9 ms·
Facebook Isn’t Sorry, It Just Wants Your Data
- metalrain 8y agoSo what would be next great wave of internet companys, that doesn't profit on your data? Actually just data storage with strong private encryption?
- elvinyung 8y agoWhat about something like Patreon? There probably needs to be a social and cultural shift (i.e. not just technology) to make micropayment "marketplaces" for creators and content actually viable, but I would actually reasonably bet that this is one probable way forward.
- jermaustin1 8y agoI look at Patreon profiles for pretty popular YouTube channels, and rarely do I see them pulling in more than a few hundred bucks a month. I can only assume they earn most of their money via YT Monetization or with their own ads in video.
- jonny_eh 8y agoThe few channels I contribute to earn enough to live on. Here's a couple: https://www.patreon.com/CaptainDisillusion/overview https://www.patreon.com/CaptainDisillusion/overview ($11,471/month) https://www.patreon.com/GameMakersToolkit/overview https://www.patreon.com/GameMakersToolkit/overview ($9,882/month)
- noncoml 8y agoIs it your data that it wants or your attention?
- inetknght 8y agoWhy not both?
- metalrain 8y agoData can be used to get attention. So data first, then however they can monetize that.
- zamalek 8y agoAttention is then, in-turn, used to get data. It's a lucrative feedback loop.
- snarf21 8y agoThey are a righteous circle feeding each other and both for sale to the highest bidder.
- dabockster 8y agoI only largely use Facebook for the events calendar anymore. Big brands and community groups use that part of the site heavily for event promotion. If we want Facebook to become obsolete, we would need to create a comparable event promotion experience elsewhere. So far, though, I've only seen inroads into discovering events already being promoted. The real money is disrupting how events are promoted so the customer doesn't have to do any "discovery" what so ever.
- snarf21 8y agoYou've hit on the key, make it lazy for the user. Don't make them go search on meetup or eventbrite like a neanderthal.
- dabockster 8y agoAs I said in my post, Eventbrite can't compete because all the organizations are posting events to Facebook exclusively. You would have to get them to change that practice before users will move.
- Zelphyr 8y agoMy apologies for the accusatory tone but aren't you kind-of proving the point of the article? Keeping your Facebook account because of the events calendar means you place more value in convenience than you do privacy, Facebook knows it, and they're not going to change.
- stinos 8y agoUnless OP uses a dummy/fakse account in a container maybe; I wonder what FB still knows about the real you then?
- codyb 8y agoWouldn't facebook already have his data anyways even if he deleted his account? I thought they were even making shadow profiles of people who didn't exist? So if he's not adding new information the only info he's giving them is by what events he clicks which is still valuable. And then of course if he browses the web with the facebook cookie that probably gives them a significant amount of browser habits, no? Which i feel like really doesn't get enough attention.
- fermienrico 8y agoIt’s very simple: As a consumer, we cannot trust any advertisement company. Their goals are in direct conflict with user privacy. In fact it’s not a wishful goal, it is their business model. Our attention is very expensive and everything is designed around us to grab us by the neck so to speak. Flashing ads, stories and feeds. I cannot, absolutely cannot, trust Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Adobe, Facebook, Visa, Amex, MasterCard, etc. These businesses bullshit their way through with “We want to make the world a better place by connecting people.” Yes, that’s great. So charge us for your service and stop forcing me to view ads, selling off my privacy into a giant bidding war of advertisers. Fuck advertisement. Apple is an exception and I hope they continue to charge premium for their products. I’m happy to shell out money for privacy. But you never know when a multi billion dollar company all of a sudden decides to take a different route. Tim Cook has great personal ethics but we don’t know about the next CEO. Mark my words: The next big successful companies will be around user privacy. Apple has started to market themselves as such already in their keynotes. Duckduckgo is selling it as their main value proposition. Edit from comments below: Amazon, Walmart, Sears, Netflix, Visa, Amex, MC.
- jakelazaroff 8y agoI agree in general, but what free ad-supported services do Adobe and Microsoft offer?
- bstn 8y agoBing?
- marmaduke 8y agoMaybe the recent open source efforts and GitHub thing: if devs aren’t paying..
