5 ms·
The video games industry is where we consistently hear some of the worst stories of workers being mistreated and lied to under dysfunctional management in toxic
by Apocryphon 8y ago
The video games industry is where we consistently hear some of the worst stories of workers being mistreated and lied to under dysfunctional management in toxic cultures. Constant crunch time for games that don't even succeed in the market.
What would anti-union libertarians say about the labor conditions there? Workers should just avoid the game industry until more tolerable and better-paying workplaces arise? How is organizing workers not a valid solution to the problems there? Do they think that unions will somehow make the situation worse?
- stevenwoo 8y agoI've had several anti-union libertarian coworkers in the video game industry, each one thought they are exceptional so they don't need a union and they trust their choices/negotiation skills - to be fair probably everyone in game industry has a robust opinion of themselves.
- mattnewport 8y agoA part of the reason you hear these stories of the games industry is that it's a desirable job for many people. Games companies can get away with more than some other software companies because enough people want to work on games despite worse employment conditions than they might find with the same skill set elsewhere. There's a supply and demand issue. There's also a certain amount of self imposed crunch by people who are genuinely passionate about the game they're working on and don't have as many other demands on their time due to family or other outside interests or commitments. To the extent that unions improve worker conditions, they do so in part by restricting entry and thus influencing the supply side. In general unions tend to benefit people already in the industry at the expense of people outside who'd like to join, among other groups. Whether that's a desirable outcome depends on large part to which group you either belong or care about the most.
- mrfredward 8y agoCollective bargaining relies on negotiating blanket policies for all the workers. In some industries, that is fine. If all your brick layers get paid the same and given the same breaks, and all your brick-laying supervisors get their standard supervisor pay, that might be for the better. It doesn't work that way for knowledge workers and creative types. Some people are rare talents, some people are just okay. Some people fill wear 5 different hats and cover responsibilities outside their title. One artist may be the visionary behind your greatest success, another just follows orders, but both are on the same team and at the same level of the hierarchy. If you force a system where everyone makes the same salary based on how long they've worked there, the best people will leave. But if people negotiate for themselves, it isn't collective bargaining anymore, and you don't have a union. Want to prevent burnout? The union negotiates for rigid 9 to 5 hours. Many creative people will hate it. Or you let people come in when the want, but they have to fill out a timesheet, can't work overtime without the approval of both a manager and a union rep, and have to adhere to rigid guidelines. Unions can't work without bureaucracy, but creative people and creative organizations don't work well with bureaucracy.
- georgeecollins 8y ago>> It doesn't work that way for knowledge workers and creative types. SAG WGA DGA Last I checked all the best people in those fields were members.
- mrfredward 8y agoYou make a good point with screen writers. Admittedly I don't know much about that industry. Do you have a good example of engineering unions? The only one I know of is the SPEEA, and I know of it because one of my friends quit a job to escape the union defined hierarchy and the associated culture.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThe reason that Unions work for Hollywood is that the final product is dependent on a small number of specific people (mainly actors, but also writers and directors). If those people refuse to work, there is no product. Because actors are unified and honor the other less powerful unions they imbue them with power. Teamsters can strike and gain concessions from studios because actors won't cross the picket line. Knowledge workers are largely cogs. No game project can be held hostage by one or a several critical employees. A majority of game jobs have already left California, with drop in replacements in Shanghai or Montreal or Austin.
- Apocryphon 8y agoSounds like this article illustrates the vital importance in writers to adventure games. Telltale Games’ post Walking Dead Season 1 efforts specifically failed because the writing was not as strong and just attempted to replicate the success of the first.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThey are vitally important, but they aren't perceived by the public as vitally important, so their negotiating power is limited.
- stale2002 8y ago> Workers should just avoid the game industry until more tolerable and better-paying workplaces arise? Yes. There are too many people in the industry pursuing their passion product, as opposed to doing something because it will be successful. If you act like an artist, expect to be treated like one. And artists are treated.... poorly by society. Not that I don't support the general idea of working on things that you like. I have a couple side project myself, that I am doing for fun. But I have absolutely zero expectation of success, and have a day job (that I like) to pay the bills. I am not going to pretend like my side projects could support me.