19 ms·
Modifications to Google Chromium for removing Google integration
- nadont8 8y agoGoogle Chromium, sans integration with Google, and sans updates. Thanks but no thanks.
- vemv 8y agoChromium updates are blobs and tend to have close ties with Google.
- regecks 8y agoYes, but they also come with Google's release engineering, so at least you can be somewhat confident they've not been subverted in some way not intended by the authors of the browser. The way Ungoogled Chromium is distributed is way too yolo for my tastes. Would be nice if it had reproducible builds or was packaged into a reputable distro or thirdparty repo.
- SquareWheel 8y agoUnless you're compiling yourself, all software is "blobs".
- vemv 8y ago- Many dependencies of dev projects are simply source files which will be compiled on-the-fly. Or at least that's the case in the languages I normally work with. - Some blobs are more trustworthy than others.
- aphextron 8y ago>"IMPORTANT: These binaries are provided by anyone who are willing to build and submit them. Because these binaries are not necessarily reproducible, authenticity cannot be guaranteed." Safety not guaranteed. Just how I like my browser.
- vemv 8y agoCoincidentally I had found out this one today and compiled it myself after a frustrating experience with `brew install chromium` (videos wouldn't play; inputs would blink). I guess this has more flags set up by default, and it makes it easier to target a stable commit to compile against. Also as a word of caution, don't use ungoogled-chromium binaries - they never are fully official/confirmed/reproducible. Running opaque blobs from strangers defeats the purpose of leaving Chrome for increasing privacy. Just bite the bullet and run the 2h compilation process yourself.
- colordrops 8y agoIs there a flag for compiling out integrated login?
- djrogers 8y ago> Also as a word of caution, don't use ungoogled-chromium binaries Unless you’re reading every line of code yourself before compiling it, I’d say you’re no safer going you’re route than downloading the binaries offered from the same source.
- vemv 8y agoGenerally as a software developer I can assess which projects' source to trust, else I wouldn't be running thousands of transitive dependencies in my machine. Binaries which are unofficial to even ungoogled-chromium itself surpass my threshold of trust. But yes, one could take a further step and extract the interesting bits from this project and apply them to the official Chromium trunk.
- User23 8y agoHow do you assess the trustworthiness of thousands of transitive dependencies with a far greater number of code contributors in a way that scales? This is a serious question, and it would be great if you shared the solution you found. Thanks.
- 8y ago
- quickben 8y agoAwesome. Keep up the good work!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 8y agoYou could always switch to Firefox and use something like fastmail or protonmail. Did that a year ago, and actually it works better on mobile imo
- rurban 8y agoprotonmail sells your email for profit. I would better recommend fastmail which charges you, but it is still in unsafe legal regulation. You are not safe from the "lawful" dragnet neither.
- zeta0134 8y agoCould you please provide a citation for your first claim that ProtonMail sells your email for profit? Their entire sales pitch heavily revolves around clientside decryption that should in theory prevent this from being possible; I'd very much like to know if this is not the case.
- rurban 8y agoPlenty: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8755492 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8755492 (javascript) https://medium.com/criptext/we-need-a-new-encrypted-email-service-4971c5ee77c5 https://medium.com/criptext/we-need-a-new-encrypted-email-se...
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoCan you quote the part where it says that "protonmail sells your email for profit"?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sneak 8y agoSwitching email providers is of little use for privacy from Google when everyone you correspond with is also using Google.
- shawn 8y agoC'mon. People are trying to stand up to Google. It's important to encourage this behavior, or at least not spread FUD with unsubstantiated claims of insecurity. EDIT: Lol, Google employees swarming HN on a Sunday. I guess people are getting a little nervous that a mass exodus from Chrome might be beginning. Hey look ma, an unsubstantive complaint about downvotes! Can't wait for my account to be penalized further.
- linkmotif 8y agoStanding up to Google is meaningless if you’re not being smart. The number one feature of Google is their overwhelming intelligence. Throwing a fit and compiling some software semi-ignorantly doesn’t stand up to anything, much less this type of power.
