9 ms·
Europe Finally Has an Excuse to Challenge the Dollar
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IBM 8y agoSanctions are one of the most powerful tools in the US toolbox short of war. In fact it's more important than war when dealing with Great Power adversaries because they have nukes. The US should aggressively block any attempt to get around it. Trump shouldn't have pulled out of the Iran deal, but preserving that power for the future is more important. Here's a good article about OFAC, the Treasury Department group that handles sanctions: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-sanctions-insight-idUSBREA3D1O820140414 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-sanctions-insight-idU...
- curiousgal 8y agoI've always found it fascinating to link the stand of an entire country to a single person or a group of people. For instance when we say, the U.S. has imposed X sanctions, it's weird to think that it's simply the work of a small group of people. I am doing an awful job at wording my thought, but what I am trying to say that putting a human face/name on an entire country's action makes it interesting.
- RangerScience 8y agoI think I get (and agree) with that you're putting down. Maybe this phrasing? : "It's weird to think that the actions of the few who wield the most - but not the majority - of the power in the US are talked about as if they are the US." Sometimes, we narrow this down; we say, the X administration. But is that accurate? Does it convey the emotional reality? Maybe we should say; [Person], acting in their duty as [Role] on behalf of the US, has [action]. But, does this have the inevitable effect of distancing those people from the country that has given them power? More than half the voting-power of the US voted for Trump, and some portion of that power is then invested in these decisions; at the same time, less than half the voting-power of the US voted for trump, and some portion of that power is then disinvested in those decisions. It's almost like we need different words to describe the national entity when that entity is democratic than the words we inherited from monarchies. Maybe we take a page from swarms - perhaps instead of "The US imposed sanctions", we say, "From the US emerged sanctions", or, "Those empowered by the US imposed sanctions". But, none of these use as few words as: "the US did X". Brevity wins.
- XorNot 8y agoYou are describing a problem I see often when people try to discuss international relations - they get addicted to using grouping or personal terms to describe truly massive numbers of people, organizations and agendas which at an extremely high level can perhaps some some simple motivation ascribed to them.
- chme 8y agoWelcome the representative democracy. When someone wants to know how americans currently think and look like, then they just take a look at their current president. /s
- devoply 8y agoSanctions are a type of war on civilians. Great power adversaries are no worse than allies like Saudi Arabia. American unilateralism is evil, and it has to end. The sooner the better!
- sbierwagen 8y agoRussia invades another country. You are the President of the US. Your options are: 1.) Do nothing. Poland, and the parts of Germany that used to be East Germany, might not like the long term consequences of this plan. 2.) Start a nuclear war, killing hundreds of millions of people. A few disadvantages to this plan as well. 3.) Economic sanctions. You can certainly say this will kill people by way of depressing GDP growth. Will it kill fewer people than a full nuclear exchange between the US and Russia?
- namirez 8y agoYou forgot to mention the 4th scenario: turning Iran into another Afghanistan or Iraq. smh!
- gdfasfklshg4 8y agoThe USA invades at least as many countries as Russia.
- d__k 8y agoPurely statistically you cannot even compare them: |US invasions| >> |Russia invasions| But maybe it is because of the difference in GDP: |US invasions| / GDP ~= |Russia invasions| / GDP
- S4M 8y agoSo you're saying that having a large GDP is a justification to invade other countries?
- 8y ago
- sschueller 8y agoWhy does the US get to unilaterally decide who gets sanctioned and who doesn't? Europe has a lot more to loose on an unstable Iran than the US and can't risk deals being undone because the US has a new regime every 4 years.
- IBM 8y agoThe US gets to unilaterally decide because they've underwritten global stability and security in the post-WW2 era. Europe being one of the biggest beneficiaries of that. And this isn't even me being a jingoistic American, I was born in Canada.
- david927 8y agoThat's still you being a jingoistic American.
- bambax 8y agoThe Iran problem was created by the US (and the UK) when a CIA-backed coup deposed Mosaddegh in 1953.
