7 ms·
The problem here is the ability to spoof caller ID. This should not be possible. Regulations set up the phone system, regulations need to make this change. I do
by phkahler 8y ago
The problem here is the ability to spoof caller ID. This should not be possible. Regulations set up the phone system, regulations need to make this change. I don't care what excuse anyone has, don't care about your stupid PBX or any of that. Caller ID should be mandatory and reliable.
Having said that, always assume someone calling you is a fraud. If your "bank" calls you, tell them you'll call back and don't call a number they provide over the phone or in caller ID. If you can't find a reliable number to the bank, drive over there. The bottom line is that you can't trust anyone who calls you.
- badgers 8y agoAgreed, caller ID should not be able to be spoofed. My rule of thumb is if it is important, they will leave a voicemail with a call back number. This screens out 90% of the spoofed calls I get. The visual voicemail is a nice feature too, I can immediately check the voicemail that is left and decide if I need to follow up, or if it is spam.
- walrus01 8y agoThere is no way to fix the ability to spoof caller ID with the way SS7 is built. Not without breaking functionality to something like 85% of the installed base of PBX and phone switch equipment, most of which is anywhere from 10 to 45 years old. The legacy telco SS7 phone system needs to be burnt to the ground and rebuilt, but it never will be, because people have moved on to friend-opt-in based message platforms like whatsapp, signal, telegram, facebook messenger, and the domestic chinese equivalents (wechat etc).
- ghaff 8y agoYeah, it's hard not to think that basically rebuilding the entire phone system would be a massive case of fighting the last war. People won't stop needing the phone system entirely but it becomes a piece of quirky legacy technology. And probably just have to live with the fact that there will be situations where people are harder to reach quickly than they are today.
- walrus01 8y agoRebuilding SS7 with new modern features, and making it talk natively to all the existing 10 to 50 year old SS7 equipment deployed in the world would basically be polishing the brass doorknobs on the titanic.
- Retric 8y agoI just want the major cellphone companies numbers to show up correctly and everything else can be ???. That does not require fixing all these other systems.
- kurthr 8y agoExactly, If your provider can't be certain that the number is real (i.e. they generated it themselves or it came from a trusted/liable source) then they shouldn't be charging for it and held liable if they allow a spoofed number for fraud. Maybe that would be the mean the end of caller-ID and associated fees, but if I'm not sure that it's useful today with the level of spam. If someone spoofs your ph# to make 5000 spam calls, I guarantee it's not useful to you. Find another in/out of band way of providing caller-ID services.
- nradov 8y agoHow exactly could they do that for calls originating outside their network? Most spammers are using VoIP, not cell phones on major US companies.
- walrus01 8y agothey can't, because as things currently exist they have to trust the caller ID data in the SS7 links coming from other wholesale carriers where the calls are coming from. possibly several hops away from the grey market voip sip trunking providers.
- LeifCarrotson 8y agoThey could not fix it. However, it would be a big value-add to me if, say, the big 4 US carriers could add an out-of-band security check and block calls to their networks from numbers they control but which are spoofed. I get way too many calls from area codes and prefixes I recognize. This would help me get some of that back.
- metildaa 8y agoThere are legitimate use cases like Google Voice for sending caller ID that another carrier owns. Despite that, a basic authorized users list would be an easy fix, doubt that'll ever happen though. Look at the mess that LRN and CNAM data are, providers will nickel and dime for access to data that doesn't cost much to maintain...
- phkahler 8y agoThey know who to Bill for the call. Fix the rest. I don't care about excuses for this.
- prebrov 8y agoCompelling telcos to do that is the regulator's job. Not sure about the US, but in most of the rest of the world regulators come up with new rules and regulations requiring some form of network upgrade all the time – SLAs, connectivity and routing requirements, legal interception, data residency, etc. And telcos have no other way but to spend billions to protect some monopoly or enable more surveillance power for the governments. It's a matter of priorities, really.
- deathanatos 8y ago> Having said that, always assume someone calling you is a fraud. If your "bank" calls you, tell them you'll call back and don't call a number they provide over the phone or in caller ID. I did this to a student loan company. The caller ID was that of my parent's house, and the woman on the other end was incredulous that anyone would demand that she prove who she was. And it turned out to be legitimate, incredibly, though I certainly did not think so at the time.
- BonesJustice 8y agoIf you can actually identify the company or individual on the other end of a spoofed call, please report them to the FCC.
- mc32 8y agoSpeculating, but Would fixing that break things like dialing a local number which is answered overseas without a toll charge? Or is that separate?
- gerdesj 8y agoThe problem here is the ability to spoof caller ID. This should not be possible. Think of incoming CLID in the same way that you do email From: addresses. Often and easily faked. Funnily enough both my office PBX and SMTP daemon check incoming CLID/HELO and drop attempts to spoof their own identity. Its not a particularly sophisticated protection these days but is one of many, many rules. Actually, now I come to think of it, my firewalls also check for inbound IP spoofing on their own IPs. As the OP stories highlight, your mental firewall must make you bail out when asked for your PIN, regardless of how legitimate things sound. The only thing that should ever request your PIN is a machine that you have stuffed your card in first. I'm pretty certain that CVV requests should also only ever come from vendors that you are buying from, not your bank.
