6 ms·
I'm a Heart Doctor and Wary of the New Apple Watch
- wlesieutre 8y agoI don’t know about the ECG part, but buying an Apple Watch has definitely made me exercise more
- stri8ed 8y agoHow so?
- pen2l 8y agoApple Watch 'gameifies' fitness. You set a goal of burning a certain amount of calories, "moving" a certain distance, etc. -- and it tracks these things, and gives you little "awards" for when you successfully meet your goals per week or per month, and tries to encourage you in smart ways if you're not making your goals ("Hey if you do a brisk walk in the next few minutes, you'll have met your goal!!"). I find that these reminders work pretty well for me. As well, if you have peers who have Apple Watch/fitbit, there are tons of apps you can use to "compete" with them.
- wlesieutre 8y agoIt measures activity and lets you set goals. I used to have days where I didn’t really do anything except lay on the couch or sit at the computer. Now I don’t. https://www.apple.com/watch/close-your-rings/ https://www.apple.com/watch/close-your-rings/
- gumby 8y agoPaywalled, and not in the .is archive.
- candylifter 8y agoYou can easily get around Medium's paywall by opening in incognito window
- anothergoogler 8y agoYou can also use a script blocker. Medium's site is annoying enough I've disabled all of their JS with uMatrix. Most journalism paywalls are half-assed JS-dependent paper tigers, and I don't know why they befuddle so many "hackers" here.
- heavymark 8y agoThe doctor says buy it if you think its ‘nifty’ but do bit buy it for health since it will not make you healthier. That’s crazy, it will certainly not make every person healthy still like a personal trainer it cant make you do anything but it can certainly encourage much healthier habits as it does for millions of people like myself with real world tangible results. He dilutes his more valid concern about his belief of saving lives from AFIB may or may not outweigh the inconvenience false postives could cause.
- DanBC 8y agoDo we have any evidence that these devices lead to long lasting changes? We know that fitbit doesn't. Or, better, that they lead to reduction in all cause mortality or reduction in days lost to disability?
- threatofrain 8y agoSo the argument of the article is that widespread screening may cause net harm. The issue is with the imprecision of the test, as well as the followup procedures necessary to be precise, and the probability of mistreatment.
- DanBC 8y agoNo. We know that widespread screening does cause harm, even if the tests are 100% accurate.
- fearoffish 8y agoCould you show me the evidence for this so I can be educated.
- ghufran_syed 8y agoSome info regarding possible harms of prostate cancer screening: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5485506/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5485506/ Relevant snippet: ‘The potential gains of screening are opposed by reduced QoL related to diagnostic biopsies, burdensome cancer treatment, including radical prostatectomy (RP), radiotherapy (RT), and androgen deprivation therapy (ADT), and the frequent long-term treatment-related adverse events, including erectile dysfunction (ED), urinary incontinence (UI) and bowel dysfunction (BD) [12–14]. In addition, RP has a small risk of peri-operative death [12, 13]. Finally, since a substantial fraction of PCas shows late onset and slow progression, overdiagnosis and overtreatment are common consequences of screening, especially when it is performed repeatedly or in men with relatively short remaining life expectancy due to age or life-shortening co-morbidity. Overdiagnosis and overtreatment are difficult to assess in empirical studies, because it would require a lifelong follow-up of men randomized to no screening and various screening options in a study without migration bias.“
- mikeash 8y agoThose sound like consequences of improper reactions to screening results, not consequences of screening. The solution should be to make better decisions with the results.
- dpatrick86 8y agoIt really sounds like a software issue to me. If the watch is causing atrial fibrillation to be detected too often, then you can either make the software meet some greater threshold before alerting the user.. or, even better, determine more fully formed diagnostic criteria to be applied. The fact that medicine hasn't studied whether or not healthy hearts are regularly doing this because sensors were inconvenient previously, doesn't mean we need to get rid of the sensors. It means that both the presentation of the software should have some sort of feedback loop from clinical research that should emerge as a consequence of that data now... existing.