- teekert 8y agoThis is just laughable, start with reading "Confessions of an economic hitman", go down the rabbit hole from there.
- partycoder 8y agoImagine a wrestling match. 2 wrestlers fight for some good amount of time. When they're tired enough, a 3rd wrestler gets in and beats both. That was World War II for the most part. After World War II, most of the world was destroyed except for the US. After the war, the US never left. Overseas bases still exist in Germany, Japan and many other places. They had everyone adopt a financial system (Bretton Woods) which was largely abused making the US absurdly rich for a few decades... highways, higher education for a bunch of people, space exploration, absurd wars thousands of miles away, a gigantic navy and air force, you name it. After other countries realized it was a scam (aka "exorbitant privilege"), this golden era ended and the US started to slowly meet reality, rapidly accumulating debt. The inevitable fate of the US is to collapse in the same way the Soviet Union did in 1989. This will likely happen before 2050 and you read it first in the comments section of HN. Once the US collapses, the Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance will be worthless and South America will be taken apart in a giant pinata party starting by the Argentinean Patagonia.
- smnrchrds 8y ago> The US should aggressively block any attempt to get around it. The ubiquity of US dollars in international trade allows US to torpedo the economy of any country it so desires. It is like the US has a kill switch to shut down any economy it wishes to. But the only reason the rest of the world plays along and allows the kill switch to exist is that they trust the US to use it responsibly and only in extreme circumstances. Now with the erosion of that trust, it is to be expected for the world to move towards eliminating that threat.
- bambax 8y agoI disagree. I think the only reason the rest of the world plays along is because the rest of the world is weak. The US are simply a bully. But it's true that the advent of Trump makes the bullying more difficult to accept because it's now absurd and incoherent; if some other powers unite and find a way to resist the bullying, then at least some good will have come out of trumpism.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoI don't think we've been a bully so much as the rich kid that indirectly paid people to be their friend. I think Trump is accurate in pointing out that many of our arrangements are detrimental to the US on the first level, but at the same time those arrangements, and the unstated threat of their removal, is what gave the US the power to arbitrarily exert its influence. This became even more true as other nations started to take those arrangements as a given and became reliant upon them. In the grand scheme of things I'm also happy the rest of the world seems to be becoming less dependent on the US. It removes single point of failure scenarios. Economies and nations keeping each other more at arm's reach would help ensure the world acts in a more democratic fashion while simultaneously also providing insulation against the failing of any given nation's poor decisions - be those social, political, economic, or military.
- IBM 8y ago>It removes single point of failure scenarios. Economies and nations keeping each other more at arm's reach would help ensure the world acts in a more democratic fashion while simultaneously also providing insulation against the failing of any given nation's poor decisions - be those social, political, economic, or military. This is completely ahistorical. You're describing the "balance of power" system that governed international relations and we know what happened: hundreds of years of European wars culminating in two world wars.
- nickik 8y agoThis is just factually wrong. There is great beliefe in some groups about economic sanctions but economists and political sientists mostly agree about this, it not. The data is pretty clear on this, it does not lead to regimn change or whatever else the country wants. Now people will claim that the Iran deal is a counterexample, but it is not. I was the US who realied that their sanction had no effect on the nuclear program was going fast. The US then compromised even more. The US is very good at making sanctions, but bad at removing them. The way the do it in the Iran case is directly and clearly against all the international laws the US claims to stand for. Its a sad state of affairs when Iran observes international law and the US spits on it.
- tanilama 8y agoUS has this clout because it controls a large part of the organizations for international cooperation. With Trump, it is clear that he only wants to exercise such power without considering the consequences of it. With the trust towards US fading, in and out of West, a complimentary mechanism will be created. US will control/influence where its hard power can still reach, but not beyond.
- IBM 8y agoTrump is an aberration and will likely be out of office in 2020, worst case 2024. No one is going to blow up old alliances because of Trump. Every foreign capital is just trying to ride out the storm.