- shawn 8y agoYes it does. Literally doing anything other than blindly using their products and not giving a shit is standing up to them. It doesn't matter whether you're smart or not – anyone can do this. It doubly stands up to them if you make a blogpost or a tweet saying "I did this. Here are the steps I followed." And this is less likely to happen if you discourage people from doing it. Honestly, it's a bit depressing how little people care. We're supposed to be the activists and the world-changers. But when it comes to merely doing anything at all, you're likely to get ass-blasted just for attempting the lowest common denominator form of protest. EDIT: Replying to your reply to my reply to your reply: If you click on a comment's timestamp, you can reply directly to it, even if HN's benevolent software doesn't normally show you the reply link. The reply link hides in order to discourage pointless flamewars. Like this one.
- linkmotif 8y agoAh thanks for that tip. Yes let’s not flame :)
- kibwen 8y agoRather one could attempt a protest of a higher denominator, for less effort, by using a non-Chrome-compatible browser, which also does more potential good in the long run by giving webmasters any reason to give a care for browsers that aren't unilaterally controlled by Google.
- browsercoin 8y agothis kills firefox for me.
- bootlooped 8y agoThis seems like one of the most difficult solutions to the problem of switching to a browser that's not Chrome. Not only are there other browsers like Firefox and Safari, but there are other Chromium-based browsers like Vivaldi and Opera. I would have liked to read about some expected use-cases in the readme.
- andrewmcwatters 8y agoYeah, Chrome isn't so good that I find a need for the open source community to maintain a fork of it. ⌘Space Safari and I get on with my life. It's been interesting to experience Internet Explorer, then Firefox, Chrome, and finally coming back to operating system default browsers with Edge and Safari and being perfectly content. The leverage Microsoft and Apple are utilizing with their operating system ecosystems is fairly pleasant, creating better out of the box experiences. Installing more software just feels like such a nit-picky user experience that I don't want, especially with refreshing my systems now and again.
- swasheck 8y agoWhy is this downvoted so heavily? It's a legitimate opinion. I don't agree with it and you may not either, but it highlights the fact that for at least a portion of the user base the default browser may be an acceptable option.
- andrewmcwatters 8y agoI would appreciate it more if people mentioned why my comment doesn't contribute to the discussion, but I think it's more realistic to say that I've been downvoted simply because someone didn't like what I had to say.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI didn't downvote you, but perhaps people are thinking that attitudes like the one presented in your original comment are what lead to IE6 and the general state of the internet in the late 90s / early 2000s?
- user812 8y agowhen I compile it on mac, it throws some errors. As a noob, I can't use ungoogled chromium apparently.
- ndnxhs 8y agoRather just use Firefox. Its an insanely good browser.
- thomasfedb 8y agoMade the swap recently and very pleased with the result.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agolol
- GeekyBear 8y agoEspecially for Firefoxes container functionality. >Allows you to sign in to two different accounts on the same site. Allows you to isolate your sites from one another, by containerizing tabs. Allows you to avoid leaving a social networking footprint to keep those sites from tracking you. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.techrepublic.com/google-amp/article/how-to-use-the-firefox-multi-account-containers-extension/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.techrepublic.com/google-amp...
- ndnxhs 8y agoFunny you mention avoiding tracking while pasting an AMP link. But yeah the containers are fucking amazing. I use them for development to log in as multiple user types at the same time.
- infogulch 8y agoYep this is actually a killer feature for development and more than makes up for the polish difference in dev tools imo.
- mtgx 8y agoI think the only thing that's missing is allowing the containers to sync with Firefox Sync with a client-side passphrase. I don't want to lose all of that "work" I've put into carefully separating websites into their own containers when I switch to another machine or re-install the OS, etc. Also, it should be easy to "reset and switch" a website from one container into another while leaving no traces that it's been in another container. I often load a website in no container or in another container, and then I use another plugin to switched it to where it should be. This should be a default feature.
- keyle 8y agoWouldn't it be better to move onto Brave then?
