5 ms·
No. The gyros are more accurate. If it were to use reference stars, through the big camera, any detected motion would be at least one pixel. So every image w
by sandworm101 8y ago
No. The gyros are more accurate. If it were to use reference stars, through the big camera, any detected motion would be at least one pixel. So every image would be blurry. It has to react before any drift results in movement more than a pixel.
- frgewut 8y agoCouldn't you measure star motion over longer periods of time, then even minuscule amounts of motion could be detected.
- PeterisP 8y agoBy the time you can see the motion on your image sensors it's too late - you want to detect and correct the motion you need to do it while you're imaging stuff, before it smears all your measurements.
- PopePompus 8y agoActually, you can do substantially better than one pixel, because the point spread function is bigger than one pixel. Even a technique as simple as centroiding will get you sub-pixel accuracy.
- sandworm101 8y agoYes but to get there you need detectable movement, a change in the image because of motion. A pixel has to change somewhere, the definition of blur. Sub-pixel blur is still blur.
- torrance 8y agoGP is right. The point spread function will spread the flux of a point source (eg. a star) across multiple pixels. You can identify the location of the actual star with sub pixel accuracy if you have a good PSF model.
- rcxdude 8y agoNo, you can get sub-pixel accuracy with a static image. The point is the star takes up multiple pixels, and when it moves by less than a pixel, some pixels get brighter while others get dimmer. This is a common fallacy in computer vision. Often people get to a within a pixel and stop because they assume they can't get better. Most times you can get substantially better. I worked on a qr-code like system where the scanner could reconstruct the code from an image with (slightly) less pixels than 'pixels' in the code.
- FabHK 8y agoInteresting observation. This works presumably because the output of a pixel is not just one bit, but some sort of continuous brightness reading (discretised, of course, sooner or later)? Not obvious a priori, but makes sense.
- dekhn 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_spread_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_spread_function The light is blurred, with a fairly predictable pattern, so if you fit a function to the shape, you can find the peak of the function and that is the most likely center position for the point source.
- sandworm101 8y agoIf a pixel gets brighter, that is a moving pixel, ie blur. This is scientific observation. Any change to the data because of movement is blur. The rules for computer vision and astronomy are very different.
- freerobby 8y agoIn addition to what others have said, the concern about pixel-imperfect star tracking is somewhat moot, as we're talking about two different cameras. The effect on the imaging camera is very small. There is the star tracker camera (widefield, fast), and the imaging camera (narrowfield, slow). Star trackers use a fast widefield camera because it's easy to get a good signal:noise ratio (there is a lot of contrast between the stars and the background). The imaging camera, on the other hand, generally takes much longer exposures (HST subjects are generally very dim, relative to stars). All those beautiful, nebulous HST photographs you see? Those have exposure times on the order of hours or days. In practice, being off by a pixel momentarily is not a big concern -- the amount of "bad" photons you collect during that time is very small.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoThis is nonsense. The gyros are only used for coarse pointing, guide stars are used for much more accurate and precise position sensing during exposures (which is why they are called Fine Guidance Sensors).
- AtomicOrbital 8y agogyros can be used for both sensing motion as well as creating motion (is this true for Hubble's gyros ?), using spinning spheres on each axis of a high enough mass ratio in comparison to the enclosing object similar to haptic ... if so, I wonder if the issue is a degraded gyro is impacting ability to steer the telescope not just to do the sensing
- InclinedPlane 8y agoThere's no good reason to combine jobs for such devices on spacecraft since the requirements for attitude control and attitude sensing are very different. The gyros on the HST are only for sensing, it uses a combination of reaction wheels and magnetic torque rods for attitude control, which are well suited to orbital observatory application due to their high precision.