11 ms·
He will still be the most powerful single person at Tesla, but this at least opens the door for him to not be the most powerful entity at Tesla. There is no wa
by slg 8y ago
He will still be the most powerful single person at Tesla, but this at least opens the door for him to not be the most powerful entity at Tesla. There is no way of knowing when or even if the Tesla board will start saying no to Musk, but this at least makes it possible for them in the future. That is a good thing in my opinion.
In fact, I think a Tesla shareholder should be pretty happy with this settlement. The $20m fine at a time when Tesla is already running low of cash is certainly tough news, but every other part of this settlement is probably good news for the company's long term health. It is also obviously a lot better than some of the punishments people were talking about earlier this week.
- DennisP 8y agoMusk is covering the fine to Tesla by buying $20M of Tesla stock. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/29/business/tesla-musk-sec-settlement.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/29/business/tesla-musk-sec-s...
- amluto 8y agoI don’t think “covering” is the word you’re looking for here...
- greglindahl 8y agoFor those wondering why, look at the comments elsewhere in this discussion about how the $20mm owed by Tesla will cause them to run out of cash sooner.
- kyle_v 8y agoI dont see how that's covering if he's still getting $20m of tesla stock
- jsight 8y agoI don't know the terms. I'm assuming that this is a new issuance at the current market price and thus would effectively provide $20 million of additional liquidity to counteract the cost of the settlement. The details will surely be disclosed.
- URSpider94 8y agoAssuming he is buying newly-issued shares from Tesla, then the money goes directly into their treasury. So, the company will have $20MM more in cash than it did the day before.
- RhodesianHunter 8y agoAnd all existing shareholders will be diluted by the issuance of those shares.
- peeters 8y agoThe shares would lose value via dilution or via a new $20 million debt, this is just an easy way to get the cash on hand.
- nathanvanfleet 8y agoHe is still getting something out of that transaction. That's like saying buying food at a restaurant is a donation.
- manquer 8y agoIt will cost the company 20 million yes but will not affect the free cash flows
- Phenomenit 8y agoIf it's newly issued the price will be dilution of the other shareholders stock. I guess it's a smallest burden on Elon and the rest of the shareholders.
- cpuguy83 8y agoI'm no finance person, lawyer, or anything like that. But I suspect that he can't just give Tesla money and it has to be in exchange for something, such as stock.
- DennisP 8y agoI meant "covering" in the context of the parent commenter's concern about cash flow. He's not donating the money to Tesla, but he's preventing the fine from making their cash flow worse.
- milemi 8y agoHe's not covering anything, and unless he buys it at the price it was right before he tweeted it's arguably another instance of securities fraud.
- mandeepj 8y agoInteresting excerpt from that NYT article - "The terms of the settlement are slightly tougher than those that two people briefed on the talks said Mr. Musk had rejected on Thursday, which called for a two-year bar on serving as chairman and a $10 million fine." It got harsher just after one day
- mbesto 8y agoAh yes, just keeping leveraging against debt!
- thucydidesofusa 8y agoI'm a Tesla shareholder and I'm extremely hopeful, an independent chairperson could really cut down on the nonsense that makes the company off-putting to some investors. Just as Google needed an adult in the form of Eric Schmidt, Tesla needs someone who can collaborate with Musk. Eric Schmidt would be perfect but he's probably conflicted out because of Alphabet's Waymo. Though I'm hopeful that they'll find someone who can help Musk achieve goals and instill some discipline and sternness where needed. However, it could go awry. If the independent board member were to try to combat Musk and get the company wrapped up in internal struggles, it could go badly for the company.
- freerobby 8y ago> I think a Tesla shareholder should be pretty happy with this settlement. The $20m fine at a time when Tesla is already running low of cash is certainly tough news, but every other part of this settlement is probably good news for the company's long term health. Hi there. More than 1/4 of my net worth, and over 1/2 of my equity holdings are in TSLA. I agree with every word of this. The $20M hurts, but on net, I think this is better for Tesla than if Elon had won the lawsuit.
- kosei 8y agoYou do you, but having 1/4 of your net worth in any company is extremely risky and ill-advised. I hope it works out for you, but I also really hope you diversify your portfolio.
- jsight 8y agoGranted, we know nothing about the person's current life circumstances, but this is really good advice.
- mytaa 8y agoI mean it's the most generic advice you can give. Maybe he enjoys believing in a single company and taking risks. Maybe he's totally fine even if he lost it all. People spend more than 1/4 of their net worth's on hobbies, but suddenly if you have 1/4 of your net worth in a single company it's a disaster and you are crazy.
- marvin 8y agoMaybe he invested 2% of his net worth in Tesla at the IPO, was determined to hold the shares for at least 10 years until they executed on their vision, and has been too stubborn to sell until now. Re-balancing your portfolio after things have started to go very, very well is certainly sound advice, and so is selling all your equity in a promising startup the moment it has significant market value (it will most likely still be worthless).