- floatingatoll 8y ago“It also features some changes” says to me that this isn’t a safe fork to recommend to others. Rather than simply releasing a de-badged instance of the public Chrome product, it additionally includes “editorial” comments in the form of turning various switches on or off. Use at your own risk.
- chii 8y agoif they transparently list out the changes (rather than force someone to diff the source), then it's OK.
- dj43nq 8y agoI'm with this. I'd actually like a fork of chromium with no googley phone home features. Maybe put timeouts on cookies and bunch of other things.
- ehsankia 8y agoIs it though? Security is a fickle thing. Unless there's a a big enough community behind it with security experts examining the changes, I'm not sure I'd trust some random person's changes to not introduce any exploits.
- floatingatoll 8y agoNope, my objection is to the mindset of making more changes than are necessary to release it. If their opinion had been restricted to “for removing Google” rather than also “and some other stuff”, it’d inspire a lot more trust in their long-term intentions. Being able to see diffs does not improve my trust in their judgement or reasoning.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoAnyone know how this differs from https://chromium.woolyss.com https://chromium.woolyss.com who has been building Chromium, for all major platforms, without Google features for years?
- odensc 8y agoThose seem to be builds of Chromium, which (even if you disable Sync and Widevine) still has Google integration in some places. On the other hand, `ungoogled-chromium` is a set of patches for Chromium that removes every Google feature/integration/service from the code.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoCheck features: https://chromium.woolyss.com/#features https://chromium.woolyss.com/#features It's doing more than that - No Google API key, no user identifier, no metrics or crash reports etc. I don't know enough of the guts of Chromium and Chrome to know if it covers everything, but seems comprehensive to my naive eye.
- snaky 8y agoEvery or almost every? E.g. Bromite (www.bromite.org) integrates privacy enhancement patches from Iridium, Inox patchset, Brave and ungoogled-chromium projects for some reason.
- jyrkesh 8y agoI use the woolyss binaries on purpose because they have Chrome Sync support on desktop (which I use for recent tabs and bookmarks). On mobile, no Chrome Sync without the official builds, so I cede all my privacy there. :'(
- jeena 8y agoI use Firefox on mobile and desktop because it is the only browser which lets you to run your own sync server: https://jeena.net/firefox-sync-15 https://jeena.net/firefox-sync-15
- xaduha 8y agoOpera is fine. Chinese connection doesn't bother me.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoClosed source, however, might bother one, especially in the context of privacy and trust.
- EastSmith 8y agoIf you want Chromium based browser - Opera or Brave seems the way to go.
- wmeredith 8y ago+1 for Brave
- ValentineC 8y agoNote that Opera is now owned by a Chinese consortium [1]. Vivaldi is the new browser by ex-Opera people. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otello_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otello_Corporation
- orionblastar 8y agoWhat about SWARE Iron? https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron.php https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron.php It is supposed to be the version of Chromium without the Google crap, right? I use it at times to test it out as I test out different websites on different browsers. They have it for different platforms: https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron_download.php https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron_download.php
- Zarel 8y agoSRWare Iron is a scam: http://www.insanitybit.com/2012/06/23/srware-iron-browser-a-real-private-alternative-to-chrome-21/ http://www.insanitybit.com/2012/06/23/srware-iron-browser-a-... Basically any other privacy-oriented Chromium fork would be better. Iridium seems nice?
- orionblastar 8y agoThank you I did not know. Someone recommended it to me one day as an alternative to Chrome. Iridium is this the one? https://iridiumbrowser.de/ https://iridiumbrowser.de/
- Zarel 8y agoYep, that's the one.
- orionblastar 8y agoThank you. I took a big hit on posting the Iron browser, but someone has to know about it so we know it is scamware.
- h1d 8y agoWhy would you post a link to a software with 3 news in the last 9 years? Are you affiliated? All their tweets seem like just version bump of base Chromium.