- tremon 8y agoAberration or not (I think it's not), the rest of the world isn't going to twiddle their thumbs until 2020, worst case 2024.
- dagw 8y agoEvery foreign capital is just trying to ride out the storm. True, but they're also starting to think seriously about building storm shelters for the next time a storm blows through.
- ionised 8y agoTrump may be an aberration but the people that voted for him are not.
- curiousgal 8y ago>Such transactions, presumably in euros and pounds sterling, would not be transparent to American authorities. Then why make this plan public?
- mrtksn 8y agoI think it's not a clandestine operation but just a challenge to the US demands, therefore it's public? US: Don't trade with Iran because politics UK, DE, FR, CN, RU: Sorry, We like the deal we made and we would like to trade with Iran. US: If any company trades with Iran, won't be able to trade with the USA. Make your choise. UK, DE, FR, CN, RU: Okay then, we will create an infrastructure where the USA won't be able to legally identify and sanction our companies that trade with Iran.
- snaky 8y agoUS: Nice. Then we will just roll the dice once a week and point our finger to random big company of yours.
- david927 8y agoThe U.S. wouldn't do this because it would have no effect.
- stefanfisk 8y agothe investigations, even if they find nothing, would require huge compliance efforts for the companies targeted.
- XorNot 8y agoPresuming the supreme court goes along with a fishing expedition like that though. Which even with a stacked court is a big presumption.
- NicoJuicy 8y ago
- NicoJuicy 8y agoThere is no way to do this? Lol
- csense 8y agoIf you want to do business with Iran, why don't you just use Bitcoin?
- ur-whale 8y agoThis is about control. If they built such a system on Bitcoin, they would have none.
- chvid 8y agoThis article makes absolutely no sense. The EU chosing Iran over the US?! That is not what is going to happen over the reopened Iran deal. What is going to happen is that the EU will fall in line and Iran will be forced to withdraw its activities in Syria, Iraq, Yemen ... due to the severity of the economic hardship caused by the sanctions.
- sghiassy 8y agoIt’s about Europe choosing sovereignty over their own international politics rather than cow towing to the US. It’s not the EU preferring Iran over the US
- tragic 8y agoBut if the means you choose to demonstrate your sovereignty is to defy a new wave of American sanctions on Iran, then you certainly are choosing Iran over the United States, as a brief glance at any recent news headlines will tell you. The current POTUS, and the large number of congressmen who hate Iran with a rather deranged fervour, will certainly interpret it that way.
- plopilop 8y agoYou're twisting the narrative here. US are the one who decided to quit the deal they signed in 2015. The one defying everyone else is the US, not the EU. So either the EU decides to submit to the US or decides to grow a spine. It appears it's the latter. Too bad for the US.
- Grangar 8y agoIt's not all black and white. I'd say it's not choosing Iran over the US, it's more a matter of distancing away from the US.
- Symbiote 8y ago> cow towing I like that, but the English word is "kowtow", borrowed from Chinese. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/kowtow https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/kowtow
- cylinder 8y agoWhy is the EU so obsessed with propping up this Iranian regime?
- cyborgx7 8y agoBecause they would rather prevent nuclear armament of more countries.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...
- swarnie_ 8y agoTrying not to screw up this potential nuke situation as badly as the US have screwed up North Korae over the last 30 years. Go do the world police thing somewhere else while you get over this weird phase your going through, leave this one to us.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoBecause they would not like to have a (nuclear) war in their neighborhood, it's easy for the US to stirr up war for 50y in the middle east when the middle east is far away.
- ernesth 8y agoBecause they want to respect the agreement they signed (that agreement the US decided to not honor and to bully every other signee into not honoring).
- bepotts 8y agoSounds about as likely as that EU army that was supposed to make the EU independent of NATO, and thus, the US. How's that working out? The EU constantly talks about challenging US power (Macron and Merkel in particular), but almost never do. I'm sure this will be more of the same.
- jsiepkes 8y agoWell for one because with the current leadership in the US there is for the first time in history enough incentive to actually push through.
