9 ms·
The End: I can not finish Limit Theory
- juice_bus 8y agoI commend the author for deciding to open source the code up until now - it could of been fairly easy to just go off the radar and never look back.
- jtchang 8y agoI'm not even surprised. I took one look at how much he raised and the scope of what was promised and instantly knew it would be damn near impossible to ship everything. Games are super hard. Even with near unlimited budgets. I don't fault Josh for closing up shop one bit. He spent 6 years on it.
- anon7429 8y agoGood games need a staff of 40-80 people working normally, a handful of highly-efficient people or a few people taking a lot of shortcuts and have more energy than a caffinated chipmunk with bags of cocaine instead of hides of acorns.
- OMEGALUL 8y agoDid I just waste 6 years?
- krallja 8y agoThis is in reference to the top post today, “Did I just waste 3 years?” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18092108 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18092108
- abraae 8y ago6 years is a heroic effort. Great work Josh. If your life obligations permit, grab your backpack and head to a warm, strange country, lie on the beach, clear your head for new battles ahead on a different field.
- jcims 8y agoFor all the charlatains on Kickstarter you also have folks like this that feel an almost unbearable burden to make good on a promise made. I feel bad for the guy, hope he can dust himself off and take the good and leave the bad from the experience.
- anonytrary 8y agoI feel worse for the people that believed he could deliver on something he clearly didn't know how to handle.
- ndnxhs 8y agoThat is the nature of kickstarter. You are not buying a product, you are funding the development of a product that may or may not ever succeed.
- austinjp 8y agoExactly. Funding any project is a gamble. Gambles don't always pay off. There could more emphasis on this. The mental health of the developer is placed way below the importance of delivery.
- coldtea 8y agoWhy? Because they fell from space yesterday, and don't know that that's a possibility in any project, and in kickstarter even more so?
- jcims 8y agoWe already have a place to buy products from folks that know how to deliver them.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoI’m in the same place in many ways. I had a successful kickstarter in 2013 but totally over promised and was unable to deliver. My June update has a little bit of what “winding down” a 5 year old Kickstarter feels like for me: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/flutterwireless/flutter-20-wireless-arduino-with-half-mile-1km-ran/posts/2204393 https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/flutterwireless/flutter... I still have people demanding refunds, and I’m inclined to make sure everyone is satisfied, but after five years it’s pretty hard to keep going. But to the author of this: you’re not alone. And it’s okay. Some people will be upset and many people will be totally okay with this. What’s important is that you take care of yourself. You are no deadbeat - you’ve really given it a solid effort and after all this time, it’s okay to admit failure, defeat, exhaustion, or whatever you want to call it. In time you will see that the work built character you never intended to build. You will be better for it. The dream you once had may haunt you at times, but try to remind yourself that the dream you imagined apparently wasn’t as realistic as you’d believed. It’s okay to let go, and the healthiest thing to do if you’re feeling burnt out. You’ll be okay. The backers will too. You’ve given far, far more than any backers have. You may feel forever in their debt, but nonetheless it’s okay to stop. Kickstarter invites us to make impossible promises, and it’s insanity at some point to keep pushing forward. Take time off, accept that you’re done, and see what it feels like to relax. To anyone else in this boat, you’ll have to follow your heart. Everyone’s path is different. But many of us fail. Failure is a necessary part of experimentation. I hope you genuinely realize that most people never even try to launch their own company or project like this, and few succeed. We all want to be the one who had success, hit the killer growth curve, and made it through the hell to the kind of traction we’d always dreamed of. But we will not all succeed. I did not succeed. But I’ve made what I’ve made and I’m sure as hell proud of the work I’ve done. Take care of yourselves. It’s hard to admit you were wrong, but it’s harder to pretend you weren’t.
- Aeolun 8y agoHonestly, if you’ve given a project 6 years of your life, regardless of how much money I pledged I wouldn’t ask for more. If you made a good effort and are burned out, you should just stop. I can only imagine how liberating writing this post must have been, even if it was hard.
