5 ms·
It doesn't work that way. Governments are interested in preserving order. The purpose of dragnet surveillance isn't to catch every single criminal and create so
by chongli 8y ago
It doesn't work that way. Governments are interested in preserving order. The purpose of dragnet surveillance isn't to catch every single criminal and create some kind of crime-free utopia, it's to create a chilling effect on moderate dissent. It's a little nudge to remind everyone to stay in line.
It also has the added benefit of moving the Overton window towards authoritarianism. This puts anyone who uses sophisticated encryption to hide their communications squarely in the radical camp, making them easier to marginalize.
- forgotmysn 8y agoi think he was being sarcastic.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chii 8y agobut the reply brings up a really good point - the purpose of the legislation is not what is stated (or implied) by the legislation. Using this mechanism to achieve a chilling effect on activism has a huge detrimental impact on democracy. We must be careful whenever a politician attempts to trade liberty for security - for fools who agree will soon have neither.
- dmurray 8y agoInsisting on having always-on listening devices everywhere would also chill "moderate dissent". Those who appear to be disabling the devices or having surreptitious conversations away from them could benefit from some "little nudges". Perhaps some re-education camps where participants would be reminded that they have nothing to fear. Attendance at the camps would be voluntary, just marketed to those who seem to avoid surveillance - but as an extra incentive, it could improve your social credit score which would be useful when opening a bank account, applying for a job or buying public transport tickets.
- panemcircensis 8y agoWe need a virus, that emulates encrypted communication and is otherwise harmless.
- krylon 8y agoIn a certain way, that is a brilliant idea! Generate a random key, encrypt a bunch of random data with it (or maybe even just generate a bunch of random data), and send it to a few of your contacts, who immediately discard it. But I think such a feature would better implemented at the OS level! :)
- bochoh 8y agoBut surely in that case we would all demand to be able to inspect this data that is being generated and shipped on the devices we "own".
- krylon 8y agoLet's assume the OS is FLOSS software and includes a daemon that sends random data to other devices to be encrypted and discarded randomly.