- vixen99 8y agoLooking at the increasing disarray in Europe, you'd have to be exuberantly optimistic to believe that.
- chvid 8y agoPush through with what? True independence of the us requires a military that the eu does not have (and even less now that the brits are leaving).
- bepotts 8y agoLike I've said, the EU said the same thing about an EU army and that army is nowhere to be found. Even on the petty insults Europe falters, like when they all got pissed about the US leaving the Paris Climate Accords and yet the US lead the world on reducing climate emissions. The unfortunate (for them) truth about the EU is that outside of its economy, the EU is irrelevant on the international stage. People want access to their market, but Europe cannot project any force outside of their own borders. Outside of maybe Iran, there isn't a single country in the world that curbs their actions due to fears about what the EU will do. Even countries inside the EU act without fear of what the EU will do, just look at Poland. I'd even venture to say most people in the world don't even know it exists. People know about Germany, France, and those countries individually, but people only know about the EU because of the news Brexit caused. The United States has allies AND leadership in every region of the country - Europe doesn't. If all this commotion has to do with the Iran deal, the other major players in the region (Israel, Saudis, and UAE) all have close ties to the US and will be following American leadership and ignoring whatever Europe says. So I don't even see how Europe successfully protects Iran in this case. So sure, Europe can talk all it wants about how they want to get rid of US leadership. But American leadership is felt all over the world, and major countries in almost every region will follow the US and not Europe. Sometimes having a big ass army, economic and cultural hegemony, and a history of being in other people's affairs gives you some clout.
- doombolt 8y agoI wonder if Russia could use banks of Crimea to trade with Iran. USA does not want anything to do with those anyway. So they already exist as clean room institutions.
- Arcadcomp 8y agoEurope is going downhill and it is really sad. Hope there won't be another war or something.
- sanatgersappa 8y agoWhen are we 'exporting democracy' to Europe? Oh, wait.
- snaky 8y agoThat very thing started from 'exporting democracy' to Iran in 1953.
- Proven 8y agoWho will go bust first? The big race is on!
- david927 8y agoWe're at an interesting crossroads in modern history where US hegemony is slipping away, as viewed in declining US Dollar dominance. I wonder if this will end with a bang or a whimper.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoEnded in a bang the last times an empire fell and a new one was rising.
- dalbasal 8y ago"Germany, France, Britain, China and Russia to create special financial infrastructure to work with Iran" hmmm... There's a story here about Iran-US, a story about the "western coalition," a story about the dollar's special status (maybe). There's also a story about this "special financial infrastructure/ vehicle." WTF is that infrastructure? Why are Germany, France & Britain and keen on this? These thing can (often) have ulterior motives or outcomes. Other than trading in other currencies, what does this do? On the diplomatic "story" this really demonstrates the new multipolar world, once you step out of the military realm and into an economic one. China, the EU & the US are similar size/strength. No stable teams...
- orbifold 8y agoWell the UK is about to leave the team, without it the EU is significantly weaker...
- Yptur 8y agoOr perhaps significantly stronger. The UK was historically the naysayer of the EU, opposing more integration. Now the strongest Economies are Germany and France which are both very much in favor of a closer EU. If this leads to the EU being quicker in decision making and pooling more of their resources it could mean a big boon to the EU. On the other hand the UK used to be kind of a watchdog of the EU so that role might have to be filled by either someone else or one can hope that the EU politicians will have enough pressure from their own countries. Lastly even though the UK is in the process of leaving, basically all the politicians responsible for it have either back paddled or just quit. The UK might yet fall back into the fold, only this time without their special status.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoGiven the unpopularity and utter ineptitude of the UK's brexit "negotiations" I'm tempted to say might be in the process of leaving. They're making such a mess, I would not be the least surprised to see the DUP withdraw support and a surprise election result. The Labour conference seems to be moving them towards a second referendum. 18 months ago I thought claims "it might not happen" foolish, now I'm starting to think it might not happen. :)
- grecy 8y ago> The cost of defying American sanctions can be steep: in 2015, BNP Paribas SA, the French bank, paid a penalty of almost $9 billion for violating U.S. sanctions against Iran, Cuba and Sudan I'm cruious, who imposes that fine and how do they enforce payment? Can the US Government FORCE a French Bank to pay them a fine? Surely a French bank could just say "no thanks".
