6 ms·
That destroys the point of the whole "decentralized systems" thing. Crypto has always kind of looked like a solution in search of a problem, IMO. What is it so
by bobthepanda 8y ago
That destroys the point of the whole "decentralized systems" thing.
Crypto has always kind of looked like a solution in search of a problem, IMO. What is it solving that isn't some sort of political science question?
- sparkie 8y agoIt's solving the problem that currency, up until now, has never had a finite supply, and that even currencies with limited supply could be forged, seized or inflated until they became worthless. Bitcoin is the first money ever, which nobody can create beyond the very predictable initial distribution programmed into the system. Gresham's law roughly states that when two kinds of money exist, people will stash the good money, and will trade with the bad money until it becomes useless. It's been proven time over throughout history. You only need to look at the gold rush that happened during the last financial crisis. Given that Bitcoin is the best money that has ever existed, then anyone who is paying attention is stashing it while they're trading with anything else. The next recession won't be a rush for gold.
- pjc50 8y agoThis isn't even true for bitcoin; anyone can fork it, there has been at least one fork already, and the miners can easily decide to hardfork across to keep the block rewards going when they run out. It doesn't help that the miners are increasingly cartelised.
- beaner 8y agoHard forking Bitcoin doesn't increase Bitcoin's supply.
- sparkie 8y agoIf miners attempted to hard-fork in inflation, do you think users would follow their chain? It was already attempted on the first halving from 50BTC to 25BTC. Guess which one won? Miners don't make the rules. They enforce them. The network of economic users decide the rules that they are willing to validate in their software client.
- bduerst 8y agoThis fact makes bitcoin even more dangerous. Miners are only going to fork the network in a direction that benefits them, sometimes at the expense of everyone else and the network. This is called tragedy of the commons, and the block-size debacle is an example of that.
- sparkie 8y agoThe only direction that benefits miners is the direction where they have the maximum potential for profit by selling the coins they earn through transaction fees. This will inevitably be the network which most people are transacting on. The actual incentives are a bit skewed currently because transaction fees are dwarfed by the block subsidy.
- bduerst 8y agoRiiiight, and fisherman only fish the species that are most prevalent in the sea. You don't know how tragedy of the commons works, do you?
- simias 8y agoYou can't just make wild claims like that without providing a coherent argument and expect people to blindly believe you. I actually had to re-read your comment a few times to figure out if it was some kind of satire of cryptozealotry. In your comment you state, without any source or reasoning behind your claims, that: - Finite supply of currency is good - Inflation is bad - Bitcoin is "best money" - Everything else is bad money What about the fact that deflation means that people are incentivized to stash money instead of spending it (something you admit doing yourself)? What about the fact that it means that the rich becomes richer while doing nothing while the poor can't make money because nobody wants to spend it? Don't let greed blind you. How does society work if your main form of currency is meant to be "hodled" and people who spend it are ridiculed as suckers? Bitcoin is currently near-useless as a currency because it's mostly an asset for speculation. How is that going to change in the value of bitcoins keeps increasing by virtue of being artificially capped? That's what kills cryptocurrencies: you need the deflation to reward early adopters but in the end it means that your currency is effectively unusable as a currency.
- sparkie 8y ago> In your comment you state, without any source or reasoning behind your claims, that: > - Finite supply of currency is good > - Inflation is bad > - Bitcoin is "best money" > - Everything else is bad money My arguments aren't based on feels about what one might think as "good" or "bad", but just based on the undeniable fact that people are self interested. If it's a choice between holding my assets in a currency where they won't be devalued, and holding them in another where they will lose 1% or 2% annually, which am I going to chose? The people who care about the rich getting richer are really complaining that they aren't getting richer by the same ratio. They obviously won't if they think that the second option was a better choice. The rich already get richer. If they have money, they will invest it into other assets which offer them various levels of return, some more risky than others. People without money are traditionally excluded from these kinds of investment, and thus, their only for saving for the future is to put money into a bank account and let it have less purchasing power than the labour they put in to earn it in the first place. Bitcoin changes that completely. Anyone, even low-income earners, can put small amounts into Bitcoin and it will retain value in the longer term. They can completely shift their mental mode from high time preference into low time preference and begin investing in their own future. The idea that everyone needs to spend spend spend is not grounded in reality. It's necessary for governments to continue their bad policy making which only enriches the elite who print the money. High time preference is the source of inefficiencies, cutting corners and high debt. People should save rather than spend. People should spend more wisely in ways that are an investment into their own, and their descendants future, rather than borrowing from their children's labour through debt.
