10 ms·
Sex Differences in Visual Motion Processing
- 21 8y agoEthics committees in universities should require all studies on sex differences to also go through a Gender Studies committee peer review, to make sure such papers (where the authors are predominately males like here) don't perpetuate the myth that there are brain differences between males and females. https://qz.com/1057494/the-biggest-myth-about-our-brains-is-that-theyre-male-or-female/ https://qz.com/1057494/the-biggest-myth-about-our-brains-is-...
- mantas 8y agoSo you're saying that males are incapable to run studies without help from women (majority of gender studies students are women)? Wouldn't that confirm males and females differences?
- ticviking 8y agoUmm... but there are measurable differences, to the point that we can measure that Trans-folk tend to have have an intermediate brain compared to Cis-folk
- falcolas 8y agoSo, don't publish research results that are counter to our research, because our research results are "the accepted truth"?
- vorpalhex 8y agoShould we run them through the censor as well? Just because your beliefs conflict with the outcome of a study or you don't like it's author's gender isn't reason to strike it from the record. Stating there is or is not any difference in brains based on gender seems an exceptionally hard fiat statement to make at all. Brains are complicated.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cronz 8y agoTroll or retard?
- sctb 8y agoIf you keep breaking the guidelines we'll ban the account. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- macinjosh 8y agoI am not a brain scientist (I don't even know the correct name for a brain scientist). That being said isn't it true that there are chemical (e.g. hormonal) differences in male and female brains? So if the "hardware" (brain structure) is the same but the "software" (chemicals) is different doesn't that invalidate the argument that sex should be ignored when studying the brain?
- ryandvm 8y agoWelp, somebody is tired of their career...
- dijit 8y agoThat’s an odd thing to say. Why would this end someone’s career? Is it “wrong” to identify and test for neurological differences between men and women? Or am I completely missing something?
- presscast 8y agoIt's increasingly (esp. in the US) a touchy subject that paints a target on your back. But you're right. It's a valid (and interesting!) research question.
- epicureanideal 8y agoI believe OP was remarking on the likelihood that the authors of this paper will be attacked for the nature or conclusions of their research, by people from a certain ideological perspective who don't like the results.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIronically, making the observation in question, rather than discussing the actual science in earnest, tends to fall under "Being part of the problem, not part of the solution."
- weberc2 8y agoNah, it’s just highlighting a different problem. Off topic, sure. Problematic, definitely not.
- epicureanideal 8y agoJust to provide a counter-perspective, I am actually happy every time I see someone drawing attention to this problem. If enough people draw attention to it, rather than trying to ignore it and hope it goes away, maybe society will start trying to solve the problem.
- hosh 8y agoThis stuff matters for VR technology and the "uncanny valley". Early versions of the technology that crossed the uncanny valley for men did not necessarily cross it for women, and so women still get motion sick. Some people have tried to study this with transgendered people who are undergoing hormone replacement therapy. There is enough of a difference to warrent further study.
- tabtab 8y agoFor most of human history, men were pretty much forced to be the warriors and primary defenders of a village. Thus, there was strong genetic pressure to react quick (or die). But women seem better at "find Waldo" kind of tasks, so perhaps there's a tradeoff. We are tuned for different specialties.
- AstralStorm 8y agoThe important part is how well tuned. In formal terms, how big is the overlap and effect size. If overlap is big or effect size is small, the difference will be irrelevant for most tasks. The question on thresholds for these values requires further major study. Such as devising a wide set of tasks and comparing performance in real tasks that putatively use it vs these measured motion detection differences. I'd start with catching a thrown ball. Avoiding getting touched by a moving object. Matching speed by movement. Etc. Additionally, it has to be seen if specific training can change those values and to what extent.
- jfk13 8y agoCareful; people have been known to lose their jobs for voicing such opinions.
- hokumguru 8y agoLike the whole James Damore fiasco at Google earlier late last year.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoNo. James Damore jumped from “there are differences between the sexes” to “women are less capable of my job”.
- stcredzero 8y agoI think his position can be better paraphrased as: There are preference differences between the sexes which we might want to take account of when we are organizing and designing technical workplaces. Oddly enough, this was the same position taken by YouTube and Google executives speaking in public shortly afterwards.
- jnovek 8y agoWhy all the wasteful discussion about gender politics? Read the last sentence of the abstract — “Overall, these results show how sex differences can manifest unexpectedly, highlighting the importance of sex as a factor in the design and analysis of perceptual and cognitive studies.” ...which implies that some studies in the past may be in error because they didn’t take into account otherwise innocuous differences in behavior between the sexes. This is cool and interesting, right? Good, then take the gender politics chat back to reddit where it belongs.
- tvladeck 8y agoThat quote doesn't seem to be particularly political. It's just saying including sex is important. Even the implication you read into it is not particularly political.
- jnovek 8y agoSorry if I wasn’t clear — “gender politics” is the discussion of the societal role of gender, it doesn’t imply politics in the sense of government and leadership. What I’m getting at is that there’s a perfectly interesting article which my have revealed a tiny croute about study inaccuracies — a pretty big discussion for the last few years — and for some reason almost all the comments so far are about the comparatively uninteresting realm of gender politics.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 21 8y agoThis line of thinking leads for example to studies on differences in risk-taking behavior between genders, which then leads to people saying "of course most companies are run by man, because men being more risk-taking start more companies". This kind of sexist thinking has no place in academia.
- weberc2 8y agoThe solution is to fix bad conclusions (preferably by showing them to be bad, with data), not to restrict inquiry to subjects that could be interpreted in ideologically unfavorable ways.