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThey're one of the world's largest banks with presence globally. Not only do they have presence in US financial centres they have US subsidiaries. Plenty of places to send the bailiffs to, or whatever the US equivalent is.
- dagw 8y agoSurely a French bank could just say "no thanks". Sure, and lose their banking license in the US and quite probably have their US assets seized.
- qubax 8y ago> I'm cruious, who imposes that fine The executive branch can ( via executive order, treasury sanctions, etc ) and of course congress can. > and how do they enforce payment? By threat of financial collapse. > Can the US Government FORCE a French Bank to pay them a fine? Yes and no. Are we going to invade france and force the bank to pay the fine? No. Could we threaten to place sanctions on the bank and exclude it from international financial system. Yes. > Surely a French bank could just say "no thanks". It can. But then it would immediately collapse. No international bank can survive a US sanction because the US runs the international finance system. There is reason why the swiss banking system submitted to US demands to turn over customer data a few years ago. Economic sanctions on switzerland would turn it into north korea or venezuela. People mistakenly think that US sanctions means that the US won't do business with a certain country. US sanctions means that everyone doing business with the US can't do business with a certain country. US sanctions essentially forces the world to choose between the US and country X. The US being the largest economy and the heart of the international financial system wins every time. It's why there is so much drama with US sanctions on iran. It's not that we won't do business with iran. It's that everyone who wants a business relationship with the US can't do business with iran.
- sbt 8y agoThe US cannot sustainably force the EU to suspend trade with a third country. Sanctions, at least employed in this way, is a weapon which use reduces its effectiveness. Like everything the Trump administration does, reneging on the JCPoA represents an extreme trade-off in favor of short-term gain at greater expense in the long-term.
- menotyou 8y agoHistorically the US-Dollar became dominant in the 50/60ties when the oil exporting countries were partially forced, partially by their own preference staring factoring their oil bills in USD. One reason among others was that only the USD market was big enough to provide enough liquidity for the oil market. Other exporters then started billing their export goods in USD Dollars so they could pay their oil bill with the Dollars earned. Ever since this becoming more a self sustainable system by which more goods were billed in USD because more exporters wanted to buy imports billed in USD. The US itself as only country as extraordinary privilege in the world could just print the currency at will, while others had to sell products to earn the currency. The other side of the deal was, that Europe an Japan were using their economic capacities producing civilian goods, whereas the U.S. could buy these goods with printed money and could use the capacities to build up an otherwise unsustainable large military sector to protect their allies. As another effect, USD trades are ultimately settled buy the U.S. Fed, so the U.S. can effectively get countries or companies out of the market as long the settlement is done in USD. Fast forward today: The Euro is as big as USD. With EUR or CNY you can buy all products you want to have. When Russia, Venezuela and Iran decide to sell Oil or Gas there is little technical need to stick for USD. Further Trump cutting the U.S. side of the deal. Why should Europe other further grant the extraordinary privilege to the U.S? And why it would put it's own countries and companies a the risk of Feds goodwill to perform the settlement? Given Trumps apparent will to use the USD as a weapon, it is a question of national security for Europe, UK, Japan, Iran and the BRICS to change to a different regime. My personal expectation is that settlement in EUR will be only transitional before SDRs issued by the BIS will become the final currency of choice. These will resemble the "Bancor" proposed by Keyenes before the Bretton Woods system was implemented
- sigvirt 8y agoThere is similar premise in James Rickards 2014 book The Death of Money. He describes trade dynamics and international organizations, including the Bank for International Settlements and their unit/basket of reserve currencies called Special Drawing Rights. Several years ago China was on about having the Yuan declared a reserve currency so it would be included as one of the currencies which comprise an SDR unit.