- esalman 8y ago> you can either make the software meet some greater threshold That will, on the other hand, increase false negatives. I think that will defeat the whole purpose of putting the sensor in the watch. > medicine hasn't studied whether or not healthy hearts are regularly doing this because sensors were inconvenient previously Medicine has studied this. It is just that this specific kind of diagnosis is subjective and there are a lot of debate. The main point, from what I understood, the author is arguing is that the one-lead EEG of the Apple watch is prone to higher false positives, and users should take it with a grain of salt.
- Kliment 8y agoThe way I read it, applying something with a nonnegligible false positive rate to a much larger population (that is, screening everyone without indications) will lead to many incorrect diagnoses because your error rate is multiplied by a large healthy population. Whereas applying diagnostic tests only to people with suspected a-fib gives you a smaller group with a higher base rate of what you're looking for, so false positives are not as much of a problem.
- dan000892 8y ago“Since all medical interventions come with risks, many people will suffer harm from unnecessary tests and procedures.” I agree with this statement generally, but in this specific case it seems tenuous. If the iWatch’s 1-lead EKG detected a-fib, the next course of action would be a more reliable diagnostic, specifically a proper 12-lead EKG interpreted by a qualified medical professional, perhaps followed by a Holter monitor to record 5 or more leads over a 48+ hour period. A 12-lead involves attaching ten electrode stickers to a patient which are then wired up to a backpack-sized monitor which passively reads the difference in electrical activity between specific electrodes. It’s a simple non-invasive procedure that’s performed a hundred thousand times a day in the US. In fact, it’s so simple and low-risk that I as a lowly EMT am allowed to perform it. (To drive this point home, the state of California does not allow me to prick a patient’s finger to get the drop of blood required to ascertain blood sugar. I need a paramedic to do that for me.) It’s absurd for this doctor to suggest an asymptomatic young person could be prescribed anticoagulants for a-fib “diagnosed” by an iWatch. I can understand doctors expressing opposition to “self-diagnostic medicine” but to make these arguments about a 1-lead makes as much sense as arguing that people shouldn’t be able to buy and operate a blood pressure machine without a prescription.
- ghufran_syed 8y agoNot so “absurd” - you may be missing some context. A 12-lead ecg can diagnose whether you have a-fib at the time of the ecg. The question for the doctor is whether you may have “paroxysmal” ie intermittent a-fib. So what if the Apple Watch said ‘a-fib’, but the 12-lead is negative. Most doctors are probably going to end up ordering a holter- monitor, to monitor the patient’s rhythm over 24-72 hours. Some proportion of those patients may have very short runs of a-fib, and would likely have remained blissfully ignorant (and well) without the Apple Watch. Instead, they may well end up anti-coagulated, because if that patient is not anticoagulated and gets a stroke later ( which may or may not be due to a-fib), the doctor is going to get sued. Whereas if the doc starts the patient on anticoagulants, and tells the patient that, “ there’s a risk of bleeding, but...”, that is much less likely to end up in a lawsuit.
- heartIssuesGal 8y ago
- Latteland 8y agoThis article needs more analysis. How many people who didn't know about af will be detected by the device, compared to the 100k estimated false positives. And do these pan out the same way for other heart ailments.
- dhnsmakala 8y agoI'm not a heart doctor. Here's why I am not wary of the Apple Watch: 1. At a societal level, perhaps false positives during screening put undue load on the medical system. But as an individual, it makes sense for me to screen for anything that does not take too high of an effort. If there is a false positive, it will be snuffed out in the next test. 2. Here is a little thought experiment. Lets say the false positive rate is 1%, and you screen 100 people. Then, your total number of tests including repeated tests on false positive subjects will be ~101 on average (the chance of 2 or more false positives is low enough to ignore). As long as the screening itself is not too much of an effort, then in fact false positives don't add that much load to the system. So, we should be seeking additional methods for widespread screening rather than worrying about false positive rates. --- I also find the doctors assumption of 10% false positive rates to be a little self serving in his argument. 1 in 10 people with an apple watch are going to be have atrial fibrillation detection? Doubt it.
