8 ms·
It’s mostly a privacy issue. For example, if Netflix used P2P, you’d be able to track which IPs had parts of which movies and start profiling Netflix customers.
by jedberg 8y ago
It’s mostly a privacy issue. For example, if Netflix used P2P, you’d be able to track which IPs had parts of which movies and start profiling Netflix customers. That would be bad.
The problem with P2P is that you have to make what you have public. That’s fine for a game update where it’s all the same, but for movies there are huge privacy implications.
- atomical 8y agoIt's a privacy issue either way. How long until shareholders demand that Netflix sell user data?
- newnewpdro 8y agoRight, and the data is actually made more valuable by not being public with access controlled by a company like Netflix.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> It’s mostly a privacy issue. There is a simple way to fix that. You wouldn't want to force everyone to upload anyway (some are on metered connections etc.), so what you would do is offer a nominal discount for uploading, but if you choose it then you don't just host what you watch, you host whatever needs more hosting capacity. Then random third parties can't tell what you watch because what you host is random. This reduces the efficiency somewhat, but it's easy to minimize that: Don't give someone a hundred movies to host, give them one movie and have them host it a hundred times (over the course of a year).
- gruez 8y agoresidential customers have really poor upload speeds so how many customers would you need to have to replace 1 caching server collocated at an ISP? short of having FTTH, most customers would have < 10Mb/s up. a dedicated server can have multiple 10Gb/s links. you'd be looking at hundreds or thousands of customers per caching box. the "nominal discount" you're offering would have to be tiny for it to make sense financially. so much so that most customers wouldn't even bother.
- jdc 8y agoWhat does the ratio of customers to caching boxes have to do with the size of the proposed discount?
- gruez 8y agobecause if you're offering customers $1/month discount to use their computers as cache boxes, but dedicated 1 caching box is equivalent to 500 customers in terms of capacity, then if the amortized cost of 1 caching box is less than $500/month, it's cheaper to go with the dedicated cache box than to pay customers to run cache boxes. (all numbers are hypothetical)
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIf the nominal discount was $1/month, most customers with an unmetered connection would take it because it's effectively free money. From the company's perspective it could even be revenue positive by raising the price $1 and offering it back as the discount. You're also not considering the power law distribution. If nineteen customers have 1Mbps uploads and one has symmetric gigabit, the average is >50Mbps. And the discount could be per-byte -- set it at half whatever the cost of central servers would be.
- gruez 8y ago>most customers with an unmetered connection would take it because it's effectively free money not really, because have to pay for the electricity costs of leaving your computer on 24/7. assuming a modest 50W power consumption for a PC, that works out to 36KWh per month, or $3.6 at 10 cents /Kwh. That alone wipes away your $1/month you're saving. also, that's a third of the monthly plan cost, how much of a discount can netflix really offer here? as for hard disk space, I'll grant it's "free" space (as in the consumer wasn't going to use it anyways), but running consumer drives 24/7 with frequent seeks can't be good for them.
- Declanomous 8y agoHow many people turn off their computer regularly? I suppose people with laptops probably do. I leave my computer on 24/7/365.
- ticoombs 8y agoThere is already a fix for it. P2P over the I2P network. https://geti2p.net/ https://geti2p.net/
- pletnes 8y agoI’m watching netflix on my chromecast or smart tv. There’s no storage to speak of. I’m guessing that only PCs would be suited for what you’re suggesting, and that very few people watch on PCs.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoFor a company like Netflix, the thing to do there is to make your own such device and then you can put whatever hardware you want in it. I'm actually slightly surprised that nobody at Netflix has already done that. Netflix Steambox would be a thing people would pay money for, and then you don't have Google/Apple/Amazon/Comcast/etc. diverting your customers to their video services because your customers are using their devices. Also notice that you don't need 100% of users to upload. Having 10% of users with a 5:1 ratio still cuts your bandwidth costs in half.
- shorttime 8y agoDoesn't (or didn't) Spotify do this?
- bri3d 8y agoYes - there's a paper documenting the approach and metrics here. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/5569963 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/5569963 . It was removed in 2014 in favor of central distribution.
- shshhdhs 8y agoWhy did they switch back to central distribution?
- shorttime 8y agoI don't know the real reason but for myself, I actually uninstalled Spotify after I found out about the P2P feature. There was a noticeable lag when I would play online console games and had Spotify open on a PC or laptop. It was never really an advertised feature and it kind of pissed me off that they would do that without a clear notification. Took me a bit to troubleshoot as well. I'm sure it was in the user agreement but come on, who reads that.
- dfgert 8y agoI don't think Netflix subscribers are as worried about privacy implications of P2P as Netflix is(not interested in sharing data). Netflix already has all history data of all subscribers and can decide to sell/use it as it seems fit thought policy changes. As subscribers, it's no different to have our data visible to one profit driven company vs to all subscribers. Moreover, having this data available publicly would of immensely help in creating transparency among people and bringing then closer. World would be a lot better place if we starts becoming comfortable with sharing our real thoughts/preferences openly, and it would simplify transition to truly public-sprited internet platforms based on etherium, etc.
