4 ms·
The cynic in me wonders about the plausibility of all this. Firstly, why would you add a new chip to a board, rather than alter an existing one? That would be
by GordonS 8y ago
The cynic in me wonders about the plausibility of all this.
Firstly, why would you add a new chip to a board, rather than alter an existing one? That would be essentially undetectable.
Secondly, why Bloomberg? It's an odd organisation to get a scoop on something like this.
Thirdly, they talk of the PLA approaching plant owners and such; to do all this, a lot of people would need to know about it, from the top to the bottom. I imagine that would be very difficult to keep secret.
Finally, the timing is very suspicious - it comes with midterms approaching, and Trump and China arguing over trade tarrifs; it would serve the political narrative well for China to be painted as the 'bugbear de jour', and this also plays to the MAGA crowd.
- akavel 8y agoCan you delete one of your 2 nearly identical comments?
- GordonS 8y agoDone, and thanks for pointing this out. I wrote this on mobile, and thought the app (Materialistic) had lost what I'd written, hence I wrote it again. Not targeting you with this, but it seems a bit harsh to get downvoted for what was obviously a mistake.
- mercer 8y agoI think many people, myself included, will downvote duplicate comments without too much thought. It might seem harsh, and perhaps it shouldn't be done so thoughtlessly, but at least based on my personal experience it's not meant to be harsh.
- robbiep 8y ago>Thirdly, they talk of the PLA approaching plant owners and such; to do all this, a lot of people would need to know about it, from the top to the bottom. I imagine that would be very difficult to keep secret. Well the bloomberg article said that intelligence sources knew that those boards were going to Apple and Amazon, so presumably (if the story is true) someone did speak, maybe
- GordonS 8y agoBut why would anyone do this knowing that at some point they were practically guaranteed to get caught?
- ItsMe000001 8y agoBecause "getting caught"'s only consequence is that you have to use a new method. There is no punishment, no negative cost to be applied retroactively to compare it to the received benefits. The net effect still is highly positive since while it worked you got what you wanted. Same as in every spy operation, ever.
- GordonS 8y agoI'm not sure about that - this could really bolster the MAGA crowed, and I can imagine calls in the near future for manufacturing to be moved to the US. I doubt much will actually move, but it's a possibility.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoI think respect for the feelings of the MAGA crowd is not high in the PLA's list of concerns. The Trump doctrine is largely built on fictions anyways, and the international community seems to have settled on "distraction" as the only worthwhile strategy for dealing with him.
- mrb 8y ago«Firstly, why would you add a new chip to a board, rather than alter an existing one?» Altering the flash chip would be too obvious. Looking at the flash image (dumping it) or chip (x-raying it) would be the first thing anyone would do if they suspected something fishy. Swapping a flash chip with a compromised one is a textbook 101 supply chain attack... However a small rogue chip sitting on the SPI link (between the flash chip and the BMC) can be very sneaky: it can replace legit code with evil code ONLY when the BMC is booting up and loading code from flash. The rogue chip would not do that when the flash is read for verification (think dieselgate: a VW car disabled cheats when it detected lab testing conditions!) Also Bloomberg talks about this rogue chip being sometimes hidden within(!) the fiberglass layer of the PCB. This is the ultimate stealthy attack. No one expects the bare PCB itself to be already compromised by a backdoor even before components are soldered on it...
- GordonS 8y agoThese are good points!
- solarkraft 8y agoGreat insight. Thank you.
- solarkraft 8y agoI don't think Blomberg is politically motivated. Maybe their sources are. Bloomberg is traditionally anti-Trump.
- rasz 8y ago>Thirdly, they talk of the PLA approaching plant owners and such; to do all this, a lot of people would need to know about it, from the top to the bottom. I imagine that would be very difficult to keep secret. like offering cheaper, gray market source of capacitors to plant owners? that one got out what, 3 years after the fact? and only after hardware started dying en masse.