- anothergoogler 8y agoThat's a lot of words to say that your hunch of a 1% false positive rate is more likely than the heart doctor's hunch of 10%.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat would make some sense if we were talking about tests for long-term state, but from what I understand, the test in question detects a potentially rare and irregular event happening. Which means, you can test yourself 100 times, get one indication of a problem, and still not have enough information to be confident that it was a false positive.
- coldtea 8y agoTo gain some free publicity by stating the obvious which was already accounted for?
- malshe 8y agoWhat’s the source for 10% specificity? I couldn’t find any article that said this was the case. In fact the only article that mentions any numbers is written by Quartz and says this: “Cardiologists were able to read 90% of the total readings, although about 10% of them were unreadable.” That’s not false positive.
- avip 8y agoHe did not source it directly, but looking at some ROC curves from AF detection publications the numbers seem completely reasonable.
- dev_dull 8y ago> I worry that the Apple Watch will discover lots of short-duration AF or AF occurring in younger people with fewer risk factors. Given their lower risk of stroke, it’s unlikely that anticoagulant drugs will deliver similar benefits. But anticoagulants do increase the risk of bleeding. This is completely grounded in science. And we should be weary of going to the doctor too often: >Medical Errors Are Third Leading Cause of Death in the U.S. 1. https://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-05-03/medical-errors-are-third-leading-cause-of-death-in-the-us https://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-05-03/medical-erro...
- philwelch 8y agoThe vast majority of these fatal medical errors happen in the hospital, and healthy people don't often end up hospitalized. Much of the time, the alternative to hospitalization is going to be fatal anyway.
- empath75 8y agoSo I started having premature ventricular contractions a couple of years ago, and had a lot of anxiety around it — I made multiple emergency room visits and trips to the cardiologists because I was convinced that when they were giving me ecgs, they weren’t getting it when I was having a severe problem and were missing a-fib(which runs in my family) They eventually told me to get a Kardia so I could check it whenever I wanted to. After a few weeks of checking every time I thought something was going on and periodically sending the worst examples to their analysts, I realized it was only ever pvcs, and it dramatically lowered my stress levels and made the episodes much less severe and shorter lasting. It also helped me figure out my triggers (caffeine) and helped me realize that going on a brisk walk for 15 minutes pretty much always stops them. I wouldn’t say the Kardia saved my life or made me healthier, but it absolutely helped me get a handle emotionally on what was going on with my heart and improved my quality of life. I don’t carry it around any more, but I definitely think it’s worth getting (or the new watch) if you have palpitations and want to get a better idea of what’s going on.
- gist 8y agoThe issue is not whether it would be of benefit to someone like you. The issue is if having that feature as well as the downside risk to people who are in the general public and don't have a particular risk factor or need. Also it's not an option it's built in the core product. As such it will alarm people that have no reason to be using it in the first place even if it ends up alerting and saving some people in the process. Is it worth it to give 1000 people anxiety, tests, medication in order to provide benefit to 10 people or even 100? (those numbers are made up to illustrate and are fictitious).
- doe88 8y agoI understand his argument but better have a false positive than a false negative in my opinion.
- mentalhealth 8y agoThis is manifestly not the case, and there are a large number of studies showing why this is true (many linked elsewhere in this thread). Most people do not have a good understanding of the risks associated with ongoing medical testing/medical visits. A hopefully not-too-inaccurate analogy might be if you heard a strange sound while driving your car, and took it into your mechanic, whose shop gets paid more the more tests they do and the more labor they put into fixing your potential non-problem, and they're potentially liable if anything later goes wrong that could be traced to that sound. Think about where the systemic incentives lie.