- mythz 8y agoMy preference for a well supported Chromium-based browser that's not Chrome would be to use one of the "Blink" based browsers: https://vivaldi.com https://vivaldi.com https://brave.com https://brave.com https://www.opera.com https://www.opera.com Opera was purchased by a Chinese consortium, I'm not a fan of Brave's hijacking of ad spaces so my preference is currently vivaldi - which was founded by co-founder and former CEO of Opera and has been adding new innovative features at a good pace. Edit: been having fun trying out the latest vivaldi, loving a lot of their features like you can add website filters like greyscale, invert colors and sepia, monospace font + disable loading images or only load from cache, etc. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dn03GeXWkAEXRP3.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dn03GeXWkAEXRP3.jpg Feels like they're focused on adding cool features users want, instead of Chrome's catering to mainstream-only users and features that benefit Google.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoBrave seems to be focusing on a monetization model that prevents third parties from tracking its users. Seems like a win-win. I’m okay with them hijacking ads if that allows them to succeed and thrive.
- projectramo 8y agoThanks for the tips. I hadn't heard of Vivaldi or Brave.
- mythz 8y agoI prefer each website be in control over their own monetization model and not dictated by the whims of a browser vendor without their consent.
- Sophistifunk 8y agoThat's what we have now. It hasn't exactly been working out for the users.
- 8y ago
- shagen 8y agoI'm using https://iridiumbrowser.de https://iridiumbrowser.de
- lucb1e 8y agoLots of browsers are mentioned in this thread, before clicking each one it might be nice to know a few things like whether it's open source and how development is sustained.
- h1d 8y agoI don't see a reason to trust anything without a track record when it comes to a browser.
- ben_bai 8y agoIt's Chromium without Google integration, too.
- upofadown 8y agoIn a discussion of privacy preserving browsers, open source can be assumed. The only task is to out those that are not for some reason. Here is the about page: * https://iridiumbrowser.de/about https://iridiumbrowser.de/about
- upofadown 8y agoIt seems to be a similar project. I encountered it as one of the best browsers currently running on OpenBSD. In particular it doesn't slowly leak memory over a period of weeks and get really slow like Firefox does on that platform[1]. [1] In fairness, Firefox slowly leaks memory on Linux as well, but it never gets entirely unusable, just mostly.
- known 8y agohttps://prism-break.org/en/all/#web-browsers https://prism-break.org/en/all/#web-browsers FTW
- pilif 8y agoWhy does this add various flags an knobs to disable ipv6? Disabling ipv6 has nothing to do with de-googling Chrome. What is it with people disabling rather than fixing their ipv6 config (and then possibly complaining about slow adoption)?
- progval 8y agoAre you refering to `--set-ipv6-probe-false`? This change might be motivated by the probe sending a request to a Google-owned IPv6 address.
- ZiiS 8y agoChromium tests if IPv6 is working by connecting to Google's DNS servers with it. This changes it to manual control so these servers can't track that connection.
- fulafel 8y agoThere is a change to that which preserves functionality: -// Google DNS address used for IPv6 probes. +/* RIPE NCC k.root-servers.net. 2001:7fd::1 (anycasted) */ So that's not it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vbsteven 8y agoIf you're so afraid of Google just don't use Chromium at all. It's a bit like using tools developed by the NSA thinking you are safe because you manually applied patches for all the known backdoors.
- techntoke 8y agoChromium is open source. MacOS, Windows, Safari, Edge, etc are not.
- TimTheTinker 8y agoSafari is open source (see WebKit). Darwin (MacOS kernel and subsystem) is also open source.
- commoner 8y agoOnly Safari's browser engine is open source. The browser as a whole is released under a proprietary freeware license.
- jakeogh 8y agoGentoo: emerge layman ; laymen -a alinefr ; emerge www-client/ungoogled-chromium
- trulyrandom 8y agoPlease don't recommend installing ancient versions of Chromium.
- jakeogh 8y agoTrue. Bad advice on my part. For ref that gets you: www-client/ungoogled-chromium-55.0.2883.75.1::alinefr Really, I wish gentoo would just -9999 most everything not in the core tree. Practically every custom ebuild in my own overlay does.