- jamesmiller5 8y agoIt's a shame that so much modern technology ends up betraying the average consumer in ways they can't understand. I can understand the hesitation. It's warranted, but there is progress such as this very threads response.
- godelmachine 8y agoI was of the opinion that Facebook used P2P / torrent protocol. >> According to an interview in 2012 with Chuck Rossi, a build engineer at Facebook, Facebook compiles into a 1.5 GB binary blob which is then distributed to the servers using a custom BitTorrent-based release system. Above part is taken directly from Wikipedia article on Facebook - "Technical Aspects" section.
- AdamJacobMuller 8y agoFacebook uses it, internally, for code/image deploys/updates.
- arcticbull 8y agoTwitter does too - or did - under the name Murder. https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/a/2010/murder-fast-datacenter-code-deploys-using-bittorrent.html https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/a/2010/murder-fas...
- laumars 8y agoThe issue with using it for Netflix isn't privacy, it's that bittorrent is simply not any good for streaming video content when compared with current technologies already used by streaming broadcasters. * It's slower to deliver video since you're reliant on upload connections of end users * It's less reliable (same reason as above) * You have no guarantee that chunks will arrive in the right order to actually stream data (ie the end of the file might download first) * You cannot send multiple different video qualities in the same stream and have the client dynamically pick the right bitrate for their connection (this is what current streaming services do and why you often see Netflix / Prime video / etc switch between quality mid-stream without having to restart that stream. I can write more in this if people are interested) * It's harder to debug network problems if you are experiencing issues with video quality (been in enough stressful emergency meetings with network guys over the years - I can't imagine how much worse it might have been if we couldn't do a full end to end trace of the delivery) * Time to start playing a new stream is longer (which end users might care about) * It couldn't support live services where the video data is being generated near real time The current methods for video delivery are actually really good, bittorrent would be a major step backwards. However for delivering other kinds of assets - such as patches to computer games - protocols conceptually similar to bittorrent are used.
- deadalus 8y agoHence the reason why bitchute.com(uses Webtorrent protocol) is so slow.
- abraae 8y agoIt's all about economics. Yes, torrents have some downsides - forever they can be worked through at some cost of quality. I might see some delays occasionally for example while I wait for an it is sequence chunk to arrive. However for some content/use cases, perhaps that will be acceptable. Right now the economics favor a dedicated and reliable changes from the source - e.g Netflix. Perhaps one day another use case will appear where the massive cost benefits of piggybacking off other people's resources comes into its own.
- laumars 8y ago
- the_clarence 8y agoInteresting. Could there be a more privacy-friendly protocol involving cryptography? The Zcash cryptocurrency managed to hide transactions with zero knowledge proofs for example. It also reminds me of some cryptocurrency who asks other nodes about a bloomfilter of data, allowing them to receive what they want but more stuff to hide the real request.
- ThePhysicist 8y agoI think it should be possible to build something akin to Tor (or even use the Tor protocol directly) that proxies requests and responses through intermediary nodes, so that the sender doesn't know who's the receiver and vice versa. But you're probably right in that this is a relevant problem, as IP addresses are considered PII (in Europe at least), so leaking them could be problematic. That said, as Netflix already has a contract with each of its subscribers it shouldn't be too difficult to modify it to accommodate that kind of data sharing. I imagine the real problem is ensuring streaming quality in such an infrastructure, as it's very hard to predict when a node will go down (e.g. user turns off laptop) or massively degrade in bandwidth (e.g. user starts downloading other content), and there's not much that customers hate more than interruptions when streaming movies (as you can probably attest firsthand). So given all these constraints it might be cheaper just using a CDN. Also, the bandwidth costs per customer probably make up a negligible share of overall costs (licensing is probably the biggest part) so it might not be worth optimizing this at all. I'd estimate that when I used Netflix I streamed maybe 20-30 movies / episodes per month (sometimes more), which would total at about 50-100 GB max (?) given the right encoding. For a company like Netflix that distributes probably petabytes of data a single GB should cost significantly less than 1 cent, so my bandwidth cost to Netflix would be between 0.5-1 $ per month (I even think it's much less probably).
- user5994461 8y agoThe Tor network has little capacity and it's abusively slow to use for normal web browsing. The experience for video streaming will be abysmal.
- ThePhysicist 8y agoI'm not saying use the Tor network but rather implement the protocol on a custom, provider-specific infrastructure.
- Kalium 8y agoI believe your interlocutor is suggesting that the Tor protocol makes tradeoffs in its design that tend to make it slow. This is demonstrated by slowness in the largest Tor deployment to date. Also, have a large and single-purpose Tor deployment controlled by a single provider would mean there would be no privacy from that provider and anyone able to send them subpoenas. I think that this weakens the privacy provided to the point where the decision to use Tor at all becomes questionable.