5 ms·
Is that still possible with one party moving to the extreme? I'm going to use hyperbole to hopefully make my point clear, imagine it's 1930s Germany, could you
by netsharc 8y ago
Is that still possible with one party moving to the extreme? I'm going to use hyperbole to hopefully make my point clear, imagine it's 1930s Germany, could you have an evening out with someone who wants to gas the Jews?
One side now lives in an alternate reality and is forcing somewhat objective people (scientists, FBI) to parrot that reality or face punishment...
- fiblye 8y agoBoth major US parties are headed towards their own extreme, highly skewed views of reality. People deeply rooted in each side think it's only the other side that's crazy. And the media megacorps are playing this up hard, really trying to push that divide to get people to view their reactionary bullshit, bringing in the ad revenue. And it's working probably even better than they intended, since Americans seem to hate each other more than they have in almost 150 years.
- Daishiman 8y agoPlease, let's stop with the "both sides" rhetoric. One party's views have not changed dramatically with time, and still have arguments and discussions grounded in reality. Another party's views are being shaped by propagandistic forces that have no interested in basing themselves under any realistic interpretation of reality.
- oerpli 8y agoThe fun thing is that I'm pretty sure that someone on the other side could write the exact same thing and sincerely believe it. I am not even sure if I am the dunce here for not getting that you wrote it that way on purpose and I'm explaining you your own joke.
- archagon 8y agoIt’s easy to believe things when you’re not bound by the truth.
- iamdave 8y agoI love seeing statements like this because it always stops short of identifying who's who when making such barbarically binary assessments, and I often wonder why that is.
- jf- 8y agoIt is both sides. How grounded in reality you think either are depends on your own biases. From my point of view both the left and the right have become more extreme and more removed from the truth. The left thinks that the right is distorting reality more than they are (and they are to a degree) because they themselves live in an oppositely distorted reality.
- Daishiman 8y agoNo, I'm sorry but that's absolutely false. One party places anti-immigration rhetoric that completely contradicts the experts' understanding of immigration policies, from experts with all sorts of political backgrounds. One party denies the entirety of the fields of climate science, environmental science, and has no trouble entertaining Creationist ideals that reject the entirety of the field of biology. One party rejects our current understanding of policies that reduce violent crime, and incarceration. The other one at the very least has an internal dialogue where positions are based on known statistics. This repeats itself on and on. The fact that there are people who reject our current understanding of topics on all political sides doesn't mean that there is one party whose political interests are completely disconnected to the point where there are no real internal arguments for logical cohesiveness.
- jf- 8y agoNo, the left has recently adopted anti-centrism, which is just a form of the ultimatum “you’re either with us or against us”. Attacking the center to try to force moderates to lean further left. I don’t agree with everything the Republicans believe, and I don’t agree with everything that the democrats believe, and I won’t be told that there is no such thing as a middle ground.
- Daishiman 8y agoWhat exactly are the positions that you believe are being attacked? Be more specific.
- 8y ago
- sheepmullet 8y ago> One party's views have not changed dramatically with time, and still have arguments and discussions grounded in reality. Of course that is what everyone ideologically invested in their own side thinks.
- Daishiman 8y agoWhat was the public Republican position on Russia 10 years ago? On trade and commerce? Deficits? Military intervention?
- sheepmullet 8y ago> What was the public Republican position on Russia 10 years ago? And the Democrats? I remember the Democrats laughing at McCain talking about the Russian threat. > On trade and commerce? Deficits? Largely the same? > Military intervention? Ok sure the Republicans aren’t the war hawks they once were but many of the same neocons are still there biding their time.
- Daishiman 8y ago> And the Democrats? I remember the Democrats laughing at McCain talking about the Russian threat. The Obama administration warned about the Russian threat. The Republican party has been coopted by it. How does that place any blame on the left when it has been the RNC who's allowed itself to be infiltrated by external actors? > Largely the same? The GOP had never been in favor of the tariffs Trump proposes. The current platform is entirely inconsistent.
- iamdave 8y agoQuestion: what if any criticisms of the modern Democratic party would you hear and think are warranted and deserved, would you be willing to articulate those criticisms or are they spotless blameless and perfect as a party? This is my problem with the people who think it's not a "both sides" issue or that both sides dont have serious issues that makes people want to have nothing to do with their affiliations. Not that they disagree with my personal critiques of the left; but that they are typically so married to their party it is functionally impossible for them to find any fault or willingess to critique their side for the better when it's absolutey called for and necessary. Instead it's a matter of"YOU tell ME what wrong with the party and I'll tell you why you're wrong". They will turn right around and blame "the other" or explain every failing of their opponents with vigor, with a straight face and not a single hint of irony or self-awareness for things like straight ticket voting or blind partisan loyalty If you ignore the baggage in your ranks, you be signaled to everyone else it's fine for them to do the same.
- sheepmullet 8y agoI like that as an independent I can’t tell which party you are referring to.
- iamdave 8y agoThat's the point. You're not mean to. It's a meme devoid of any substance with delivered via dog whistle for your side. If the statement reads as confusing to you, because it lacks any meaningful pointers to identify who it's talking about congratulations on being a rational nuanced thinker.. If it makes perfect sense on the other hand...you've probably been drinking too much "everyone else is wrong but me and people who think like me kool-aid"
- repolfx 8y agoThat's not a very helpful reply to a post lamenting how people can't discuss their differences in a civil way anymore. You literally responded like this: Q: I remember when people who disagreed could still be friends. Can't we get along a bit better? A: (you) No, because people I disagree with are basically Hitler and aren't based in "reality" so we can never be friends. One side now lives in an alternate reality and is forcing somewhat objective people (scientists, FBI) to parrot that reality or face punishment... But both sides of political extremes think that. Several people are pointing this out but it doesn't seem to be sticking. Let me try. I read an interesting story on Hacker News recently about a scientist who gave a talk, and was punished for his views. He wasn't being punished by Trump-like pillars of conservatism. He was talking about discrimination against men and was suspended by his university administrators, because even though there is great consensus amongst scientists that women and men think differently, this 'scientific reality' is completely rejected by one political tribe (but not the other). See... more or less any extremist criticism you can make of the other tribe can be easily turned around on you.