3 ms·
From the article: > Mozilla's ill-judged adoption of the EME standard downgraded Firefox from a long-standing beacon of software freedom to a well-featured bro
by camgunz 8y ago
From the article:
> Mozilla's ill-judged adoption of the EME standard downgraded Firefox from a long-standing beacon of software freedom to a well-featured browser much like any other.
I think we need to level up our understanding of how power structures are changed. Either you have an intense revolution, or you have incremental change marked by constant compromise and iteration. In the absence of revolution, which would entail somehow revamping the copyright regime in every major political region (US, EU, Asia), Mozilla had no choice but to implement this stuff in order to stay in the game.
It's infuriatingly easy to stay pure on the sidelines, just like it's infuriatingly easy to be a senator in a safe state casting moral aspersions towards senators in swing states. But senators in swing states get things done; they're on the front lines of change. Mozilla's getting things done, working against both entrenched corrupt political and corporate interests, and armchair technological purists. The way to help the situation isn't to criticize organizations like Mozilla for compromising. It's to change the environment so compromise with corrupt institutions isn't necessary.
- kgwxd 8y agoI despise EME and disable it but, I agree, they had no choice. I'm sure that 5% share would be more like 0.001%, all idealistic goofs like me. So "for no gain whatsoever" is not only unprovable, I'm pretty sure it's very wrong. Some choices at at Mozilla have annoyed me greatly but many have made me very happy. I think they've been a net positive influence for user interests.
- mjw1007 8y agoI don't think it would have been so bad for them. If I liked Firefox better than Chrome but Firefox didn't let me watch films in my web browser, I'd run Firefox day to day and open Chrome when I wanted to watch a film. In my experience running a second browser for one particular troublesome site is something not-particularly-technical people often end up doing without worrying about it too much.
- amaccuish 8y agoI did that and it was annoying. I'm glad they've put DRM in, and if you don't want it, you can just ignore the install prompt.