3 ms·
> Or are the antibiotics for dealing with an actual ruptured appendix If your appendix ruptures, it is life threatening and has to come out. Most appendix rem
by gwbas1c 8y ago
> Or are the antibiotics for dealing with an actual ruptured appendix
If your appendix ruptures, it is life threatening and has to come out.
Most appendix removals happen before the appendix ruptures. The conclusion of the study is that high doses of antibiotics is an effective way to prevent the appendix from rupturing without surgery.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI still have the question: what about the 'stone'? Do antibiotics cure that somehow? Or is that the reason that 30% of those treated with antibiotics ultimately have the surgery?
- takeda 8y agoI thing it is the second one. I don't see antibiotic helping with that.
- VerticalVideo 8y agoJust a guess, but maybe they can do the same thing they do with kidney stones with shock-wave therapy, though I feel like they would mention that somewhere in wiki or the article.
- robterrell 8y agoOne of my kids had his appendix out last year, and I asked a similar question. My recollection was: Blockages can form and resolve on their own -- it's possible he'd had blockages before, felt pain, but they resolved before an infection could occur. You could be having this happen right now, but it could resolve later in the day and you never notice anything. Or the blockage could be too severe and never resolve on its own.
- philsmith35 8y agothe actual study states that presence of a stone was an exclusion criteria
- testplzignore 8y agoI think what he is saying is that "viral infection, parasites, gallstone, or tumors" doesn't include bacteria.
- paavoova 8y ago> If your appendix ruptures, it is life threatening and has to come out. It is life-threatening, but it most certainly doesn't have to come out for full recovery. In some cases, it's impossible to remove due to the infection (inflammation, abscess) obfuscating its location. The treatment is aggressive intravenous antibiotics for a period of time, then oral antibiotics. The statics for recurrence after recovery I've had quoted as between 1/4 and 1/3 lifetime chance, and patients are advised on proactive surgery to remove what remains of the appendix.
- lgunsch 8y agoYes, this is exactly what happened to me. The only exception is that the nurse told me if they don't find pill antibiotics strong enough then I'd require daily intervenous antibiotics. However, I was glad they did find some.
- ArchTypical 8y ago> The conclusion of the study is that high doses of antibiotics is an effective way to prevent the appendix from rupturing without surgery. I've been through a few million dollar surgeries and I had my appendix out as well. When you get a blocked appendix (appendicitis induced), you create scar tissue from the inevitably distended bile duct. Now you have an increased chance of it occurring again, and a weaker duct (scar tissue is generally weaker). This snowballs. Removal is the safe course after the first onset. This study assumes 2 things. First, that no major damage is done over the course of appendicitis attack(s). Second, the patient is compliant with a dietary restriction and an antibiotic course. Yes, you don't NEED to have your appendix out after the first attack if you eat right. The chances that a patient is compliant is less than 50% This is just a medical reality. People who take blood thinners have to be monitored, more for compliance than anything else, and there's a whole industry to the more dangerous conditions than appendicitis.
- gwbas1c 8y agoNo, it's not a medical reality. It's a perception in the American system. Europe currently follows the high dosage antibiotic approach.
- ArchTypical 8y agoI would agree that it's "not a medical reality", in that it does apply only to the USA.