- nradov 8y agoWhat you're describing as a "problem" with regular currency isn't actually a problem at all. The ability to control the money supply and scale it up or down based on economic conditions is a valuable feature.
- hndamien 8y agoValuable to whom?
- m-i-l 8y ago> "Gresham's law ... Bitcoin is the best money that has ever existed" I think Gresham's Law has been showing us the exact opposite point with cryptocurrencies as a whole - cryptocurrencies are the "bad money" with no inherent value, i.e. no use case yet other than speculation, so people have been trading them away for "good money" (fiat), leading most cryptocurrencies on a long term trend towards zero. The only thing propping up Bitcoin is its pyramid scheme design (disproportionately rewarding early adopters and requiring them to constantly seek new scheme members to counteract its deflationary nature), so the small number of people with almost all the wealth are massively incentivised to protect their wealth by investing in pro-crypto projects, pro-crypto press etc. to convince as many people as possible that it is the "the future of money", "the best money that has ever existed", etc.
- beaner 8y ago> That destroys the point of the whole "decentralized systems" thing. Why? > What is it solving that isn't some sort of political science question? - Why can't you send money between PayPal and Venmo, even though they're products owned by the same company? It's because existing money is a system that you are permitted to use, under specific restrictions applied by government. Cryptocurrencies are open protocols. One thing they solve is getting around these restrictions. One day, all of our payment apps will be interoperable, and they will be enabled by crypto. - You do not have to worry about your money being stolen by means like Civil Asset Forfeiture, which is literally legalized highway robbery. Crypto has similar properties to cash, while not being as susceptible to physical theft. - Inflation is controlled by algorithm, not arbitrary policy. (Depending on your economic views, you may think this is a fault. I don't, but that's me. At the very least, it enables us to see what will happen to such a currency.) - You can remit small amounts of money instantly at low-to-no cost. This will be huge for the developing world. (Scaling is not solved, but I also don't think that bringing it up is an interesting counterargument. Computer scientists have been scaling systems for the last 60 years. We're pretty good at it, and it's happening now with the Lightning network. There is no conceptual blocker to scaling cryptocurrency. The hard problem was digital scarcity, which has been solved, which is why crypto is now a thing at all.) - Many people in many parts of the world do not have the ability to interact with traditional finance. They do not have the means to open bank accounts or connect to the global economy. They cannot invest, they cannot lend, earn interest, etc. If they have cash, it is in the form of money under their mattress or in their pocket. They are left out. Many of these parts of the world leapfrogged PCs entirely, and went straight to smartphones. They will make a similar leapfrog in finance, bypassing traditional banks entirely. Before Wells Fargo opens in sudan, providing farmers with loans and a way to save, they will have it on their phones in the form of crypto wallets. This will unleash unprecedented economic velocity, helping to raise the half of the world that is left out into a higher quality of life. - Low-to-no inflation saves common people from the hidden tax. A system designed by bankers for their own profit. The Federal Reserve is literally a feedback system that makes banks richer and average people poorer, like inflating air into a balloon and watching points on the top and bottom separate. I think, actually, that the whole balloon is rising, so it could be worse. Generally, quality of life has gotten better everywhere over time. But the people on the bottom still lack power and equality in a large part due to the distance between them and the richest increasing over time, caused by this mechanism. There are many things that crypto solves.