4 ms·
Because what his theory boils down to is that you can't predict the market. Pointing out that the market is describable by a self-similar fractal froth is an in
by jerf 16y ago
Because what his theory boils down to is that you can't predict the market. Pointing out that the market is describable by a self-similar fractal froth is an interesting thought, but it basically means that if true, you can't predict anything with any effectiveness. (Oh, you might be able to use that idea to tune yourself up something that might work slightly better on a small time scale, but as the market has sped up that small time scale has gotten awfully small....)
Who wants to listen to a party pooper like that?
I've found a similar problem at work. It is my belief after studying the problem for years, reading the work of many other of our smartest people trying to solve it, and over a decade of experience, that estimating software times are simply impossible except in the grossest of terms on any significantly-sized project, especially as you get into the multi-month estimates. Once you accept that, you can actually deal with it; Agile is in some sense a response to this problem. But try convincing other people of that fact. They'll tell you marketing needs some idea of when features go out, that management needs some ability to plan on things, that sales needs some concept of when to sell features. Well, too bad! None of that makes it possible. That is simply an extended explanation of why it sucks that we can't have these accurate estimates. And yeah, I'll play the game because it's still better than nothing.
I'm somewhat less sure that's true in the financial world. Shall we say, the evidence somewhat suggests that pervasive underestimation of risk can potentially have slightly negative effects on the global economy.
- cdavid 16y agoI think the standard model also tells you that you cannot do much, no ? The efficient market hypothesis from Fama somewhat boils down to the fact that you cannot beat the market unless you have information that other don't have. Another reason for the "conventional" methods success seems to be related to their empirical testability, at a certain period of time. The best article on Mandelbrot and the link with finance I have seen so far is on econoclaste (http://econoclaste.org.free.fr/dotclear/index.php/?2010/10/16/1748-benoit-mandelbrot-et-l-histoire-de-la-finance http://econoclaste.org.free.fr/dotclear/index.php/?2010/10/1...), but in French unfortunately.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI think the standard model also tells you that you cannot do much, no? Well, as a matter of fact... --- No, not true. The "standard model" predicts a kind of randomness which is fundamentally tractable. It comes down to Gaussian versus non-Gaussian stable distribitions. A Gaussian model predicts that total market changes mostly come from day-to-day, small incremental changes - ie, a Gaussian model is equivalent to Brownian. In stable, non-Gaussian distribution, a good percentage of total changes come from a finite number of rather large changes. In the Gaussian model, an investor has time get out before the going gets rough. In a non-Gaussian model, that investor doesn't. The last few years have made the non-Gaussian/L2-stable/"Mandlebrotian" model much more plausible.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoNo, he was right. The standard model does tell you you can't make money. You are addressing a completely separate issue (hedging risk) in the rest of your post.
- joe_the_user 16y agoIf by the "standard model", one means the general model of Black-Scholes and modern mainstream mathematical finance, I stand by my original claim. In practical terms, modern mathematical finance's modeling of market with the Gaussian distribution has the implication that it is possible to add together a number of risky items to get a product which is less risky. This was the basis of Long Term Capital Management and this was the basis of the "synthetic" Triple A bonds built out of sub-prime mortgages. The "free money" comes of out the risk combining/hedging approach through the implication that by adding up supposedly uncorrelated risks, you can create a lower-risk financial "vehicle" that still delivers a rate of return somewhat comparable to underlying items. If a bank pays 1% interest and you can get a 5% "virtually risk free return", then you've got 4% profit. Now Black and Merton of LTCM went one step further. They were so mathematically impressive that they got a virtually infinite line of credit to borrow against to use in the risk-combining approach. The implication was they would be, again, getting a nearly-risk-free rate of return and so investment banks could lend to them nearly-risk-free too. Even their massive failure didn't convince people. The entire stable of CDO etc product sold on the same basis, the basis of providing risks no greater than the highest rated corporate bond but with significantly higher return. We can see how "risk-free" they really were. Moreover, it is true that if you can find a bunch of small, uncorrelated risks with finite mean and variance, you can add them up to get a big, tractable Gaussian distribution with a very small variance (that's the mean-value theorem, in fact). So the synthetic bond approach rests firmed on the standard modeling of the market as akin to Brownian motion. The problem with this approach is that, as Mandlebrot pointed out is that one doesn't actually wind-up dealing with distributions having finite variance. Adding up distributions without finite variance gets you a distribution in the L-stable family of distributions, which are in general much less tractable, not having finite variance themselves. In this light, it seems clearer why synthetic bonds turned not to be the free money they claimed to be. One might argue that this mean that the "efficient market hypothesis" itself would imply that markets don't follow a Gaussian distribution. I'll leave that those who still some faith this formulation - I'd personally claim this "hypothesis" isn't even a coherently position.
