the discussion and hours later abruptly decided to tweet), DoD responded with a statement that they had received no Presidential order and that no policy change would be made until an order was received and a plan for implementation was devised. Another repeated theme in the book was the apparent fact that Trump just basically says things and makes decisions and then doesn’t consistently remember to follow up on them, meaning that offhand Trumpian pronouncements that nobody ever put into writing would go forgotten—at least until Trump was provoked into pressing the issue, perhaps by one of his more sycophantic aides. I actually feel just a tiny bit sorry for Trump. I have the increasing impression that he’s a deeply simple man being manipulated in competing directions by everyone around him. It’s an impression I’m very dubious of, because Republican presidents are routinely perceived as charismatic, naive simpletons being manipulated by conspiracies of sinister right-wing advisors. Both Reagan and W. Bush were suspected of this, but there’s considerable behind-the-scenes evidence to the contrary. I’d be interested in any other reports or memoirs from behind the scenes of the Trump administration, but so far it looks like Trump really is the real deal. The only difference is that the rise of Trump was enabled and precipitated by a complete fracturing of the Republican Party, and many different factions are all trying to pull Trump their way.
- brianpgordon 8y agoThey may be thinking of this: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/05/opinion/trump-white-house-anonymous-resistance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/05/opinion/trump-white-house...
- seppin 8y agoMost people say: "IF anyone wanted to invade the US, now is the time." They aren't wrong, but it just illustrates how little anyone is interested in an all-out conflict with America.
- MrLeap 8y agoI'd struggle to not derisively laugh at anyone who said that in front of me. "They aren't wrong..?" To really believe that, you'd have to discount or be ignorant the massive military spending advantage. Maybe you believe that our government is in such shambles that they wouldn't _respond_ to an attack. If any error would be made, it would be an overwhelmingly.. excessively disproportionate response to any aggression. MAD is still in play... If anyone wanted to immenitize the eschaton, now's the time to invade.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoI mean, maybe if you think that an ineffective White House will somehow stop cruise missiles from flying. And the entire nuclear system is designed to function perfectly well even if the entire government is wiped out, so...
- dionidium 8y ago> suffering from mental illness and taking daily mediation without a prescription The reality, given what we know about Nixon, is likely simpler: he was drunk. https://www.alternet.org/drugs/huge-role-alcohol-has-played-oval-office https://www.alternet.org/drugs/huge-role-alcohol-has-played-...
- jacobush 8y agoWell, this is difficult. See, people handle drunkenness differently. Churchill reportedly could down a decent amount without losing his wits.
- philwelch 8y agoChurchill was an alcoholic, not a drunk. It’s a fine distinction, but that distinction is exactly this. Churchill continually drank just enough alcohol to prevent withdrawal symptoms but rarely got truly drunk.
- jasonm23 8y agoRelevant. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/personal-view/11380891/Churchills-drinking-was-one-thing-but-what-about-his-drug-taking.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/personal-view/11380891/C...
- philwelch 8y agoAs shocking as Churchill's apparent regimen of barbiturates and amphetamines might seem, aside from the transition for barbiturates to benzos (which the article mentions), that's not too different from some of the more common psychiatric medications prescribed today. Sure, there's more of a formalized mental health process, where you have to be diagnosed with "anxiety" or "ADD", but that's largely because we now have, perhaps, a more systemic understanding of what conditions can be effectively treated this way. To name another well-known user of prescription stimulants, Paul Erdos seems like a perfect example of someone with adult ADD decades before adult ADD was recognized as a real condition.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThis demonstrates a break down of democratic order IMO. If the president is incapable, as Nixon was in your description (and in https://www.alternet.org/drugs/huge-role-alcohol-has-played-oval-office https://www.alternet.org/drugs/huge-role-alcohol-has-played-... linked down-thread), then there's a procedure wherein the VP takes over, isn't there? Not performing this procedure is deciding to contradict the democratic will of the people. Now, I can see how you might not want to publicly remove the president in a military crisis situation; but the way it was done seems completely wrong, just assuming power without due process, countermanding the president whilst they remain the president .. (as Nixon was CinC surely that's reason for a Court Marshall?) Did the people ever react to that, have anyone punished? Or are the USAmerican people happy to have a VP secretly assuming power, a Secretary of Defence that chooses when to obey orders, etc?
- avar 8y agoThe president always has the option to dismiss any of his cabinet secretaries, so it's not really a breakdown of the democratic order. On the scale of the presidency not carrying out some particular bombing raid is like some minion in an office setting not complying with an order from his boss because he knows it's the right thing. You're somewhat risking your job, and if the boss really cared he could get it done with or without your malicious non-compliance.
- nabla9 8y agoIn theory that's how it works, but removing the president needs VP and majority of the cabinet must agree. After that 2/3rd of the Senate must agree. If Consensus can't be achieved, things become worse than before. Democratic order, democracy and the law pale in significance compared to the need for the nation to survive or human race to to survive in the worst case. When the global nuclear war is on the table, I hope that everyone involved understands that all vows and laws should go out of the window if need be. Only thing that matters is preventing the war, whatever means necessary. Even murder is morally acceptable.
- toss1 8y agoNO, this is NOT a simple instance of "breakdown of democratic order". Also, all military personnel are not only allowed to disobey any unlawful order, they have a DUTY to do so. Trumps order to kill Assad is an example. [1] Moreover even with potentially legal orders, there are orders that present military professionals with moral dilemmas, "...decisions wherein the needs of the institution appear to weigh on both sides of the equation. Whether the issuer of the order is a superior officer or a civilian leader, the same principles apply. In the face of such a dilemma, the military professional must make a decision, which cannot simply owe its justification to the principle of obedience, and must take responsibility for that decision. " [2] It was rather firmly established at Nuremberg that "following orders" is no excuse for immoral or illegal behavior. Up and down the chain of command, every person is expected to take responsibility for their actions. Those actions may include modifying or refusing to implement orders. The consequences may be anything from commendation or promotion to court martial or death. Yes, they are taking a risk in countermanding the POTUS/CIC. They are also exercising responsibility. [1] http://www.ucmjdefense.com/resources/military-offenses/the-lawfulness-of-orders.html http://www.ucmjdefense.com/resources/military-offenses/the-l... [2]https://www.army.mil/article/47175/breaking_ranks_dissent_and_the_military_professional https://www.army.mil/article/47175/breaking_ranks_dissent_an...