- forapurpose 8y agoJosh, you have my sympathies. IME, in 'our culture', whatever that is, people like to boldly ignore limits to emotional energy. 'Just Do It', 'live with no regrets', and all those slogans. If you say you're not doing something due to a lack of emotional energy, people will call you a wimp, sometimes to your face. And so it's a mistake that everyone, it seems, ends up learning from hard, scarring experiences. There really are limits and they are just as real as limitations to how fast you can run and how quickly you can code. Often I see consequences that are similar to Josh's - you fail others because you didn't take emotional energy into account when you made serious promises to them. A failed Kickstarter is no big deal, those are expected to be risky; I see failed marriages; people neglecting or otherwise hurting their kids; people failing their employees, partners and investors; and people losing their family's and friend's money and good faith. IMHO, if you want to be honest with others you need to be honest with yourself; you need to know yourself and your capacity. Also, you can then learn to manage and increase your emotional energy, to spend it efficiently, and to use it to your advantage as the powerful, irreplaceable capability it is. Ignoring it is like ignoring any constrained resource, such as cash flow for your business. It might help if we taught people these things as children. EDIT: A few additions
- siavosh 8y agoAs a developer who's not in the game industry I am constantly surprised how often I read that an indie effort has decided to build their own game engine. Are Unity/Unreal/etc really that limiting or is it a psychological trap engineers keep falling into?
- cycrutchfield 8y agoNIH Syndrome. Also, I imagine that a lot of game development is fairly menial drudgery from a software development standpoint, so the temptation to make it more intellectually stimulating probably becomes pretty high.
- _wmd 8y agoI've been researching a design recently and have faced the temptation freshly, so perhaps it'd be useful to share. Having investigated every 2D and 3D engine for the web (it's a nice UI, not a game), it seems none of the existing options scratch my itch: SVG and its huge complex object graph grind to a halt burning CPU after your first few thousand nodes, while game engines that can often cope with huge entity counts just continually burn CPU and apparently have no concept of 'idle'. So the itch is there: just a little <canvas>, a few wrapper objects, and I'm sure I'll be done in no time. Just gotta reimplement D3's TopoJSON renderer, that's all. Of course it's a lie, but at this stage I'm old enough to realize that :) I think the only way many people (just like me) in IT learn this is the hard way: be getting burnt too many times.
- anonytrary 8y ago> temptation to make it more intellectually stimulating probably becomes pretty high. This is not OK when you have made promises to people who expect a product. This guy took advantage of those people, and it's incredibly sad. I don't know how they kept on doing this for 6 years without reassessing if their approach was really the correct approach. I can't fathom that in 6 years, not one person raised their hand and asked "why the hell are we writing a game engine?".
- austinjp 8y ago
- behrlich 8y agoI've been following this project since 2012. For some reason the kickstarter caught my eye and I've been periodically checking the development forums at least monthly. This was an absolute journey. He was attempting to make a game engine completely from scratch, including procedurally generated everything, NPC AI's somehow running in this infinite universe all in real time. The demos/screenshots were really beautiful throughout development. A couple of years ago he had some kind of mental breakdown and stopped updating the forums. When he came back he joined some kind of accelerator and hired a couple of developers. The project never seemed to evolve beyond engine work. The only "gameplay" was some kind of mini game written for E3 multiple years ago. The most recent updates are months and months of rewriting things back and fourth from lua to C++, infinitely tweaking to make the framerate perfect (at least this is my impression). For having no stake in this at all - I'm really unreasonably sad about this announcement.
- anonytrary 8y ago> He was attempting to make a game engine completely from scratch ... The project never seemed to evolve beyond engine work. The most recent updates are months and months of rewriting things back and fourth from lua to C++, infinitely tweaking to make the framerate perfect. Re-inventing the wheel and premature optimization are red flags in software development. I can't say I'm surprised they never got around to building a game. Based on their approach, it looks like they suffered from an XY problem. Was inventing a new game engine really the right approach from the start? In hindsight, looks like it wasn't, and I'm surprised they continued that approach for so long. It's mildly infuriating when the wrong team gets backed to build something. This is why the founders matter so much. Anyone can have a great idea, but it takes the right people to execute on something. Looks like this team was unprepared to build what they imagined, taking funding for X and then spending all of their time on Y, where they thought Y was a precursor to X, when it actually wasn't. If I was a backer, I'd be incredibly disappointed.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoI’ll play devil’s advocate here. The guy (yes, just one guy, not a team) who was building this game dropped out of college to make it after the initial Kickstarter. It’s likely that he was a fairly smart and driven guy, but simply inexperienced both in terms of software engineering and game development. He didn’t know it beforehand, but he likely bit off more than he could chew. He devoted time and resources to things that were not critical for the success of the project. He likely lacked good mentors (and a team) who could guide him along the way. I understand that it must be disappointing for the backers, but it is infinitely more disappointing for the developer who obviously feels like he let those backers down. Hopefully he picks himself up and learns from his mistakes and does a better job next time, whatever that job may be.
