8 ms·
This is what you need a union for. We have a union. So instead of a single country being blacklisted from trade or diplomatic relations due to criticizing China
by alkonaut 8y ago
This is what you need a union for. We have a union. So instead of a single country being blacklisted from trade or diplomatic relations due to criticizing China (e.g on human rights) it should just do so as a union. China obviously can’t blacklist the EU.
A good first step would be for the EU to put its foot down and recognize Taiwan as an independent state with full diplomatic relations. As it stands, no individual country dares do it.
- icebraining 8y agoRight, but the point is that (currently) criticizing as a union requires unanimous approval from the member states, and some don't approve. The article proposes changing the voting scheme to a qualified-majority rather than unanimity, but personally I think it would be better to try to understand why those countries are against it and work to change that, rather than overruling them, which just reinforces the idea that the EU is a tool of a small clique of countries to rule over the others.
- thefounder 8y ago>> but personally I think it would be better to try to understand why those countries are against it and work to change that, rather than overruling them.... Think why US governors vote differently on various foreign policy issues such the Iraq/Afganistan war or the current trade war. Absolute majority is hard to achieve even in the United States.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> US governors vote differently on various foreign policy issues Not sure if this is sarcasm. American governors govern states. They have zero purview over foreign policy, which is strictly a federal matter.
- Brakenshire 8y agoSome country will always take that position because there is economic and diplomatic benefit in taking it.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoAnother approach may be to use secret ballot. The issue many states have is that they don't want to be on record supporting something even though they do, for fear of retaliation etc. But if nobody knows how you voted, you can vote how you want to.
- Digit-Al 8y agoThat works unless a vote is unanimous. At that point it is obvious what you voted.
- emn13 8y agoYou could choose not to publish the tally (or do you mean for votes that are required to be unanimous?), or agree beforehand not to disclose detailed-enough tallies to draw this conclusion (e.g. report only that 2 or fewer nay's were voted, but not whether that number was 0, 1, or 2.) But more practically: I kind of doubt it matters when the vote is unanimous, because at that point you're in good company, and it's going to be hard for some external entity to blame you all too much (and if they do, it's easier to find backing for your position from all those that voted like you).
- eightysixfour 8y agoVotes are required to be unanimous, so a secret ballot changes nothing for the affirmative, it would only hide who voted against.
- LoSboccacc 8y agothat would immediately make me to switch from 'reform the eu' to 'leave the eu', there's nothing worse than a bunch of unaccountable politician twice removed from local issues voting secretly away from our control and ability to retaliate by electing someone else.
- disgruntledphd2 8y agoJust to note, this would be the European Council, which is made up of national ministers, who are definitely elected. You may be thinking of the Commission, who can propose legislation and are appointed for five year terms by the Council (following nominations by national governments).
- propman 8y agoChina used political capital to buy off the votes in Hungary, the Czech Republic, and Greece so those 3 countries veto any measure that China doesn’t want the EU to develop. China is smart, not naive. They can bring the EU to their knees with tens of billions of dollars making them completely ineffective due to their huge bureaucracy.
- kodablah 8y ago> China obviously can’t blacklist the EU. Don't be too sure. Even if not in absolute terms, the scale appears uneven. Still, you are correct that it needs to be at the EU level, if just to protect those that can't afford to stand on principle. Also, you don't have to go full Taiwanese independence here. Simpler measures towards transparency of Chinese influence/demands would be a much more pragmatic initial step.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoWhy would they do that? That sounds like a stupid move causing unnecessary trouble. There's like two countries worldwide who recognise Taiwan as independent, and the US is not among those either.
- expertentipp 8y agoEU countries acting unanimously towards China would mean the "predatory exporter" countries would grab the whole cake, the rest would be traditionally losers at their own fault. Only acting individually the countries like e.g. Czechia or even Poland can get a chance to trade with China. The long term negative consequences are irrelevant as this is perspective exceeding the duration of their parliaments' terms of office.
- thefounder 8y agoIndividually they get the worst deal. Just ask average Joe to do business with a big corporation and see what kind of deal he gets.
- expertentipp 8y agoActing as a union Germany, France, and UK would get everything, some hand outs for Spain and Italy, any profits skillfully funeled through Luxembourg, Lichtenstein, and Netherlands. The general population getting low quality tat "Made in China".
- emn13 8y agoSomewhat aside: it's a bit of a shame the netherlands gets the blame in these tax-dodging stories, because the issue is actually that laws differ between countries (i.e. countries with laws identical to the netherlands aren't vulnerable to the tax dodge), and as it so happens, the netherlands' tax system is... not quite as crappy as that of most other countries. Still crappy, mind you. Just not as bad. I.e. the appropriate solution would be for (e.g., to pick on a particularly bad tax code) the US and germany to simply dump their tax codes wholesale and copy the Netherlands, rather than the converse. Because seriously, some tax codes are just asking to be abused. Plug this hole, wait for the next one... The cynical side of me doesn't think it's coincidental that the loopholes are so gaping. Oh well.
- vetinari 8y agoRight now, industries in Eastern Europe are "not allowed" to trade directly with China, India or Russia. Anything they produce and is sold outside EU must go through German or other western company. Guess where the profits stay. See also sanctions against Russia: the trade of everyone _except Germany_ went down; overall the trade is the same. Cui bono?
- qubax 8y ago> This is what you need a union for. We have a union. So instead of a single country being blacklisted from trade or diplomatic relations due to criticizing China (e.g on human rights) it should just do so as a union. Actually, the union makes it harder to confront china because of the collective nature. It's like if a group of ten people going to the movies vs 10 individuals. The group has to compromise while individuals don't. There is a reason why china is so pro-EU. It's why china wants britain to stay in the EU. https://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/1871455/chinas-president-xi-jinping-tells-britains-pm-david https://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/18... The EU can't confront china if it is going to hurt greece or one of its members. But norway can because it is free to act on its own interests. https://thediplomat.com/2016/01/sino-norwegian-relations-5-years-after-liu-xiaobos-nobel-peace-prize/ https://thediplomat.com/2016/01/sino-norwegian-relations-5-y... > China obviously can’t blacklist the EU. And obviously EU can't blacklist china either. > As it stands, no individual country dares do it. A few individual countries do. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_Taiwan#Types_of_relations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_Taiwan#Ty...
- raverbashing 8y agoTwo dogs can't fight a tiger. Sure, it's harder to reach a consensus, but it has more power than individual decisions. Divide and conquer has been tried and tested, it rarely works as well as the "muh sovereignety" people think.