5 ms·
(Sort of a tangent, but it is called out in the article...) Why DO companies insist on starting out in the bay area? Is it really that hard to find talent in se
by phendrenad2 8y ago
(Sort of a tangent, but it is called out in the article...) Why DO companies insist on starting out in the bay area? Is it really that hard to find talent in second-string tech hubs?
- Eric_WVGG 8y agoThe answer I keep hearing is that it keeps the founders near the VC money, which doesn't make sense here as I don't believe Telltale was pursuing that. I've always wondered how much cash Double Fine burns through to stay in SF.
- chaosite 8y agoTelltale was VC funded. https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/53723-08 https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/53723-08
- TarpitCarnivore 8y ago> I've always wondered how much cash Double Fine burns through to stay in SF The documentary on Double Fine releasing Broken Age sort of touches on this as it chronicles the journey from idea, kickstarter, development, and release. In there there were some small layoffs or needing to shift people to bring in more money. Tim goes through some visual changes as well as the stress mounts.
- ARothfusz 8y agoI've always imagined it was because the VCs bought the buildings they rent out to the startups, and probably the apartments as well. That makes the bay area a big money laundering machine where cash is guaranteed to flow from the investors through the VCs to the startups and back to the VCs again. Cha-ching!
- lucisferre 8y agoI don't believe that is what money laundering means.
- logfromblammo 8y agoThat's not laundering. That's selling shovels (and jeans and beans and baths and beds) to the gold miners. There may be a laundering component to it, though. If you're a fund manager, and you can't steal the principal directly, you might be able to invest it in a company that you can then require to set up headquarters in a place where you personally own rental property and service businesses. Chances are that some of the money you give to the company in your capacity as fund manager will come back to you in your capacity as landlord/business owner. Then you can turn around and invest that in your own employer, if you feel like it, so you can also buy in to all their outstanding lottery tickets. This is just possible. It is not guaranteed to be happening.
- dwighttk 8y agoI feel like if you own property in the valley, there's no reason to "launder" money in that way, just rent it out to whomever and get some money.
- logfromblammo 8y agoWhy are sales and rental prices so high? Because demand is rising faster than available stock is increasing. Why is demand rising so fast? Because people are moving there. Why are people moving there? Because that's where their employers want them to work. Why are employers locating there? For some, prestige address. For others, proximity to investment capital. What does proximity have to do with investment? Couldn't a VC gain competitive advantage by locating in some other city that doesn't have such vicious competition for unicorns? I don't have an answer to that. It doesn't make sense to me as a strategy, because I have incomplete information.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt isn't for a lack of trying. Attempts to go too cheap have ended in failure typically - people don't want to move to the middle of nowhere for a one company job when they have a nice well of employment already. The network effect is very real in a that critical mass of workforce talent can provide concrete advantages. That said moving to the fringe of the network seems to be a good move to get the best of both worlds if possible - Palo Alto was once the cheap option. It probably is inflated due to ego - Juicero certainly didn't need significant talent (or have it for that matter) but if you are developing something that needs complexity like say self driving cars or their parts it could pay off.
- bunderbunder 8y agoI'm really not involved in the startup scene much at all, but my impression is that the amount of startup funding available elsewhere is just nowhere close to what's available in the Bay Area. That might have two implications: First, more startups are able to get funding in the first place, and, second, of the ones that get funded, the average amount of money they raise is much higher. If so, then it's not necessarily that more companies insist on starting out there, so much as that it's a sort of survivor bias: The Bay Area's business climate is just one that is able to grow more startups to a big enough size that you hear about them.
- freehunter 8y agoI would love to see a breakdown that shows the amount of money companies spend to be in the Bay Area versus the amount of money they raise, compared to the money companies would save not being in SV versus the amount they can raise there. It might be worth the added cost, it must be worth the added costs, but it's strange to just say "they can raise more money" because they also spend more. There may be fewer VCs in Pittsburgh, but cost of living is also lower, there are plenty of challenge-hungry programmers and MBAs there, and CMU is (subjectively) a better CS school than UC-Berkley.
- philipodonnell 8y agoI always figured it was because many SV startups are selling to other startups/VC portfolio companies at first (more open to new products, less risk averse with vendors, etc..) so it makes sense to be where your customers are.
- georgeecollins 8y agoGame companies need a variety of talent that can be hard to find. This includes engineers, artists, writers, and so on. The Bay Area isn't the only place you can find that mix of talent. There are probably as many game developers (if not more) in Southern California, but also in Montreal, Seattle, Chicago, Austin, Vancouver, etc. The trick is that it really helps to attract talent if you are based in a place where people want to live and are likely to find other employment. Once you are established in your career, if you move for a company you ought to like living there. And if you like living there it helps if there is another place you can work if something happens to that company. [Edited for grammar]
- secabeen 8y agoThe talent pool is deepest in the valley/SF and the VCs do have connections within it. You're also close to your VCs, and some VCs do provide helpful guidance to founders (that's what YC is all about).
- bena 8y agoIt's a college thing mostly. You'll find a lot of your tech hubs near colleges with decent tech programs.
- gameswithgo 8y agoits absolute insanity, and there is a huge competitive advantage by not doing that, and hiring smart people somewhere unpopular who don't want to live in the Bay Area or Austin and are looking for neat jobs to nab.