4 ms·
The experience most people have with the homeless is being harassed by the chronically homeless as they go on about their regular lives, especially downtown. I
by vorpalhex 8y ago
The experience most people have with the homeless is being harassed by the chronically homeless as they go on about their regular lives, especially downtown. I worked a block from a homeless shelter for a few years, and there was an overdose or knife fight a couple times per day, not to mention people shooting up drugs or shitting on sidewalks.
It's great to hold a moral high ground, but at some point we need to connect with reality. There are people who are chronically homeless and certainly not moral guiding stars, and there are many more situationally homeless people who need help and are perfectly fine folks.
- Spearchucker 8y agoHow d'you know what most people's experience with the homeless is? Also, distinguishing between "homeless" and "chronically homeless" (which makes it sound like an extreme sport) by your definition can only happen once you've been stabbed, stabbed another, or squeezed one out on the sidewalk. So until one of these things happen you don't really know. Forgive me, but it sounds to me like an easy way to justify hating on the homeless. Chronic or otherwise.
- darawk 8y agoThere's a pretty reasonable distinction to be drawn here. The real problem here is that the homeless that most people experience really are what they seem like: drug addicted, mentally incapacitated, or completely irresponsible and unaccountable. These people are not good candidates for jobs, and it would indeed be surprising to see them successful in a role like this. However, there's a large class of people that are not out there panhandling, not making themselves visible to regular people who are homeless, and are perfectly responsible and capable. These people can and are benefiting from programs like this. Let's not blur this distinction for some misguided sense of social justice.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoOne also has to wonder how many of the homeless who use drugs, or have mental issues came to do so because of their situational homelessness. It really isn't difficult to imagine becoming homeless, which then leads to depression and other mental issues and then using drugs to escape that. So some proportion of the "problem group" are going to be redeemable too.
- pmiller2 8y agoThis is the theory behind "housing first" programs, and it works. Literally getting people off the street provides stability that helps them get other things in their life right.
- darawk 8y agoYa, I don't mean to suggest that they're all irredeemable. They're definitely not. But the problem group is a lot riskier and takes a lot more investment to help.
- bojackstorkman 8y agoIn my experience of living in multiple shelters/streets/camps in multiple cities is that there is a lot of truth to this idea. For example, I knew a man that was incredibly ornery, almost always drunk, and prone to occasional violent outbursts. Everybody (including the rest of us in the camp) avoided him. About a year after I left the camp, I ran into his daughter and learned that he had been a normal, successful eletrician that had sustained a severe brain injury at work, and his employer managed to avoid paying for workman's compensation or helping with his medical bills, leaving him permanently disabled and with no safety net. I knew another man that also received a brain injury during a car crash in which he also lost the only extant copy of his masters' thesis in anthropology (the crash occurred in the 80s), and was in a similar position. I knew a man that actually managed to get a section 8 apartment, but lost it because he opted to move back to the riverbottom and let a pregnant homeless woman stay in it in his stead. He was then also cut off from ALL social programs. I saw a man get banned for life from an entire network of shelters spanning a huge chunk of the state for taking three (3!) single-use packets of Tide laundry detergent out of the facility. I have also met a (very) small handful of genuinely odd people that just preferred to live mostly off the grid but still wanted to be near their families/veterinary clinic/spouse's grave/etc. but they are very much the exception and not the rule. I think that for some people with limited experience with the homeless, people that are chronically homeless might appear to all fall into this category. I do 't think this happens all the time, or even to a majority of the population, but it is an idea that I have heard repeated numerous times. From my experience, the details are almost always surprising, and the search for simple explanations or solutions is frustratingly unsatisfying.
- pmiller2 8y agoRegardless of what "most peoples' experience" is, people tend to remember things that are extreme. So, the smelly, ranting, alcoholic sticks in one's head. The person sitting quietly at the BART station with a sign, not so much. Someone shooting up in the middle of the station, hell yeah. Who remembers anyone who's simply camping for the day at the public library and using it to try and search for jobs? I can tell you, I've seen all of those and more. I worked with homeless people long term in a shelter for 2 years, and, of the folks I came into direct contact with every day, I don't think 95% of them could survive contact with the real world of employment, paying rent, etc. due to disability (mental or physical), addictions, and/or general lack of a support system. Granted, I worked with people who were not in the shelter's higher tier programs (where housing was provided for a set period, and job assistance provided, in exchange for attending training and religious sessions). The more vulnerable ones, the ones I worked with, were the ones you'd see out on the street, collecting cans and bottles or panhandling. People "hate" the homeless because the ones they come into contact with who are visibly homeless are often not functional members of society. Simply put, they violate social norms in a way that disgusts most people. Nobody "hates" someone who's couch surfing or living in a car, but who's clean, not an addict, and is trying to get out of the situation the best they can.