- avip 8y agoThe numbers mentioned (90% specificity) are for 100% sensitivity (not mentioned in post). These numbers are for patients taking ECG under controlled conditions. Continuous monitoring for AF under arbitrary conditions seems indeed problematic to me.
- guzik 8y agoI must agree with the potential harm of increased false positives but I am not sure if this is the real issue here. In a short period of time, it is impossible to accurately analyze heart trends to find AFib. I mean, people might feel that everything is okay when it's not (false negatives ARE problematic), which can be only determined in full 24h+ / 12-lead ECG scan. However, 20-30s ECG monitoring is still adequate to gather information about some of the disabilities of the user's heart (for example, if any ventricle is damaged). When we were bootstrapping with a similar idea as Apple Watch at Aidlab, all cardiologist were looking at us like we were crazy. Well, seems we were talking with wrong doctors, and we should go straight to Dr. Ivor Benjamin.
- leot 8y agoUtter hogwash. The author's mistake, often made by physicians when presented with technology that gives consumers more information, is that consumer knowledge and attitudes remain static. In fact, while this may at first lead to a bunch of hypochondriac-like behaviors, people's fascination with themselves will quickly teach them to not be alarmed.
- chmaynard 8y agoI agree. I was immediately suspicious when the author identified himself as a "heart doctor". The correct term is cardiologist, as everyone knows. He should be communicating directly with the FDA, not blogging about his concerns to raise alarms.
- emmanuelindex 8y agoI suppose this doctor will prescribe you to not use all new medical tools available in case they might find something. I don't understand the logic. Having mass adoption tools to check your health is the future. This will never be 100% accurate, but like medicine and doctors will never be.
- eli 8y agoYes, doctors and health organizations routinely advise patients not to get more tests than they need. A PSA test is cheap and easy to administer but the consensus is that risk of false positives (among other reasons) outweighs the benefits of finding prostate cancer among young men at low risk.
- MBCook 8y agoI’m still not clear on this, perhaps someone can enlighten me: does the watch attempt to do an ECG whenever it can? Or is it something you have to explicitly trigger? I feel like it must be the first one otherwise people wouldn’t be arguing against it.
- manicdee 8y agoThe watch monitors heart rate all the time. If it detects some symptoms of a-fib (i.e.: irregular heartbeat) it will prompt the user to use the ECG feature.
- MBCook 8y agoAh, that’s the trick. It prompts for the ECG if it thinks something is wrong based on the regularity of the heartbeat sensor. Thanks!
- zaphirplane 8y agoNot a fan of the dumb it down title of heart doctor, cardiologist I feel is fairly widely known, and dumbing it down makes me think that they are dumbing or glossing over other points
- avip 8y agoFor reference, FDA clearance of Apple watch as class II over-the-counter ECG device https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/pdf18/DEN180044.pdf https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/pdf18/DEN180044.pdf
- kapauldo 8y agoWe know what a cardiologist is, we're not stupid.
- swingline-747 8y agoIn my experience, doctors have widely-varying, fact-free opinions that are often wrong on wearables' personal quant and consumer medical devices' precision & accuracy. Heck, some are even wrong on home-medical equipment. The reasons are medical school drills into them two things 1) only doctors and specialists can be "right" 2) everything else is wrong. This creates an opinion based on narcissism and elitism, rather than data. Take a FitBit Charge HR 2. The one I have is consistently within 2-5% of hospital & doctor office pulse readings. That doesn't mean it's perfect in all circumstances, but that it's observations haven't been discredited with evidence and there's little/no counterexamples to show that a device I wear is somehow "inaccurate." Another doctor claimed home blood pressure cuffs, products strictly-regulated by the FDA, are "widely inaccurate." This also seems binary-thinking FUD and wrong, because, anecdotally, I checked repeatedly and have an accurate consumer blood-pressure meter. This is what happens when a profession encourages people to invest their egos in a preordained outcome.
- dontreact 8y agoAs consumers we should be demanding to know the sensitivity and specificity of such health products. Doesn't seem responsible of Apple to market such products without that information.