- dedsm 8y agoSince quantum arrived, firefox developer edition is my browser of choice, and with the containers functionality it checks all my marks.
- mosselman 8y agoIt was for me as well, but lately I have been experiencing incredible slow-downs in Firefox. I thought it must be my imagination until I tried other browsers and the difference was like between day and night. Firefox is just too slow, even with their new engine.
- noir_lord 8y agoFunnily enough I noticed this just the other day. On https://browserbench.org/Speedometer2.0/ https://browserbench.org/Speedometer2.0/ (usual benchmark caveats apply) Chrome scored 68.7 and FF scored 50. That was on Fedora 28 on a ThinkPad (i7-7700HQ), I was surprised at the delta between the two tbh.
- ksmithbaylor 8y agoI saw similar results on my MBP, with Chrome scoring ~90 and Firefox scoring ~60. Not enough to outweigh my reasons for using Firefox, but interesting.
- asendra 8y agoOn Safari 12, my 2015 13" rMBP scores 55, my iPhone X 89, and the new iPhone XS 125 !? Faster than the new iMac Pro (https://twitter.com/dhh/status/1043277162676072449 https://twitter.com/dhh/status/1043277162676072449)
- codydh 8y agoSafari 12, High Sierra, 2017 15" MBP scores 104. I'm surprised at these discrepancies.
- techntoke 8y ago
- aiCeivi9 8y ago> randomly selected factor in the range -0.0003% to 0.0003%, which are recomputed on every document initialization. Does that actually improve privacy or marks you as 0.001% percent of web users, that are using Bromite patches?
- mehrdadn 8y agoSo I tried moving off Chrome 68 to Firefox 62 today, and it's quite noticeably slower than Chrome. Here's a couple GIFs from Gmail to show what I mean [1]. I start both of them at the exact same frame that I release the Enter key, so you can see exactly how much longer Firefox takes. Notice that it takes longer to render the Star/Important icons, too (including the very noticeable flash of placeholder text), not merely load the page. The situation gets even worse when I install extensions, but these are on profiles that have already visited this page, but which are otherwise fresh. (Edit: Trying it on Facebook with a clean profile now. I realized I hadn't cleaned the profile before testing non-Google sites.) So I have to say, I'm really baffled. How are people switching to Firefox and finding it to be so fast? Is this speed difference unnoticeable for everyone but me? UPDATE: On Facebook, I see similar speeds without extensions. However, when I browse with my usual extensions, Firefox is again noticeably slower -- even though the extensions in Firefox are literally a subset of those in Chrome. Are other people's experiences similar? [1] https://imgur.com/a/1oFr5Q7 https://imgur.com/a/1oFr5Q7
- AsyncAwait 8y ago> Firefox 62 today, and it's quite noticeably slower than Chrome. Here's a couple GIFs from Gmail to show what I mean If you use any Google service in Firefox, it's slowed down by Google on purpose, so you don't switch. I'd use a 3rd party email client or switch off Gmail, otherwise I just let Google know their sleazy tactics work. Other than that, I notice Firefox having some performance issues specifically on macOS. I'm using it as my primary browser on Linux and since v57 it has been super fast.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- worble 8y agoGoogle actively hamper their services on Firefox. Gmail, YouTube, GoogleDocs, they all run worse. Try an independant site, you'll find much better results. Additionally, Firefox handles having a lot of concurrent tabs way way better than Chrome, so if you do that often you'll definitely notice the speed increase there.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoI love the anti-fingerprinting features and I just hope more people actively use them.
- TekMol 8y agoIt would be great if Debian could make the Chromium in their repos a de-googled version and keep it up to date. I have no idea how the Debian project is financed. So I don't know if it is possible for them to assign resources to it. But Debian has a strong history of being trustworthy. So a userfriendly browser maintained by them would be nice.