- usrusr 8y ago> in exchange for attending training and religious sessions That just leaves me speechless
- kingkawn 8y agoWhat does moralizing have to do with it? These are people who could benefit from systematized programmatic interventions. Relying on some moral guideposts to decide who is worthy and who should be harassed or left to suffer feels really pointless. Just help them, both for their sake and for the quality of life of everyone else around them.
- 1123581321 8y agoSet aside morality and look at costs and priorities. It’s difficult to help people who just need to interrupt a bad cycle using the same programs as people who cannot, or choose not to, graduate into a more self-sufficient program or lifestyle. And the answer isn’t simply more money, unfortunately, as there are also limits to qualified staff, effective housing and facility locations, effective following steps that don’t lead to relapse, special education/home visit resources, etc. Edit: I am writing from a city that has mostly solved homelessness, so I am not saying it cannot be done. Just that an indiscriminate approach is unlikely to work.
- kingkawn 8y agoNot an indiscrimitate approach; different people require different types of help. But to claim the problem unsolvable and throw up our hands is unnecessarily cruel. All kinds of hard problems get solved so that they don’t harm anyone anymore. Why not this one?
- 1123581321 8y agoI think “throwing up hands” looks the same as prioritizing with few enough resources available. I agree the original comment wasn’t incisive enough (drug use is way too obtuse of a proxy for receptiveness to receiving help) but I also have seen naive approaches spend resources that should have gone to others first. It’s challenging. My hope is that effective use of vacant properties will proliferate because more responsible people can live in them, freeing up expensive lower-trust facilities for people who shouldn’t be let alone before they've received treatment, cut criminal ties, etc.
- noobermin 8y agoHave you not looked at wall street and seen people shooting up drugs or people in our government who have been accused of sexual misconduct myriad times? How about that those same people who are responsible for making many of those people homeless in the first place skating and allowed to bring us on the verge of financial collapse again? Where is the moral high ground for these people?
- icebraining 8y agoMany of those are reviled as well. "just 31 percent look favorably on corporate executives and Wall Street" https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-19/wall-street-efforts-to-improve-its-image-fail-to-sway-americans https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-19/wall-stre...
- stale2002 8y agoOk, and if I were to walk in downtown NYC, next to the the stock exchange, would these wall street traders start harassing me when I am just trying to get where I am going? No, that doesn't happen. Do you see the difference?
- clairity 8y agoyeah, unlike wall street, i get to choose when i give money to homeless people.
- snackbugs 8y agoThose financial workers whined and threw fits to receive federal bailouts while everyone else's futures and livelihoods were on fire with no chance of the same white-glove treatment. The banal dichotomy you're trying to illustrate here is just a rationalization for sorting humanity by their wealth.
- stale2002 8y agoAll I am saying is that they never accosted me on the street for a bailout. They may have "threw fits" metaphorically, but they did not do so to me in the streets, literally.
- pkaler 8y agoI live in downtown Vancouver. I'm in one of the more affluent neighbourhoods however about 11% of housing is non-market (depending on how you count). Vancouver has a fairly large homeless population because it is the most temperate Canadian city. Most of the homeless people are just regular people. Sure, some of them have substance abuse problems. But stand up in your cubicle when you get to the office on Monday morning. One of the coworkers that you can see from your desk has probably taken an opioid, cocaine, amphetamine, or a prescribed drug for ADHD or anxiety. And they are fully functional. Your coworkers are regular people. Just like the homeless that you see. More people than you know are one missed paycheque away from being on the streets. Many of the "chronically homeless" as you call it are one medicine away or one therapist away from being fully functional. And one of your coworkers is one paycheque away, one bad week away from being chronically homeless.
- chrisweekly 8y ago> "prescribed drug for ADHD or anxiety" I think you intended to imply "without a prescription" in grouping such people with daytime cocaine users.
- drb91 8y ago> I think you intended to imply "without a prescription" in grouping such people with daytime cocaine users. Actually reading the comment the driving point seems to be that there's less separating them than you might think--people on and off the street have legal and illegal uses for drugs, so perhaps the legal distinction isn't very useful at discerning the cause of homelessness. In fact, the main differentiating symptom between legal and illegal drug use seems to be prison.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TulliusCicero 8y agoThe very fact that drug-using coworkers are able to maintain a regular job demonstrates that they're stable and functional, though. You can't say the same for most of the drug-using homeless population. > Many of the "chronically homeless" as you call it are one medicine away or one therapist away from being fully functional. [Citation needed] IIRC when SLC got most its chronically homeless into permanent housing and assistance, their problems did decrease substantially. But most still weren't really able to work.
- stephengillie 8y agoThe chronic homeless are a different group than the normal homeless person. Most homeless people just couldn't make ends meet, then saw their resources cut off like dominoes falling. They haven't given up on the capitalist dream, and they will purchase shelter again from the free market, once ends do meet.