- elil17 8y agoIt’s improtant to remember that this study isn’t being done just to prove that men and women have different brains. It’s primarly designed to help understand neurological phenomena like Autism which are sex differentiated. Also, this study seemed to do a good job avoiding sexist stereotyping. This is an example of the right way to do research about neurological differences between men and women.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI wasn't going to say anything, but since you brought it up: There is evidence that autistic girls tend to go underdiagnosed and tend to be more required than boys to simply figure out the social stuff. So there are some confounding social elements there. Having said that, I think there are gender differences and we do ourselves no favors to try to pretend they don't exist at all. Granted, it's a minefield in terms of gender politics and the like. However, I don't think "La La La not listening!" gets us safely and effectively to the other side. That minefield seems to exist anyway, whether we discuss it or not.
- stcredzero 8y agoHowever, I don't think "La La La not listening!" gets us safely and effectively to the other side. "La La La not listening!" -- is generally a symptom of a faction which is about to become the villains in the story.
- Symmetry 8y agoIt seems really strange to me to say that you can push autistic children to act non-autistic just by requiring them to figure out social stuff. I don't really know much at all about autism treatment but I had thought that it was much more involved than that. Do you have a link? I would have guessed that just pushing kids wouldn't work and that parents would be more bothered to autism-spectrum behaviors in boys than girls.
- elil17 8y agoSo signing th autistic community pretending to be non-autistic is called masking and it is certainly possible for lots of autistic people. However, it is exhausting. It makes it hard to get work done and leaves you totally drained at the end of the day. It’s not a fun way to go about life.
- Geee 8y agoDoes this have implications for user interfaces in any way? I would guess that for women it could be harder to find fast moving objects (mouse cursor) or make sense of quick transitions on a screen.
- corprew 8y agocheck out this paper by danah boyd from 2000, for discussion of more or less this issue in virtual reality. https://www.danah.org/papers/sexvision.pdf https://www.danah.org/papers/sexvision.pdf
- dcre 8y agoInterfaces should probably avoid working on the threshold of human perception.
- anon49124 8y agoI would guestimate the answer is yes. Having an animated or visual affordance to locate the cursor might be helpful to many people.
- mnglkhn2 8y agoI thought gender is a social construct. Not true anymore?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Uhhrrr 8y agoCould this lower motion perception threshold explain male dominance in e-sports?
- jrowley 8y agoMen are probably more likely to get their 10,000 hours (or multiple thereof) of deliberate practice playing games, than women due stigmas / social pressure that doesn't encourage or support them gaming (at least traditionally - I'm sure the tides are changing and gaming is becoming more inclusive everyday).
- stcredzero 8y agoMen are probably more likely to get their 10,000 hours (or multiple thereof) of deliberate practice playing games, than women due stigmas / social pressure From what I've seen, female League of Legends players on YouTube and Twitch are well regarded. I may be getting skewed data, as I've only managed to subscribe to a few of the more popular streamers/content creators. (These creators aren't playing solely on their sex appeal for their popularity. If anything, their talents are as game players, musicians, and as commentators. They're also all "cute.")
- ahallock 8y agoThis study shows that video games activate reward regions of brain in men more than women. https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2008/02/video-games-activate-reward-regions-of-brain-in-men-more-than-women-stanford-study-finds.html https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2008/02/video-games-a... "Reiss said this research also suggests that males have neural circuitry that makes them more liable than women to feel rewarded by a computer game with a territorial component and then more motivated to continue game-playing behavior. Based on this, he said, it makes sense that males are more prone to getting hooked on video games than females." I don't think this is to say women don't get rewarded or hooked--I know quite a few women hooked on games--but I could see this giving men an advantage in terms of being more easily motivated.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThat's the first thing I thought of, granted, there must be so many factors involved in that one ... FYI it wouldn't just be 'e-sports' - it would be 'all sports'. Everything from football to downhill skiing requires that kind of hyper aware processing.
- anon49124 8y agoInteresting. I'd like to know why I can't remember people's names but can/have identified faces reverse aligned with path of travel with a glimpse (anecdotally; the brother of a roommate).
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoI can't tell much from only reading the summary, but I would think that any differences might be environmental, rather than genetic. My general take is that there has been so much bad science throughout history around sex differences, I need very hard evidence that something is not environmental before I will buy into it.
- The_rationalist 8y agoThis studie should be added to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_cognition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_cognition
- ANDERSLUCAS 8y agoHello every out there,i am here to testify of the wonderful work Dr SALATO has done for me with is herbal medicine, in the past years i have being going through hard times in any relationship am into, because of the small size of my penis which was not big enough to satisfy any woman, so which always end up in series of breakup in my relationship with women,because of this i have tried so many drugs to enlarge my penis but did not work out, then i decided to search online for solution to my problem and I came across so many testimony on how Dr SALATO have helped them find solution to their problems,so i visit his website https://drsalatosolutionte0.wixsite.com/drsalato https://drsalatosolutionte0.wixsite.com/drsalato ,i told him about my small penis and ejaculation issue, he told me not to worry that he will help me to be a real man again, i did not believe he can help me but i gave him a try,he told me what to do and then send me his herbal cream and liquid medicine which i used for two weeks and my penis enlarge to 10 inches and last longer in bed now and i am a happy man. He can also cure diabetes,H.I.V and any kind of sickness you have. you can contact him on his email on (drsalatosolutiontemple@gmail.com) website https://drsalatosolutionte0.wixsite.com/drsalato https://drsalatosolutionte0.wixsite.com/drsalato also for call or Whatsapp ( +2348103629945. ) This will be the end of your sexual problems and other problems. THANKS