8 ms·
> Given that marriage often means you end up with the lower of the two credit scores Does anyone actually think this way?? Honestly I can’t imagibe ever think
by gumby 8y ago
> Given that marriage often means you end up with the lower of the two credit scores
Does anyone actually think this way?? Honestly I can’t imagibe ever thinking financially when I proposed.
- zdragnar 8y agoYes, they do. proposal =/= legally married; I know several people who held off a little while... either until they were out of school, or made a major purchase (such as a house, that sort of thing).
- magic_beans 8y agoOf course people think this way. It's foolish not to, especially when couples can commit to each other in so many ways other than legal marriage. I'm shocked there's someone on hacker news who doesn't.
- Freak_NL 8y agoThinking in terms of credit scores seems to be a US thing though. Sure, when you consider marriage you will be aware of each other's financial situation (including debts), and ideally you'll be living together and sharing finances for a couple of years already (ten years in my case), but credit scores seem pretty localized.
- ryanobjc 8y agoA meta comment, this kind of thread is why I don't respect hackernews commenters anymore. It frequently goes like so: - Comment: Something - Reply: But my experience says otherwise, why are you so wrong? There is a persistent lack of ability to see other people's point of view. Surely it is not everyone here, but it's enough such that things get really boring here.
- sdinsn 8y agoWhy are you talking a comment thread so seriously? It sounds like that's your problem.
- gumby 8y agoWasn't the post more "am I wrong?" rather than "poster is wrong"? And the responses were useful.
- jboles 8y agoIn many cases I think it goes beyond a lack of ability, to wilful obtuseness.
- nostrademons 8y agoThat's part of what I like about Hacker News. They may not be able to see each other's POV, but I can. I come out with a richer appreciation for the diversity of experience out there from reading it, even if all the participants do is argue.
- magduf 8y agoI like his comment. I think what he's saying is not that he doesn't appreciate diversity, his complaint is the way in which people discuss these issues: instead of being respectful and level-headed, they act like extremists. I think this is common to people in this profession. There's some other forums where I see a similar dynamic, and then there's other forums where it's completely different. Let's just say that the forums where people are nicer and more respectful have few, if any, engineers. Remember, there was a study a while back that showed that engineers have a greater propensity to become terrorists. People who gravitate toward engineering have much more black-and-white thinking, and with that comes a greater tendency towards extremism.
- sulam 8y agoI was raised in a very poor environment, and I still have connections to and experiences from that sort of life. Credit affects a ton of your life in ways that people who aren't poor can't appreciate. If you want cable, they are going to run a credit check on you and if the results aren't great, you need to pony up a large deposit. If you want to open a bank account, your options are greatly diminished if you have bad credit. You are automatically disadvantaged if you're trying to rent a desirable apartment. It's probably obvious, but you also don't have credit cards without pre-paying, and that complicates life in a number of ways (and most people with bad credit also don't have the resources to pre-pay a credit card). Not so surprisingly, this all factors into whether or not to get married to someone!
- harryh 8y agoEssentially everyone thought this way up until maybe 100 years ago. Marriage was just as much an economic union as for love and companionship. In many ways it still is whether people acknowledge it or not.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xfitm3 8y agoThe credit score remark is a reference to losing half your assets and/or taking on your partners debt if things go wrong.
- watwut 8y agoThat assumes you are marrying someone with zero resources.
- sulam 8y agoMost people in the US have less than $10000 in savings.
- krageon 8y agoDo most people really not marry with prenup?
- loco5niner 8y agoI didn't. We are committed til death do us part. Not just saying that.
- sulam 8y agoCalifornia has a difficult relationship with prenups. My wife and I essentially have to keep our pre-wedding finances completely separate or they become marital assets and subject to a 50/50 split. Any debts we incur past the date of our marriage are marital debts I believe, and prenups aren’t enforceable.
- bunderbunder 8y agoIn my social circle, it's not all that uncommon for it to be a purely financial decision. One pair of friends, I didn't find out they got legally married until much later, when it came up incidentally in a conversation about filing taxes. And I was no more offended about it than I'd be about them not keeping me up to date on whether they itemize or take the standard deduction, or deciding not to invite me along for a mortgage refinance. I don't know if it's boomers treating divorce as a recreational sport, or if it's the whole 90's/00's DOMA subplot in the story of marriage in the US, or something else entirely, or all of the above. But, at some point, the idea that "love == government licensure" just stopped seeming reasonable.
- everdrive 8y agoWhat sort of social circle is this?
- rayiner 8y agoI sure did! Marriage is, primarily, a financial and risk sharing arrangement. That’s the point of it.
- astura 8y agoGood God, you're kidding right? Making sure you are financially compatible with your spouse is just as important as making sure you are emotionally compatible. Financial issues are the #1 cause of stress in marriages. Civil marriage is very similar to a business partnership.