- zlatan_todoric 8y agoDebian gets sponsored by various ways but the money isn't used directly for developers nor their time. It is volunteer based project and money is usually used for hardware, sprints, conferences, outreachy etc. That said Debian does take it seriously when it comes to privacy and security so you can always report bugs on such. Do note that Debian's Chromium builds have always disabled the infamous "mic always on" option which Chromium has (or had, didn't check) by default. Btw, Debian now moved to gitlab hosting (their own instance salsa.debian.org) so it should be much easier to contribute to Debian now. :) P.S. while Debian Developer myself, I stay away a lot from browser and especially Chromium, and I always suggest Firefox (it has really got better last year or so).
- TekMol 8y agoit should be much easier to contribute to Debian now But aren't they constantly getting new versions of Chromium from Google? I think going into the Debian Repo of Chromium and changing it would not be a viable path, right? You either have to convince Google to accept your changes too (Good luck with them accepting the de-googling haha) or you would have to consider a life of constantly de-googling new versions of Chromium.
- zlatan_todoric 8y agoDebian maintains its set of patches often (quite easy to handle with quilt in debian/patches). We get upstream source from upstream of course and use our patches until they get accepted (we don't force upstream to do so) when we of course remove obsolete ones.
- 8y ago
- niftylettuce 8y agoGreat Chromium extensions you can get from GitHub: mkdir ungoogle-chromium-extensions cd ungoogled-chromium-extensions git clone https://github.com/zenorocha/codecopy git clone https://github.com/philc/vimium.git git clone https://github.com/OctoLinker/OctoLinker.git git clone https://github.com/ilGur1132/Smart-HTTPS.git git clone https://github.com/ovity/octotree.git git clone https://github.com/mrcoles/full-page-screen-capture-chrome-extension.git wget https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/releases/download/1.17.0/uBlock0.chromium.zip
- niftylettuce 8y agohttps://github.com/jswanner/DontFuckWithPaste https://github.com/jswanner/DontFuckWithPaste
- bad_user 8y agoIf you're using "Ungoogled" Chromium, you're still contributing to Chrome's monopoly and you're still helping Google's dominance of the web. Chromium may be open source, but its development is controlled by Google. Unless you have Google-like resources available, you won't be able to create a meaningful fork that your less technically savvy users can benefit from. "Ungoogled" Chromium is a trap. Use another browser. Use Firefox. Use Safari. Heck, use Edge (aka the new IExplorer). Because lets stop beating around the bush ... Chrome is the new IExplorer 6.
- no29 8y agothe sky is falling.. the sky is falling
- pythonaut_16 8y agoThe user isn't the problem, the developer is. If you're developing against Chrome/Chromium, particularly "works in Chrome" instead of developing against the published Web standards, you're support Google & Chrome.
- jononor 8y agoThe developers decisions are influenced a lot on marketshare. Non-Chrome/Blink being more common will make "Works in Chrome" development less common.
- pythonaut_16 8y agoThat's fair but you can easily develop for the majority Chrome marketshare by focusing on designing and building your applications on top of the actual web standards instead of Chrome's specific implementations. Probably 95% of the APIs you use in a typical app will be easy to use in a standard way anyway. WebRTC and some of the more mercurial APIs might be a challenge though.
- jononor 8y agoMost developers probably try to do that. But often they only develop on Chrome, and maybe only have automated tests in Chrome (or not at all...). And then when it then breaks for non-Chrome, fixing tends to get lower priority than new features and bug affecting more users.
- xurukefi 8y agoWell, have fun maintaining that. Sort of reminds me of all the privacy-improving registry hacks for Win10 that become obsolete after the next Windows update.
- MarcysVonEylau 8y agoEveryone says to dump Chrome, and suggest other platforms that are comparable from a users perspective. But what about DevTools? Chrome has by far the best Web Development capabilities out of any other browser. Is there any single alternative or a set of tools that can match it?
- ktpsns 8y agoI love the concept of the fingerprinting deception features --fingerprinting-canvas-measuretext-noise --fingerprinting-canvas-image-data-noise --fingerprinting-client-rects-noise I wonder whether we can get similar features in Mozilla Firefox or regular Chromium? Probably with an extension? Is anybody aware of something like that? Or does it really need to be baked into the core of the browser?