5 ms·
California poverty rate highest in U.S. when housing costs factored in
- curtis 8y ago> Accounting for housing costs, California has nation’s highest poverty rate I assume that the underlying study breaks the population down into quintiles or deciles based on income and then looks at spending on housing for each group, but it's not clear from the article. If you simply compare average income to average housing costs you're going to get a skewed result. A software engineer living in the Bay Area could be well over the national average for housing (40% or 50% of income, maybe more in some cases) but they're definitely not contributing to an increased poverty level. Another way of looking at this is that California's poorest counties are in the Central Valley. I suspect this is also where California's cheapest real estate is at.
- lucb1e 8y agoGood point. To elaborate on it: > If you simply compare average income to average housing costs you're going to get a skewed result. Particularly because averages give skewed results given outliers, which there surely must be. (Particularly with wages, I imagine, someone can be hugely overpaid (like 1M vs. 100k), but you can hardly be 900k underpaid because then you'd be making negative money.) The median value makes more sense when one does not want to be affected as much by outliers. Not that comparing the median housing price to the median income is necessarily a correct or complete view; I just noticed that we're talking about averages which are even worse for this purpose.
- dmode 8y agoThis is exactly right. A statewide housing adjustment doesn't make any sense. Bay Area housing cost doesn't impact the poorest regions of the state which are in Mojave desert, Sierra Nevada foothills, far north towards Oregon border
- hellofunk 8y agoThis suggests that poverty rates do not consider the important factors required to accurately assess if someone is able to afford life. Which surprises me. Why wouldn't cost of living be included in a term that by definition refers to the ability to cover the cost of living?
- anothergoogler 8y agoIt's why you should be skeptical of the "X% of people globally have been lifted out of extreme poverty in the past X years" stories.
- jopsen 8y agoDon't confuse extreme poverty and poverty. Extreme poverty is defined as: "a condition characterized by severe deprivation of basic human needs, including food, safe drinking water, sanitation facilities, health, shelter, education and information. It depends not only on income but also on access to services." Generally, I'm skeptical of adjusting for cost of living when you have housing prices as you do in the bay area. You still have options to move away.
- sampleinajar 8y ago> You still have options to move away. True, but that is not a costless option.
- pmiller2 8y agoThis is the real reason CoL should be factored into the poverty line. If you’re barely (or not even) getting by, where do you get the money to move? Remember that many Americans can’t even meet a $500 emergency expense. Someone who can’t come up with $500 by any means in an emergency is not going to be able to afford to go anywhere.
- shoo 8y ago
- swingline-747 8y agoMight be right. I chose to live in a Vanagon Westfalia rather than pay the extortion rates for Valley rent. Single-family homes far from employment are around $1M. In other states, such homes go for $90-300k. This implies around 90% of the value is in the land. Basically, if you're not actively working in tech or servicing tech companies, it doesn't make any sense to remain in the Valley. On retirement, definitely also move somewhere else because it's a pay-to-play game.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Basically, if you're not actively working in tech or servicing tech companies, it doesn't make any sense to remain in the Valley. From a game theory perspective, certainly not. The danger is: what happens when all the tech employees suddenly don't have any Uber drivers, any paramedics, any supermarket vendors, hell any cleaning personnel any more? When their homes get raided by criminals because cops cannot afford living in SV any more? When their kids have nowhere to go to school? That's the thing why the Free Market does not work for basic human necessities. If the Free Market would do its job Walmart and Amazon employees wouldn't be forced to top their "wages" up with food stamps and other social benefits.
- manfredo 8y agoThe free market handles these factors just fine. If Uber can't find any drivers in the bay area they'll up their prices and pay drivers more. If municipalities can't find people to provide government services, they'll increase wages. That's why BART janitors pull six figures.
- mschuster91 8y ago> The free market handles these factors just fine. Then do tell me why companies like Amazon and Walmart get away with, essentially, state subsidies for their employees and why in many parts of the US teachers complain about being massively underfunded, to the point of Oklahoma switching to 4-day school days so teachers can work on the side to earn money?!
- rasz 8y agooh, the joys of traveling thru real life tent city on your way to Comic-Con/E3, real culture shock to people from Europe.
- interknot 8y agoPresumably attendees from Calais or Paris experienced slightly less culture shock.
- RobAtticus 8y agoCalifornia is the highest state; DC is the highest of the regions listed at 20.2% vs California's 19% [2]. Also interesting to note that the rate in California has been dropping over the past few years - 20.6% avg for 2013/2014/2015 [0], 20.4% for 2016 [1], and 19% for 2017. The national supplemental poverty rate is relatively flat over the same time frame -- 14.3% in 2015 and 13.9% in 2017 [0] https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2016/demo/p60-258.pdf https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publicatio... [1] https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2017/demo/p60-261.pdf https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publicatio... [2] https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2018/demo/p60-265.pdf https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publicatio...
- pascalxus 8y agoI think 19% really understates the scale of the problem. If you removed all the subsidies and the housing subsidies and enormous programs, I would imagine, that number would be even higher. I really wish they would go into the root causes of what's causing all this hardship. Too often, these articles don't cover the real causes and just cause knee-jerk emotional reactions. Without knowing the true cause, we can never address the real problem: An imbalance between the number of jobs and the housing availability. Either housing supply has to increase or all those FB/Google employers bringing in employees from out of the state and outside the US, need to stop doing that in areas that don't want to grow. The hardships we face here in CA are all self imposed. Voters and their politicians enacted each and every single regulation that's prevented housing from being built over the last 50 years. It doesn't have to be this way. There are other places that grow just as quickly and don't have these problems: Houston, Dallas, Austin. Austin's already getting worse due to all the anti-housing folks moving there (ironically whilst escaping CA housing problems). Chicago has over 2 million residents, with great housing and very little government intervention/regulations. CA can learn a lot from those states and cities.
- mancerayder 8y agoEither housing supply has to increase or all those FB/Google employers bringing in employees from out of the state and outside the US, need to stop doing that in areas that don't want to grow. How are areas to make this determination? By democratic vote? At what level, the almost invisible local electorate? Maybe I'm cynical about the level of corruption in local politics here in NY, but call me skeptical. And what communities don't want new jobs to materialize? It brings infusions of cash, even if housing demand goes crazy as a consequence. A depressed housing market, if you remember the landscape in 2008, caused a lot of strife.