6 ms·
Amazon is a company that wants to know everything about me, just like Google. They want to sell me all kinds of stuff. Not a company I'd trust with private data
by Tepix 8y ago
Amazon is a company that wants to know everything about me, just like Google. They want to sell me all kinds of stuff.
Not a company I'd trust with private data about my home.
- lykr0n 8y agoThat's my concern as well. I love the idea of home automation, but I don't want someone else to have that data. It sucks, but we're the minority here.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoWe're all in luck because the Home Assistant community [1] is on it. It's still a bit of a tinkerer's domain but things are rapidly evolving and becoming more user friendly. [1] https://www.home-assistant.io/blog/2018/09/17/thinking-big/ https://www.home-assistant.io/blog/2018/09/17/thinking-big/
- kazen44 8y agoAlso, IKEA has simple, but very effective home automation (lighting and plugs for now though more will come) that is dead simple to use and can work without an internet connection[1] Also, home assistant integration is dead easy and it's very cheap compared to comparable products. (Especially because amazon's offerings are vastly overpriced in countries where they have no locations). https://www.iot-tests.org/2017/04/ikea-tradfri-a-smart-light-in-the-darkness-of-iot-security/ https://www.iot-tests.org/2017/04/ikea-tradfri-a-smart-light...
- tfha 8y ago"Works without an Internet connection" That's all I want. Why did the first two generations of smart home equipment require a cloud? That's harder to develop. blegh
- CamperBob2 8y agoBecause good luck getting VC funding for anything that doesn't imprison the user in your company's cloud.
- kazen44 8y agocompanies like IKEA and phillip's don't need VC funding to launch a new product line though.
- JoshMnem 8y ago> It sucks, but we're the minority here. I'm not interested in any home automation. The ability to turn on my lights with a wristwatch doesn't have reasonable benefits compared to the risks. It's hard for me to believe that people actually put these Internet-connected, voice-activated devices in their homes. The smartphones are bad enough. That kind of automation doesn't encourage living deliberately, and the privacy and behavior manipulation (tracking, ads, etc.) issues around it are horrendous. (DIY can avoid most of those problems though.)
- kazen44 8y ago90% of the functionality one reasonably wants from their home automation systems comes down to basically some descrete logic and some sensory input. 1) automatic lighting depending on occupancy. (this has existed since the 80's) 2) time based events which respond to either heating or lighting, maybe alarm systems aswell. 3) acces control/security Those are basically all major systems most people would want to automate in their homes, and none of them should require voice control or a smartphone app. (heck, most could be done with discrete PLC's, although that would be a horrible UX).
- Karunamon 8y agoI'd add a #4 voice control to that. You don't think you need it until you've used it, then you use it and wonder how the hell you ever survived without it. An Echo with a couple of smart switches feels like the future. This is one of the sane use cases for the cloud, IMO. Local speech recognition kinda sucks, and expecting consumers to manually update their firmware (since we've taken auto updates off the table) for new improvements is not realistic.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoI've been monitoring my energy consumption, extending my existing doorbell to an upstairs stereo, automatically turning lights on in different modes as I walk around at different times of day, playing a beautiful loon call as the sun sets, securing my home while I'm away (it auto-arms when my phone disconnects from the router and disarms when it returns), turning on a/c when I begin my commute home, reminding me it's garbage day, etc. All locally running on an open source platform with remote access over OpenVPN. This is the wonder of Home Assistant. It's mostly just for fun but you can easily see it becoming very practical. My security system is legit; it emails snapshots from cameras to a special account that triggers a urgent notification on my phone while turning on a loud siren in the home and all the lights. I did a funhouse mode that played static on the tv and monster/police/machine gun noises on the stereo while chaotically blinking all the lights... it actually scared even me a little.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThere's been a couple of really promising privacy respecting Indiegogo or Kickstarter offerings, but neither got to a product. I find it really hard to believe there isn't a viable way to a home assistant / hub that leaves control and privacy in the home. The whole IoT, app, with constant data harvesting and selling is not what I want in the home, just control and ability to buy without all the dystopian baggage. It all seemed so much more promising back in the days of X10 and keeping automation on the LAN. Edit: X10 was launched in 1978. No wonder it could do with a refresh! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/X10_(industry_standard) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/X10_(industry_standard)
- kazen44 8y agoProper "home automation" systems do exists, but they are usually meant for automating public and large buildings, require a KNX network (which is very, very expensive on the device and programming side) and usually have hardware which is simple not affordable to the average consumer. KNX works fine, it is a broad standard with a ton of support, the issue is it's massive pricepoint and fact that almost every hardware device that has support for it comes in a DIN package. (which is fine for large scale buildings with utility closets which have DIN rails, but not for your average home).
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSounds like there's a niche I'd dearly love someone to find and exploit. X10 still exists, and modules are still sold (for about a tenth of the cost of KNX modules from a quick search), but it's an ancient standard and very limited compared to what we might now expect. On, off and dimming are about the extent of its abilities.
- kazen44 8y agoKNX can do basically anything you want from a building (including HVAC, security systems etc), but is just very, very expensive. Also, most software server front ends for it are horrible. I am actually wondering if building a relatively cheap KNX hardware module for home assistant might just not be the best option in that regard.
- thrav 8y agoAt least they’re using it to directly sell you stuff though. I find that head and shoulders above selling it to people who want to sell you stuff, but also may want to do a lot of other things. Amazon is not deceptive in their sales tactics, which I appreciate. They identify likely needs, and provide me with options for meeting those needs. They provide a service. They’re like a personal shopper who leaves everything on your door step. You pay for it, but you’re mostly happy to because it’s kind of a win win (except for the pickers). Sometimes you still save money, and you almost certainly save loads of time. They’re capturing your information in an effort to better serve you. You could say Google is doing the same with their direct products, but you’re not the one paying for those benefits, so you have to worry who is and what they’re getting out of the dynamic. At least with Amazon you know they’re doing it to get money from you, and you can choose to give them that money or not. It’s a much more straightforward dynamic.
- TarpitCarnivore 8y agoYou're kidding yourself if you don't think Amazon is selling that data: "The Amazon Advertising Platform allows advertisers to efficiently reach Amazon shoppers on Amazon sites, across the web, and in mobile apps." https://advertising.amazon.com/ad-specs/en/aap https://advertising.amazon.com/ad-specs/en/aap Also not for nothing but this is the same kind of thing we all said with Google early on and now we're all beginning to pull back on it.
- Karunamon 8y agoSelling access to you is not the same as selling the data, and it is in fact dishonest to equate the two. There is no endpoint Amazon provides where I can get data about people. They have no reason to sell the data - it's their crown jewels and competitive advantage.
- newscracker 8y agoThe same can be said of Google and Facebook too. Data is their "crown jewel" and platforms on top of that are their competitive advantage. But we do see goof ups and data being sold (to specific "partners" or affiliates) or stolen anyway. The easier route for those who value privacy is not to use such platforms and devices in the first place. Amazon and a Google are no different from this perspective.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThe real distinction is the sheer greed with the IoT domain. They want you to pay in both cash and data while often having planned obsolescence and dependencies that make it abundantly clear that the master they serve is not you. Anyone who wants you to pay twice for the same thing is not to be trusted. It seems like literally everyone in the domain is thinking of how to exploit the customers first and serve them second with security as an afterthought at best. Alexa is especially bad about the last one given they are stupid enough to include a voice interface for skills installing and don't rigorously check the word selection or confirmation before installing unknown software.