7 ms·
Caveat: I can’t read the article. I’m just riffing based on my knowledge of RE and personal experiences with tech. As someone who’s researched real estate, I h
by ianai 8y ago
Caveat: I can’t read the article. I’m just riffing based on my knowledge of RE and personal experiences with tech.
As someone who’s researched real estate, I have a hard time seeing how tech can help the RE industry. For starters, RE bubbles have led to the worst economic downturns. If people can buy homes so easily that they can profit on making superficial changes, then prices will go up far above efficient. That pushes actual “householders” out of the market. Also, look at the dumpster fire that is Silicon Valley RE.
If I’m thinking of ways tech may help RE:
-Actually providing previously unavailable or unobservable information to buyers. Knowing a home will require expensive repairs soon would, in aggregate, help correct valuations. Alerting people of a home being in a flood plain, hurricane path, etc would help.
-Helping potential buyers with otherwise good credit but lacking some of the traditional requirements could help. But again that would probably also make flipping so easy and profitable to really screw up the market.
-Disrupting the contractor/developer industry could flush some seriously awful bad actors out.
-Making rent and RE cheaper would boost the long term wealth of the country - by diminishing the portion of household income devoted to RE. Particularly, rent. Rent shouldn’t be anywhere near comparable to mortgages. You never get to see rent money again. (Here’s an idea: make a “shitty apartment” insurance. People pay an upfront insurance cost on moving into a new apartment. In return, if at any time during the residence they want to break the lease for a “qualified reason” the insurance helps them negotiate the process and ponies exit costs. Eventually a complex’s insurance premium would be enough to signal to potential renters about a place.)
- baybal2 8y ago>I have a hard time seeing how tech can help the RE industry. For starters, RE bubbles have led to the worst economic downturns If that can amount to help, maybe burning it to the ground will do it? Google Ziroom and what it did to rental market in China. Were something similar to appear and get hold USA, expect American RE companies in big cities to burn down within a year. But I doubt this prospect, I bet rich RE boys will spare no money lobbying to nuke it like they did with Airbnb.
- ianai 8y agoI don’t think they’d have to worry. That business model clashes with the individualism I’ve experienced in the west. Their whole apartment option sounds viable though. They’d have some success here but they’d have to pick their markets well. Certainly, let us not forget a rich RE boy lives in the White House right now.
- tim333 8y agoI googled Ziroom and see they long lease apartments and then sublet, and their doing so has raised the cost of long leases in places. How is this burning anything to the ground? I'm confused.
- baybal2 8y agoJust take a look on a very impressive list of RE companies they took over. Besides of them doing all kinds of leasing models, they put a very thick slab of butter on top with add on services, something nobody else can match. With a single click you can: get a handyman to fix anything, order renovations, moving, breakfast delivery, daycare, cleaning, maids, buy furniture, order a restyling, get new appliances, remote lock it, pay for every service, or even Airbnb it on your behalf if you leave for extended amount of time, or do that in reverse while you are on a trip to another city. Effectively they sell life in high end serviced apartments for just a bit more than price of regular rental. They mainly aim at a rich millennial demographics, bit with few tweaks, you can imagine them making up something for US market
- r_smart 8y ago>Rent shouldn’t be anywhere near comparable to mortgages. How am I supposed to rent you a house if the rent you pay is less than the mortgage I have on the house? How do I build a pool of money to use for repairing the things that inevitably break?
- newacctjhro 8y agoYou're building equity with the difference between rent (plus repairs etc) and the mortgage. The renter isn't.
- saiya-jin 8y agoYes, and you are exposed to myriads of risks that tenant isn't either - property market crash, tons of possible environmental disasters, issues with plumbings, fires, damage done to property, gradual degradation of, well everything. Another thing is the amount of time and energy invested into acquiring, renovation, maintenance and improvement of the property. Financially any of those, especially market crash can ruin you for life - how do you want to price this massive risk in rental price? Ever tried to buy a property? For mortals getting mortgage, its such a stressful experience even for simplest type - obtaining already existing and equipped flat, that it easily breaks relationships and marriages. I understand the tenant point of view to try to pay as little as possible and have as big choice as possible, I am also in that camp, but there is other side (and I don't mean some super rich or people inheriting big properties by being lucky with birth).
- bluedevil2k 8y agoAll this, plus you forgot taxes & insurance. Not even homeowners insurance, but liability insurance in case someone hurts themselves on your property. You need to cover times it's not occupied, pay for a property manager, any legal costs when a renter abandons the property and you need to instantly evict them, clean up costs between each tenant. Building equity on a property backed by a mortgage is such a slow process that the only way to make profit (in my real estate market) is to eek out a thin margin every month and cross your fingers nothing breaks.
- lr4444lr 8y agoI agree with your last point, but what is tech supposed to help about it? That's a systemic problem of jobs continually concentrating in dense urban cores where land is simply more scarce.
- humanrebar 8y agoTech could absolutely help jobs and services decentralize. But we wouldn't call it "real estate tech". If Google really wanted to make a dent here, getting serious about remote first employment at Google would be a game changer even if the enabling tech never made it into the Google suite.
- mhjas 8y agoUnfortunately I think that is unlikely. Real estate gains and career prospects from centralization is essentially part of the compensation package for large tech companies today.
- leetcrew 8y ago> Rent shouldn’t be anywhere near comparable to mortgages? why not? rent probably should not be egregiously larger than the mortgage payment, but rent needs to at least price in the risks related to owning a property long term.
- lallysingh 8y agoThe markets for owners vs renters is different. People with the means will buy if they have reasons for staying in one place for a long time. They will rent if they don't. That can depend on the local economy, schools, livability of the area, industry trends, etc.
- anoncoward111 8y agoHere on Long Island, NY, renting with one roommate is infinitely more profitable than owning a house: Renting = $1,900 a month for brand new construction, centrally located 1br apartment including utilities Owning = $3,300 a month for 2br dilapidated house, inclusive of property tax, home owners insurance, massive utility bill, and I haven't even factored in repairs of equipment from before 1960 Sure, you could rent out your basement and your bedroom for an extra $1500, but now you are running a hotel and have to report that income :)
- voicedYoda 8y agoJust as a slight clarification, if you set yourself up to rent part of the house, you could convert ownership of the house to an llc, or soon legal entity, and then that organization collects rent from you and tenant, which pays the mortgage, property taxes, utilities, etc. Do this only if you intend to rent portions out, as it can reduce liability. Ymmv and ianaa
- anoncoward111 8y agoNice house hacking! Just be sure that you can quickly and easily prove that you as a personal entity still have ownership over the deed to the property, which is owned by your sole-partner LLC or etc
- arkades 8y ago> Alerting people of a home being in a flood plain, hurricane path, etc would help. I would pay for a service that gives me a reasonable 10-50 year estimate of climate change impacts on a given real estate area. I haven't been able to find this so far. Presumably very large RE investors have access to such information, but for the average consumer...?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIt seems unreasonable to expect any human to be able to reasonably predict anything 10+ years into the future with the kind of accuracy needed to provide climate change impacts of a given area. Only easy one is probably water levels rising causing places next to the ocean to go underwater. Buy at a decent altitude, higher up than surrounding areas where water can drain into, and that has access to a water and food source which seem resilient. But who knows when a fire or flood or earthquake or whatever will come ruin your plan.
- emodendroket 8y agoI bought my home through Redfin and I was pretty happy with it. I can also definitely see the appeal of OpenDeal's model of buying your house and then reselling it; it's like the house version of a dealership trade-in. You may not be getting the best deal but you're skipping the hassle.