9 ms·
Mosquitoes Genetically Modified to Crash Species That Spreads Malaria
- godson_drafty 8y agoWhat about releasing a genetically altered strain of the malaria organism itself?
- hsnewman 8y agoMaleria reproduces asexually, so I guess it wouldn't work.
- danieltillett 8y agoMalaria reproduces both sexually and asexually depending on its lifecycle stage.
- maxerickson 8y agoCrashing the mosquito population greatly diminishes transmission of the disease. Because malaria mostly infects humans, if you managed to create a malaria that conferred immunity, you'd have to infect lots and lots of people with it to spread it into the wild, and then it would only infect a subset of the people with the normal malaria strain.
- gascan 8y agoImmune mosquitoes would be good too, though certainly more challenging to engineer than "kill everything".
- msla 8y ago> But the researchers stressed that many years of additional research are needed to further test the safety and effectiveness of the approach before anyone attempts to release these mosquitoes or any other organisms created this way into the wild. > The scientists acknowledge the technology raises serious concerns. So it will require broad political debate, rigorous regulation and the consent of people living in any areas where they might be released, they say. It also raises an interesting moral issue which might be a good plot for a novel: The plan to introduce the mosquitoes runs into roadblocks, mainly from people who see all GMOs as inherently evil and utterly terrible, as a matter of basic dogma. A few of the scientists on the team developing these mosquitoes realize that those roadblocks are not going to go away, regardless of how well-argued the case in favor of the mosquitoes is and how many lives are being lost in the Third World, far from any anti-GMO activists. (See also: Golden rice, which could be curing blindness were it not for implacable opposition to GMO food.) The scientists proceed to release the modified mosquitoes into the wild, saving a lot of Third Worlders and making First Worlder anti-GMO activists go nuclear.
- the8472 8y agoAnd the benevolent scientists would happen to work for umbrella corp? I don't think that would be good PR.
- mayamatrix 8y agoPlot twist: the modification has an unexpected side effect of killing large populations of birds that relied upon the mosquitos for food.
- maxerickson 8y agoThere's dozens of species of mosquitoes in areas with endemic malaria and 2 or 3 that transmit malaria.
- msla 8y agoYes, because every book needs a Frankenstein Complex. That's just about the Least Predictable Plot Twist In The Universe, I daresay.
- technofiend 8y agoReddit's /r/writingprompts would probably take this and run with it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- danieltillett 8y agoEveryone opposed to this should have to write a letter explaining why to the mothers of all the children that die every day of malaria. 3000 letters a day should just be doable if you learn to write fast and don't say much beyond that you don't care about their loss and grief. Edit. Yes this is an emotive argument designed to jar people into looking at the consequences of dithering. It is fine for us rich to worry about possible unintended consequences, but doing so has a terrible outcome for real people [0]. 0. For the record we already know what happens when you remove the particular species of mosquitos that transmit malaria from an ecosystem as we have done this using pesticides in the places rich people live. The answer is nothing other than people stop dying of malaria.
- davemp 8y agoIt's very naive/irresponsible to imply that anyone who would be concerned about massive ecosystem impacts doesn't care about malaria victims. Even the researchers are hesitant. > The scientists acknowledge the technology raises serious concerns. So it will require broad political debate, rigorous regulation and the consent of people living in any areas where they might be released, they say.
- danieltillett 8y agoPut that in your letter - "So sorry your child had to die, but I care about the mosquito that killed your child more." The point I was making is that these academic debates about ecosystems are at the expense of the lives of millions children.
- shittyadmin 8y agoThis sort of emotional argument with no thought given to side effects has no place in rational discussion.
- danieltillett 8y agoActually they do if they cause the opposing side to justify the cost of not acting. Everything new has possible unintended consequences or side effects. Do you oppose everything new because of what might happen?
- thedudeabides5 8y agoMosquitoes seem like they belong on the bottom of the moral weight spectrum, above viruses and below bacteria.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoThis needs to happen as soon as possible. According to the WHO http://www.who.int/malaria/en/ http://www.who.int/malaria/en/ There were 216 million malaria cases worldwide in 2016 with 445 000 deaths. Developing nations, especially in Africa are most severely affected by this. Whoever, manages to eradicate the mosquitoes surely deserves the Nobel prize in Medicine as well as the Nobel Peace Prize.
- melling 8y agoWhat could go wrong?
