3 ms·
So I did a fair bit of an MBA as part of a joint course with Engineering at a well known UK institution. It wasn't literally an MBA, but the MBA there was just
by lordnacho 8y ago
So I did a fair bit of an MBA as part of a joint course with Engineering at a well known UK institution. It wasn't literally an MBA, but the MBA there was just one year whereas there was an equivalent amount of time spent at the business school if you chose the right electives.
A couple of my classmates went on and got full 2-year MBAs from very prestigious US institutions.
The verdict, both from those who went on to do something technical, and those who went on to other things, is that Engineering is harder. It may not pay as well, and it's harder, but it's probably more fun if you find the right job. My friend who is a PE partner wondered what he missed out on, since a girl he knew from Engineering went and joined SpaceX very early on. There were a few stories about people who got into F1 as well.
The other part is that you don't actually learn a great deal about business in business school. You won't learn how to make decisions in a strategy class. You won't learn how to invest in a finance class. You might learn some things about the history of thought in the field, eg Taylorism. But generally it is not what it says on the tin.
By contrast I built a working radio in my first term as well as a bridge that an adult could stand on.
A really big issue, which to their credit they pointed out at business school, is that it might be better for managers to have domain knowledge in what they manage, rather than just be general management "specialists". I happen to fall into this more Teutonic camp.
Also, note that very few people that I know report taking an MBA to learn anything. They generally are as cynical as they ought to be about it (!) and did it in order to have better job prospects. It's worked out very nicely for them.