- noxToken 8y agoAdobe[0] has an entire analytics/tracking platform. Microsoft is likely about the telemetry stuff happening in Windows 10. They're not supported by ads, but the tracking baking into the OS is a non-starter for a lot of tech folks. [0]:https://www.adobe.com/analytics/adobe-analytics.html https://www.adobe.com/analytics/adobe-analytics.html
- dumbfounder 8y agoBut it comes with a camera cover so it doesn't invade your privacy!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tempodox 8y agoThis headline really says it all, there's not much more to add. George Orwell's Big Brother looks quaint in comparison, besides the fact that the populace consists mainly of believers and fans. If there has ever been a case for the existence of Free Will, FB membership only supports it. Human freedom is not proven by the great and lofty choices we make, but by the truly shitty and questionable ones.
- Animats 8y agoMaybe there's an opportunity here for someone to do to Facebook what Craigslist did to print newspapers. What people want is a way to keep in touch with their friends. But that's not a big revenue generator. So the "social networks" put in ads, "sponsored tweets", and other crap. Then users get fed up and leave. (Doubling down on ads as the number of users drops is called "pulling a Myspace"). A basic friends-only system isn't that expensive to run. A low-budget operation like Craigslist could do it with a modest staff. A low fee or infrequent ads could bring in enough revenue to keep it running.
- downrightmike 8y agoThe thing is called "personal weblogs", or "blogs" for short.
- nbardy 8y agoYea, I think what we really need is more tools for enabling build to build there own stuff.
- CPLX 8y agoIt's really not. A configurable feed of updates from friends is, in fact, a distinct digital product. That seems self-evident to be honest.
- hathawsh 8y agoBlogs are a good answer for the question "how do I post?", but not a good answer for the question "how do I read?". Most people want some kind of aggregator. There are many aggregators out there, but if the answer to the question "how do I post?" is different from the answer to the question "how do I read?", then most people won't overcome the technical friction. Facebook, Twitter, etc. solved the problem by answering both questions, along with other important questions like "how do I restrict who can read my posts?" and "how do I bring in my friends and family?". I'd really love to see a resurgence of blogs, but any replacement for Facebook needs adequate answers to the kind of questions that blogs always left unanswered.
- shmerl 8y agoDon't use Facebook, as simple as that. Prefer decentralized social networks if you need them, ones that aren't built around profiting on your profile.
- seppin 8y ago> decentralized social networks I'm sorry but what would the point of this be? A social network is only as useful as it's centralization.
- ddtaylor 8y agoIt appears the Facebook Apology Tour continues. https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/facebook-mark-zuckerberg-apology-reporter-interview_us_5ac53e06e4b0aacd15b80dc4 https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/facebook-mark-zuckerber...
- moocowtruck 8y ago$COMPANY Isn't Sorry, it Just wants your Money; whats the difference?
- fortythirteen 8y agoWhile the general conclusion is correct, this angst-ridden blog post posing as a news article wouldn't get past the most generous editor a few decades ago. It's sad that Buzzfeed News is considered a legitimate source by some.
- truculent 8y ago> It's sad that Buzzfeed News is considered a legitimate source by some. I think it's fine to differentiate between their fluff and opinion pieces, and some genuinely excellent investigative reporting. Why do we need to simplify to "legitimate" or "not legitimate"?
- dabockster 8y ago> It's sad that Buzzfeed News is considered a legitimate source by some. Everyone has a different definition of "legitimate source" these days.
- 0x54D5 8y agoI deleted my Instagram and Facebook two weeks ago after being a member since Facebook's .EDU only days. I urge men and women of good conscious to do the same.
- crunchlibrarian 8y agoFacebook is the most consistent company I've ever encountered. They have never really changed and have always hit the same notes over and over. Remember the beacon fiasco? That was the start of the pattern, the fact that they were so baffled by everyone's reaction was so amazing to me that was the month I deleted my account and never looked back. But they haven't changed one bit since 2007. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook_Beacon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook_Beacon
- GrumpyGrandpa 8y agoThere are many people who will still use all the stuff Facebook releases, even though they will know about the data collection things. The world is becoming a creepy place to live, with zero anonymity