- brownbat 8y agoWell, it's worth asking. On the other hand, one rebuttal would go something like: P1. We should calibrate our tolerance for risk against the level of harm we're addressing. P2. Mosquitoes are at the high water mark for ongoing harm to humanity. C. We should be more tolerant of risks here than against any or at least most other problems in the world. Another rebuttal would be that a survey of leading biologists and entomologists leads to near unanimity that suddenly erasing mosquitoes from the planet wouldn't really have any downsides on the larger ecosystem: https://www.wnycstudios.org/story/kill-em-all/ https://www.wnycstudios.org/story/kill-em-all/ https://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html https://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html To be fair, note that some rare arctic orchids might be affected: http://www.mosquitoreviews.com/mosquitoes-niche-pollinate.html http://www.mosquitoreviews.com/mosquitoes-niche-pollinate.ht... If you want an updated review of biocontrol more generally, Outside/In has a great episode about it, with interviews with proponents and critics of biocontrol. One takeaway might be that there are a bunch of overlooked success stories, and the widely popularized failures provide a really distorted sample: http://outsideinradio.org/shows/s02e01 http://outsideinradio.org/shows/s02e01 On the other hand, it includes interviews with critics of biocontrol as well, so I feel like you could learn more details about both sides of the discussion. Other contrarian stories about invasives: https://www.wired.com/2011/02/good-invasives/ https://www.wired.com/2011/02/good-invasives/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/07/140724-invasive-species-conservation-biology-extinction-climate-science/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/07/140724-inva... https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/01/science/invasive-species.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/01/science/invasive-species.... If you want beautiful and complicated historical poetry about a human intervention that lead to a population collapse, The Memory Palace will take you back to the late 1800s: https://player.fm/series/the-memory-palace-110374/episode-131-lost-locusts https://player.fm/series/the-memory-palace-110374/episode-13...
- sand500 8y agoThis article talks about controlling Anopheles gambiae but something similar already being done to control Aedes aegypti. https://debug.com/ https://debug.com/
- godelski 8y ago> something similar already being done to control Aedes aegypti. Which carry: yellow fever, dengue fever, Zika fever and chikungunya.
- alwaysdoit 8y agoA notable difference is that Debug is using the sterile insect technique (SIT)[1], as opposed to gene drives, which are much harder to control once released. With SIT, 1) we have a lot more experience using it for decades, and 2) it's pretty easy to simply stop releasing sterile insects if unintended consequences were found. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sterile_insect_technique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sterile_insect_technique
- EamonnMR 8y agoIf we're going to be making species extinct anyway, I don't see any reason not to make wiping out the harmful ones a priority. Can we do Toxodendron next?
- rdl 8y agoI think this should be released without any form of government or popular consent (i.e. don't even ask them); JFDI. We do so many worse things on a regular basis with more concrete known negatives for far lower benefits.
- justtopost 8y agoWell aren't we just a paragon of bad ethics.
- godelski 8y ago> a technology that no one could say is safe definitively Problem with this type of technology is that there is no way to even test if it would be safe. You either have to just take the risk or not do it. And unfortunately someone else will likely take the risk even if we don't. So it makes more sense to me to try it and watch carefully. BUT there is something that people aren't talking about much. This targeting isn't "kill all mosquitoes" it is "kill the mosquitoes that carry malaria" (Anopheles. Which are different from Aedes aegypti, which carry yellow fever, dengue fever, Zika fever and chikungunya). So doing this to Anopheles shouldn't affect the Aedes aegypti mosquito. So it is a tad safer than killing ALL the mosquitoes. But still potentially unsafe as other creatures may rely on them as a food source more than currently believed. It also begs the question, can we try this out on a specific species that is far less widespread? Doesn't even have to be mosquitoes. Disclaimer: Not a geneticist. If I stated something wrong please correct me! And please provide source material so I can read it. Thanks!
- mrfusion 8y agoMaybe some things are worth the risk. We shouldnt sit around bioethicizing while people are dying of maleria.
- beatpanda 8y agoEven if your premise is that we should prioritize human life above all else, there's still a very good reason to consider the effect of eliminating any species on the rest of the ecosystem before we just pull the trigger. It's really easy to imagine a scenario where eliminating this mosquito ends up being more harmful to human life than leaving it in place.
- godelski 8y agoI agree that we should think about the ecosystem. But is that something we can reasonably model? From what I understand Anopheles isn't thought to be essential. Plus, this demonstration would show we could do similar things with other similarly dangerous and potentially non-essential animals. Though a counterpoint, malaria was eradicated from Europe without eradicating Anopheles.
- jekeeei 8y agoFirst they came for the mosquitos...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- _Microft 8y agoIs such an invasive method even needed? Malaria deaths are down by almost 50% in the period of 2000-2015 according to WHO data.
- godelski 8y agoThis solution isn't about reduction, it is about eradication. It is cost effective and also implies that you can do other things along the same lines. For example, you could do the same thing to Aedes aegypti (another mosquito species that carries thinks like Zika and Yellow Fever). You might be able to do it to bot flies. Lone Star Ticks. Or many others.