- coaxial 8y agoCurious: how does the PBX verify caller ID? Do you know how it works in practice?
- gerdesj 8y agoIt doesn't actually verify it, all it can do is read it. Just like email. When the PBX is told that the caller is say 01460223344 (I'm in the UK) then it would infer that the caller is from Crewkerne in Somerset due to the 01460 which is a designated area code. It may also be able to look up the whole number and infer a source. However, just like email the CLID can be trivially faked and just like email, the lookup in your contacts is then wrong and potentially dangerous. In the case of telephony, if you subscribe to the BT service (I presume it still exists) that will return a name given a CLID (just like DNS for a price!) then you may end up with completely the wrong thing on your display. Just to re-iterate the point: a PBX/phone/whatever cannot ... CANNOT ... verify CLID (Calling Line IDentification) it can only show what is presented to it. Remember this, please: CLID is nominally under the control of the caller and could also be changed in transit. It should absolutely NOT be considered authoritative in any way.
- wlesieutre 8y ago
- amatecha 8y agoYeah I get spam phone calls almost daily, and it's always from a local area code and ANI which I recognize as being from a nearby city. So, it _seems_ legit. But I no longer answer phone calls from numbers I don't already have in my Contacts... :P
- jghn 8y agoIn my case I have a bit of an outlier combination so it never seems legit when I get a call from a number like that. Makes it easier to spot the spammers, however!
- CPLX 8y agoOne thing I hadn’t thought of until a friend who is a parent mentioned it, is that if you have a young child and that child is currently out of your sight you basically have to pick up a call from any possibly local number, it’s just too risky not to. I would imagine that accounts for a lot of the success of this strategy.
- jjeaff 8y agoI inadvertently solved this by keeping my old, out of state number. I can pretty much block all numbers that match my prefix if they aren't in my contacts. Any actual local number is always legit since spammers have no way of knowing where I actually live.
- cm2187 8y agoIf we make a regulation that requires protocols to change so that the caller ID to be unspoofable, we might as well also require to make it impossible to spoof an IP address or a sender email address...
- ajmurmann 8y agoYou mean like we are trying really hard to get everyone to use https and most people here would love some easy to use, widely adopted email signing? Yeah, that would be awesome!
- alliecat 8y agoI work for an ISP. We filter packets spoofing their IP source address. SPF, implemented by most major email providers, helps to prevent FROM: spoofing. Hell, I'm pretty sure our VoIP product drops external calls where the Caller ID matches one of its' own numbers. These are problems we are solving. These are problems we should be solving in telephony too.
- cco 8y agoWon't this rapidly become beside the point? With text to speech software becoming so amazing, see Google's Duplex, I'm not that concerned with caller ID and am massively concerned for aging boomers who will have to contend with nearly perfect speaking bots.
- hellbanner 8y agoIf only there was a way to register a Public Key that only a corresponding Private Key could use.
- chiph 8y ago> don't call a number they provide over the phone It's OK to ask for their extension. A lot of times you can't call the fraud department directly, but if you have their extension you can ask to be transferred to it. But yeah, always call the number printed on the card, not what they tell you.
- my_first_acct 8y agoIt looks like Canada is moving in this direction. Here is a PR piece (by a telecom technology vendor) that explains that the Canadian telecom regulator will require non-spoofable caller id by March 2019 [1]. The technology is called STIR and SHAKEN. (That's all I know; I'm no expert). The US FCC doesn't seem to be moving as quickly, if at all. [1] https://transnexus.com/blog/2018/canadian-regulators-mandate-caller-id-authentication/ https://transnexus.com/blog/2018/canadian-regulators-mandate...
- notyourday 8y agoThe problem is the lack of motivation: VOIP service providers aren't being smacked with multi-thousand dollar penalties per call when their customers spoof caller ID. If Peerless Networks was starting at millions of dollars in fines fake IRS scams originated on it because there's no way for someone else to find who actually originated the fraudulent calls, you would be able to bet a farm that a concept of a fake caller ID coming from Peerless Networks would go away.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- czechdeveloper 8y agoI did this to my bank. They called me, I told them that I'll not talk to them as I can't identify them and that I'll call them back in standard number. Bank was really not prepared for this. They blocked my card (call was about suspicious transaction that was ok) and the transaction. I called to unblock transaction, but card remained blocked. So I had to call again. It all took precious time, they really should anticipate this more.
- grkvlt 8y agoNote that on many land-lines this will fail, as the calling party simply does not hang up, waits for silence on the line, then plays dial-tone down it. When you pick up again, it seems like you are connected to the exchange, but when they hear DMTF they just play ringing tones back at you, then pretend to answer as your bank and continue the scam. Bonus points to the scammers if they actually call the number you dialed and MITM the call for extra realism, only jumping in when you get transferred... ;) In fact, I bet you could program Asterisk to do this for you, or similar VOIP PBX software?