9 ms·
Politics may never have been pure and things today aren't as bad as they were at certain points in human history, but I am honestly surprised that people here a
by slg 8y ago
Politics may never have been pure and things today aren't as bad as they were at certain points in human history, but I am honestly surprised that people here aren't recognizing that there has been a pretty stark change in how politics have been progressing in the last decade versus the several previous decades. The polarization has increased drastically and the civility of political discourse and faith in institutions has dropped considerably.
A prime example is that the US is on the verge of confirming a man on to the supposedly apolitical Supreme Court that says under oath that his political opponents have created a vast conspiracy to bring him personally down. If that man is telling the truth, that is an awful moment in political history. If that man is lying, that is an awful moment in political history. It doesn't matter which side of that issue you are on, but something is happening here that would be unthinkable a couple decades ago.
- bliblah 8y agoI think this is the issue; at least in the U.S. EVERYTHING is becoming more politicized no matter how inane. You are also EXPECTED to have a binary opinion on all these issues with no room for differing opinions. Look at the NFL protests during the anthem. Kneel and you are a bleeding heart liberal that hates the cops. Stand and you are a red hat conservative promoting police brutality and the Private Prison Complex. Every day there's a new outrage that somehow splits up the community down party lines.
- clairity 8y agothen just say no. stop falling for the partisan trap and assert your right to have an opinion disconnected from a political identity (even if that opinion more-or-less falls in line with one of those parties).
- hnruss 8y agoIt's classic divide and conquer. The ultra rich have framed politics as red vs. blue, when in reality it has always been (and always will be): them vs. the rest of us.
- chasd00 8y agoi remember during the financial crisis thinking if only the tea party and the occupy crowd realized they were two sides to the same coin maybe something great could have happened. I feel like that dawned on the powers-that-be and the old divide and conquer technique was quickly applied; tea party turned far right, occupy turned far left and they've been fighting ever sense.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- longerthoughts 8y agoIt's eerily similar to the Machiavellian approach to alliances. Something along the lines of joining forces only with those who are weaker than you but can be used to amass power against your greatest threats. In the context of the examples you provided: major party identifies small group making noise, major party aligns themselves with that group, major party exploits that group as tool against opposing major party, major party under no obligation to truly pursue agenda of absorbed group due to relative power.
- chrisco255 8y agoThey definitely had the same spirit and were pissed off about many of the same things, but they differed drastically on the solutions...
- ppseafield 8y agoThe Tea Party was funded by the Koch brothers. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/oct/13/tea-party-billionaire-koch-brothers https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/oct/13/tea-party-bill...
- AnarchoYeasty 8y agoLol no occupy was always a leftist movement and the tea party was created by the Koch brothers. Centrists really need to stop trying to change history.
- refurb 8y agoI blame the media. They only ever cover the most extreme viewpoints. They wouldn't get clicks otherwise if an article was titled "Voter aren't sure what to make of the Supreme Court nominee". I've overheard a few conversations of my coworkers (yes, anecdote) about the whole Kavanaugh debate and pretty much every one of them was pretty common sense (e.g. not sure if I believe her, but Kavanugh certainly sounds like he isn't an angel).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- debaserab2 8y agoYou could take that a step further and blame media consumers then - the media promotes the stories that bring in ad revenue more than others.
- longerthoughts 8y agoYes. Seems far more plausible that the media is a reflection of human nature than that the media has reshaped the way people think.
- simplify 8y agoMedia is not merely a reflection, but a perpetuator of extremes. If everyone stopped using media, there would still be extremist, but they would be so far distant we wouldn't think of them or their ideas. Here's a great interactive explanation of how this works: https://ncase.itch.io/wbwwb https://ncase.itch.io/wbwwb
- longerthoughts 8y agoAbsolutely, only meant to point out that the media brings out the worst that is already in us rather than corrupting otherwise civil beings. To speak even more generally, humans make tools that amplify our impact. Some of those tools make us better at being terrible, some make us better at being clever, some do both.
- RodericDay 8y ago>Stand and you are a red hat conservative can you provide an example of anyone saying this?
- jonny_eh 8y agoWho said that standing means you're a MAGA supporter? That sounds like a straw man to me.
- evan_ 8y ago> Stand and you are a red hat conservative promoting police brutality and the Private Prison Complex. Nobody is saying this
- rexpop 8y agoI am saying this. There's no reason for anyone to stand for the national anthem, these days. Women should be kneeling in protest, men should be kneeling in solidarity.
- disgruntledphd2 8y agoI think you may just have confirmed GP's point.
- boomboomsubban 8y ago> It doesn't matter which side of that issue you are on, but something is happening here that would be unthinkable a couple decades ago. Robert Bork, the man Nixon promised a Supreme Court seat to for assisting with the Saturday Night Massacre, was fairly close to making it to the supreme court. He blamed "ultraliberals, radicals and leftists" and their dangerous tactics for his vote failing. Hardly unthinkable.
- vowelless 8y agoIt's been going bad for a few decades now : https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/04/23/a-stunning-visualization-of-our-divided-congress/?utm_term=.77bcad5bee02 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/04/23/a-stu...
- tomjen3 8y agoI am old enough to remember that the supreme court choose Bush as president -- that was an aweful moment (and would have been so if it was the other way around too). A conspiracy by one side to harm the other, that is politics. As for civility, you can argue that but in my mind that civility ended with the candidacy of Trump. I hold the belief that civility is overrated though, I would much rather have them be honest than civil.
- irrational 8y agoFrom what I've read, the time after the World Wars was an aberration and we are now returning to the norm.
- odorousrex 8y agoThis seems to be the case. It takes a mass tragedy to unite people. Look at what happened to GWB's approval after 9/11! I worry it will take another war or mass terror attack to get us out of this divide we are in. If only I were Ozymandias planning a fake Alien attack on New York to bring everyone together...
- jdoliner 8y agoIt's interesting that you say this would be unthinkable a couple decades ago when it seems, on the face of it, that it's pretty similar to the Clarence Thomas confirmation process in 1991. Do you see them as distinctly different?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fjsolwmv 8y agoHyperpartisanism is not new. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_machine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_machine
- poilcn 8y agoIn most countries in the world either nowadays or in historical perspective it would be unimaginable that there would be a dialog between different cluster of powers. They'd just try to destroy each other no matter what.
- charlysl 8y agoI agree that politics has polarized in the last decade, but I would say the primary cause is the wave of populism in the aftermath of the financial crisis, which has overlapped with, and been amplified by, the social media explosion.