- pshapiro 16y agoThe determining factor in economics varies as a function of the problems and matters connected to what is inside people themselves. "Because the consciousness that moves us is making a world." A simple example to demonstrate that it is possible to predict things about this society to a nontrivial degree, is the products and activities of Apple Inc. They have great marketing foresight. But besides that, it sounds like they were building mobile devices for a long time before the touch-based smartphone market really took off in the last few years, enough to get it right. I'm not an Apple employee but I've been using an apple for ages. It seems to me like the people at the group had to very carefully understand what kind of questions there are in building something like that and making it work best. Granted, Apple has lots of problems, but what I'm trying to point out here is that by funding and working on the problems in order to get it right, is usually going to result in the best products which if able to be made available widely enough will become very popular for a period of time. As a result, objective-C has come into use much more, and jobs were opened. The question of how to see and predict the course of the world lies in understanding what exists in front of us. Products that were developed by copying others or with ignorance of the problems in the matter, will eventually exhaust themselves. On the other hand, products from a company that had see what exists in their life and generates work matching what they see in problems, assuming they are adept at protecting themselves in business, will be able to be more successful. Even people who don't have any university education can be successful through their knowledge of what is. So we have to be able to comprehend human consciousness in order to understand how an economy will move. Luckily, to understand consciousness is simple, if you are really willing to know. Consciousness is changed for better or worse by what happened to it. In this society where people have undertaken large-scale industrial production on Earth, people in presently affluent circumstances can afford to use cell phones more profitably than without them. But in a different society, the problem that makes the economy exist may be different but the principle through which it exists remains the same. Things are either getting better or worse through what is in the principle. This principle isn't precisely comprehended in those economists' education and that results in lots of thinking that turn out to be misguided. But things in reality are very simple. It's just that we need to search what kind of problems we have inside of us in order to know what they are like.
- T_S_ 16y ago
- joe_the_user 16y agoWho wants to listen to a party pooper like that? Yes, yes, yes! The exact correct point. Mandlebrot's finance papers, in published in the 1960's, refute Black and Schole's Nobel Prize winning theories of the 1990's. Who wants to hear that? Does Mandlebrot rate a Nobel himself? Why of course not... Mandlebrot pointed the way to "another country", one which marketing can not describe...
- Natsu 16y agoActually, I thought I read about someone who bought a certain position in the market such that, if everything was priced correctly, they would lose a known amount of money each day. But every time a "black swan" sort of event occurs, they'd make big money. It was on TV, so I don't have a citation handy, but I suppose that they could be said to be making money off of the assumption that people can't correctly price these things.
- sharpn 16y agoThat would be Taleb & Universa (the true extent of whose success has been questioned, fwiw)
- eru 16y agoI'd like to know that position. Because then I could try to invert it (i.e. turn longs into shorts and vice versa).
- konad 16y agoIf you'd searched for "Black Swan" it would have told you all you need to know. Betting $1 at 1,000,000:1 that today something unlikely will happen is pretty much the same as playing the lottery.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Hackademic 16y ago"Because what his theory boils down to is that you can't predict the market." Citation needed, please. By the way, my good sir, RenTech and others have shown over the past two decades or so that it's possible to predict the market... at least in the very, very short term. We have very solid empirical evidence of that, but some intellectual nihilists prefer to ignore that. "Pointing out that the market is describable by a self-similar fractal froth is an interesting thought, but it basically means that if true, you can't predict anything with any effectiveness." Please define "predict" and "effectiveness". If you have access to order book data, I guarantee you that you will find pockets of predictability. A deep question would be: why is that the collective behavior of millions of agents acting in their own self-interest generate fractal patterns? Can that be derived from first principles? Moreover, what exactly would exhibit fractal behavior? The price time series? But they are only a very low-dimensional picture of a very high-dimensional beast, which is order flow. The mathematics that make sense in financial markets are not stochastic processes not fractals, but game theory. "Who wants to listen to a party pooper like that?" More like: who wants to listen to a pompous, bitter old academic who once did some interesting work in Mathematics and who is now trying to force his aesthetics on other people's fields of knowledge? "Shall we say, the evidence somewhat suggests that pervasive underestimation of risk can potentially have slightly negative effects on the global economy." And airplanes sometimes crash, and ships sometimes sink. From the very definition of risk, your statement is a truism.