- bdamm 8y agoWhile I would love to see tick-borne disease wiped out, I just don't think that wiping out ticks is the right way. Instead, how about wiping out the parasites that are borne by these ticks? It's a never ending cascade of special eradication. Today, ticks and mosquitoes carrying life threatening agents. Tomorrow, perhaps rats, cats, mice, sparrows, bed bugs, termites, and any other organism that we find inconvenient? How about certain kinds of humans, perhaps we can terminate people that are cognitively impaired? Wielding the rod of genocide seems like a poor choice.
- waserwill 8y agoThe difference is that while animals like mosquitoes have many offspring and are sexually reproducing, many of the microscopic parasites are not… The gene drive requires sexual reproduction to spread and produce sterile mosquitoes. Huh, maybe this will open an opportunity for sex-non-obligate mosquitoes infected by Wolbachia, if those are even produced by their interaction
- bdamm 8y agoYour answer sounds like "because we can".
- 8y ago
- beatpanda 8y agoI think a more interesting question than "should we do this or not" is "how would you build a tool that could model an entire ecosystem?". Does anyone reading this know what scientists use to do this currently?
- ashtonbaker 8y agoI did a little bit of this for my masters project. Modeled ecosystems and measurements of the ecosystem as partially observed markov processes.
- mullingitover 8y ago> "It could lead to other species coming in to fill a niche that are even more a problem," Steinbrecher says. "It's beyond our ability to predict what the consequences are, except that it could be really devastating." Malaria has killed more people than all wars in human history combined. Hundreds of thousands, if not millions, are going to die while we come up with reasons not to do anything about it.
- blazespin 8y agoThe application is fine, unfortunately the real danger is the technology itself. Nuclear power was dangerous, but at least it's somewhat tricky to generate refined uranium. CRISPR, unfortunately, is theoretically not that tricky.
- alwaysdoit 8y agoA. gambiae in particular is so strongly anthropophilic that it would likely become endangered or extinct if cut off from all human hosts, so a widespread bed-netting program would have likely the same effect, just slower and with millions more cases of malaria in the meantime. Any naysayers out there interested in volunteering for blood-feeding? Our current approach of "make the poor people do it" isn't exactly fair.
- fallingfrog 8y agoJust to play devils advocate.. what's the worst possible way this technology could be used? What if you give the mutation to people? Maybe people you don't like for some reason?
- waserwill 8y agoThis may lead to ecosystem crashes, but almost certainly not extinction. The gene drive, here, relies on two major features: high reproductive rate of mosquitoes, and the maintenance of the elements responsible for the drive. First of all, geographically or reproductively isolated populations will not be affected and will repopulate. Second, the components of the drive may recombine, creating offspring that will not be affected by the drive, and will out-compete the affected individuals within two generations. Needless to say, the number of mosquitoes (of this species) will plummet. Perhaps, other insects, including mosquito species, will take advantage of their absence. But given their ubiquity and population sizes, some will survive. Maybe the genetic bottleneck that occurs will make them more susceptible to disease, but that's minor.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- breatheoften 8y agoCould they develop another version of the gene-drive modification that undoes the first effect? It seems like they should be able to do this and conduct an experiment in the laboratory that proves that there is at least theoretical ability to reverse the effect if it prove desirable to do so for some reason. Seems like an achievable improvement on the safety model for this technique? Maybe a necessary step before deploying a tool like this for the first time?
- greeneggs 8y agoThis is theoretically possible. Researchers have also considered creating gene drives that automatically end after a certain number of generations. It is a bit scary, but it is probably prudent to support such research, not only for interventions like this but as a possible countermeasure against biowarfare and bioterrorism using gene drives.
- CitizenTekk 8y agoPoor parts of Africa, Asia and Oceania are the ones who suffer and getting perpetually killed by this disease, not just malaria, even dengue, yellow fever, etc which have may have cause by mosquito. Why it keeps happening is that because they don't have really help from the Government about proper health care and education on how and what to do to avoid this. People, specially on poor status, mostly rely on their homemade or even herbal treatment that we knew will not help them at all. Malaria is a curable disease.
- snovv_crash 8y agoTo all the naysayers: Did you know that there were massive DDT campaigns to wipe out mosquitoes in Europe and the USA, which means you no longer suffer from malaria in Mississippi or Italy? Italy was only declared malaria-free in 1970. The proposed measures have much lower environmental risks than the DDT ever did. Saying this shouldn't be used is effectively pulling up the ladder behind you. Go to Mozambique or DRC, get malaria, and then use the same health care the locals have access to. Hope to hell you don't have Cerebral Malaria (20% mortality rate with treatment). Then come back and complain about the environmental risks of wiping out 1 of over 15 mosquito species, which primarily feeds on humans anyways.
- a0-prw 8y agoThis will clearly have a negative, long-term effect on the environment by causing up to 400000 more human beings to reach sexual maturity in a part of the world where expanding human population is the major environmental threat. And, in the long run, a collapsing natural environment is also going to cause tremendous human suffering and death. But never mind it's just a drop in the ocean anyway, so go ahead.