7 ms·
If you trace the path of individual photons it seems implausible. That somehow a photon leaves the sun, travels possibly weeks until it strikes some nanoscopic
by jcims 8y ago
If you trace the path of individual photons it seems implausible. That somehow a photon leaves the sun, travels possibly weeks until it strikes some nanoscopic face of a crystal on the surface of this object, which is rotating and travelling tangentially at several km/sec, and departs at such a resolved and precise an angle that it makes it almost all the way back to the sun, passes through the atmosphere of an orbiting body travelling 30km/sec, lands on a finely curated layer of aluminum where it is reflected yet again and lands on a square likely smaller than an index card.
- kgilpin 8y agoThere may be more photons than you think. 10^^17 per cm^^2 per second at the surface of the earth. https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/2n6zo0/comment/cmax1uj https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/2n6zo0/comment/...
- drdeca 8y agoWhat do you mean by the double caret (cm^^2) ?
- zimpenfish 8y agoI think that's a plain text way of saying "square centimetres" - `^` often means `xor` thus `^^` to mean exponentiation (and is less obtuse than `cm2`)
- drdeca 8y agoAh, I didn't think of it being to disambiguate from xor. I would usually expect 2^3 to mean 8, and 2^^3 to mean 16 Perhaps too much time reading people talk about 3^^^^3 dust specs
- EForEndeavour 8y agoI've never seen '^^' to mean exponentiation. In Python (and probably other languages), exponentiation is denoted with '', so 23 = 8.
- kopo 8y agoWell since we still don't have any great explaination for the 200 year old double slit experiment, how do you know it is photons moving around? Could be star sized tsunami waves of light trashing about collapsing into photons when finally measured.
- jcims 8y agoThat's even cooler, photons popping into existence like whitecaps on a wave as the energy coalesces to a point after travelling independently for hundreds of billions of miles.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoA detected photon is just a wavefunction that isn't there any more.
- lmm 8y agoIt's just a wavefunction that your wavefunction is entangled with; it only looks like it isn't there because you're now inside rather than outside.
- abdullahkhalids 8y agoIn fact, we do have an explanation for it - its called quantum theory and it explains and predicts not only the double slit experiment but many other much more complicated phenomena.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoMeh. Predicts, yes. But I expect you could poll massive support for the proposition "the standard model is an accurate description of what happens, but not an explanation of why things would be like that".
- whatshisface 8y ago>Well since we still don't have any great explaination for the 200 year old double slit experiment I'm duty-bound to point out that this is only true in a philosophical, interpretive sense based on the aesthetics of explanations. Scientifically it's completely understood.
- the_other 8y agoI'm not smart enough to have that kind of doubt: you really got me thinking! And you made me think of the wave/particle duality. Detection over this distance seems much more plausible with the light-as-waves model; the waves behaving like er... waves and our detection of them working more like radar/echo-location.
- ummonk 8y agoIt doesn’t make any difference - the probabilities would be the same. You can treat it as a bunch of photons (with the expected photon density that the sun emits) or as a light wave that collapses to a photon in the detector with probability given by the Born rule. The probability will work out the same.
- the_other 8y agoThat breaks my mental model of waves (which probably means my model needs improving). I imagined the probably of the wave reaching the detector was proportional to the energy of the original signal. Does that map directly to photons and probability? I suppose it must... woah.
- snowwrestler 8y agoI mean, yeah, it's an incredibly unlikely scenario for a single photon, but on the other side of that equation is a whole heck of a lot of photons.
- aurailious 8y agoEnough chances makes almost anything likely.
- jackmodern 8y agoI really enjoyed this description. Very colorful.
- EForEndeavour 8y ago"You know, the most amazing thing happened to me tonight... I saw a car with the license plate ARW 357. Can you imagine? Of all the millions of license plates in the state, what was the chance that I would see that particular one tonight? Amazing!" —Richard Feynman
- deepsun 8y agoIf you select a random point from [0, 1] segment, then probability of selecting that particular point is zero. Not "very close to zero", but "exactly zero".
- a_e_k 8y agoYep. That's why one speaks of probability density functions and not just probability functions.
- levythe 8y agoIt is not equal to zero. It is infinitesimal. There is a difference.
- Sharlin 8y agoInfinitesimals don't exist in standard analysis. There exist no positive numbers smaller than all positive real numbers. The probability of picking any given real number from [0, 1) is exactly zero, there's no other number it could be. Rigorously, the measure of any countable subset of real numbers is zero.
- deepsun 8y agoHonestly, I don't really "like" real numbers, exactly because they are defined as classes of equivalence of converging sequences of neighborhoods. But I'm pretty sure even in rational numbers probability would be exactly zero, because that's how probability there is defined (as a limit of a sequence, and limit is zero).
- 8y ago
- groby_b 8y agoThe thing is 9 light hours out. It's 9 light hours back. What's the photon doing in the meantime? A little R&R on the beaches of Neptune, taking in the sights of floating diamonds?
- caspper69 8y agoIt's travelling at the speed of light. From its reference frame, the trip is instantaneous.
- groby_b 8y agoGiven that OP - our observer - is presumably on earth, it's a different reference frame. We'll still have to account for the difference of "possibly weeks" and and 18 hours. And it's a really sorry state of affairs for photons that their vacations pass instantaneously. (IOW: I was poking fun at the OPs statements of the photon travelling "possibly weeks", not making a statement of fact. I thought the "beaches of Neptune" bit gave it away, but I guess not)
- jdmichal 8y agoThat may or may not be accurate. The limit of time dilation function as velocity approaches speed of light is zero, but the function itself is discontinuous. It hits a division-by-zero.