- beefsack 8y agoI'm a backer, and am now very used to non-delivery after backing hundreds of projects as a gamer on Linux. The non-delivery of projects, either complete failure or just failure to deliver to Linux, is probably around 20% or so in about 100 projects backed. As a FOSS proponent I'm obviously biased in this, but I believe failed projects have a duty to release source to the backers in some way. In a perfect world, the community will help carry the project over the line, but worst case at least the backers receive something of value and can do with it what they will. It doesn't matter if the original developer has concerns about levels of quality or completion. Please see this both as a general comment to the community, but also a plea directly to the developer in this particular instance.
- vertline3 8y ago"I believe failed projects have a duty to release source to the backers in some way." He said in the link "I will prepare the source code for release" And he will be in touch after the source is released.
- benatkin 8y agoCommenters on the KS page were also asking about the source code despite the author mentioning that it will be released. Maybe they suspect that the source code release be failed to be released in a timely manner just like the product was. If it is indeed a duty, it might be prudent for a creator in a similar situation to delay the announcement until the source code has been prepared.
- Tempest1981 8y agoSounds like the latest version may not compile, after incomplete refactoring. Would be good if he released the full git repo - a previous version might be a better starting point.
- anon7429 8y agoWhat's a procedural universe? Algorithm robot fights?
- anonytrary 8y agoPart of starting a project is in understanding the scope, commitment and time you will need to dedicate to finishing it. Ideas are easy, execution is hard. If there are people depending on you, don't start what you can't finish -- it will just leave tons of people sad and disappointed.
- fastball 8y agoHonestly, I don't think there is a person alive that could single-handedly develop a game of this scope without getting burnt out. That's the first problem. The subsequent problem, once you've realized that, is that many people that want to pursue solo development of a game are unlikely to be good PMs once they bring on others.
- fastball 8y agoI mean, just look at what a joke No Man's Sky was, and realize that they had way more funding and many more people working on it at various points.
- jcl 8y agoTo be fair, No Man's Sky is a much better game today than it was around launch, when it was getting peak bad press. At that point, the prudent move might have been to cut their losses and move on to other projects. But instead Hello Games has spent the last couple years releasing free updates.
- fastball 8y agoAbsolutely! But that still took two extra years and loads more money and people.
- mcphage 8y ago> many people that want to pursue solo development of a game are unlikely to be good PMs once they bring on others When I went from being on a small independent consulting team, to working for a company with project managers, it really blew my mind just how important a good PM is. I had that cocky developer attitude of "We don't need no stinkin' PM", but now I see so many projects that, if they only had a good PM, would have gotten so much more done, faster...
- michaelmrose 8y agoKickstarter isn't as I hope people have realized by now a store with extreme preorders. Its not an act of bad faith to fail and its not shameful. A substantial portion of software projects fail and many burn through a lot more than 180k of investors money. I hope that the author can learn from this and move on to more fruitful endeavors. You deserve to.
- singularity2001 8y agoYou (creator of Limit Theory) should get a $300,000 job with the skills you have shown. You did not fail. You just underestimated that one person can't do the work of a 50 head game studio alone.
- ricardobeat 8y ago> We've written a custom engine from scratch using C, Lua, and OpenGL No other explanations needed :(
- bjnord 8y agoWhat stands out to me is the supportive comments on the Kickstarter page for this announcement. I only speed-read the first page, but they're almost uniformly "that's OK, you gave it your all". One person said they found his updates inspiring. He may not have reached his goal, it may have been an unrealistic goal for one person, but clearly he ran the process in such a way that he kept his supporters rooting for him. Compare that to the pitchfork-and-torches ending of a lot of failed Kickstarter projects.