9 ms·
The biggest issue is the whole jury system - I don't understand how being judged by 12 people with no formal law education is considered a working or fair justi
by gambiting 8y ago
The biggest issue is the whole jury system - I don't understand how being judged by 12 people with no formal law education is considered a working or fair justice system.
- ritchiea 8y agoThis makes a lot of sense, what systems are in place in other countries that lead to better outcomes?
- brobdingnagians 8y agoI think the main issue with this case is that the prosecution/court excluded evidence and didn't present the case correctly, even though someone else was _publicly_ admitting guilt in the case and there was plenty of evidence pointing the other way. The jury system could provide relief from this sort of court bias-- _if_ they had the information. So it appears that it is the _system_ that is so frenetic to convict that causes the issue; not the jury [prosecution attorneys tend to think everyone is guilty]. I would agree there is a cultural issue with wanting to convict a lot and firmly believing that everyone convicted by the system must be guilty, but that has very little to do with the jury system. The point of the jury system is to prevent tyranny, especially that experienced in most European countries that had monarchies and oppressive parliaments where angering the government or monarch, being the wrong religion, or having a different ideology would get you convicted very quickly. At least with a jury of your peers you have a chance of getting let off from trumped up charges. Europe _might_ not have the same problems currently, but still nice to have a system that could prevent some egregious things... perhaps including this one.
- ranko 8y agoThe jury shouldn't be deciding legal questions - that's for the judge. A jury is supposed to come to their verdict on a consideration of "matters of fact" (a term of art in the law). For example, the definition of a particular offense (Grievous Bodily Harm, say) is a matter of law, and not up for debate by the jury. The jury's role is to decide whether or not the accused committed that particular crime; eg, does the evidence support ("beyond reasonable doubt") the conclusion that they throw the punch that the prosecution allege caused the injury to the accuser?
- leetcrew 8y agoworth pointing out because i don't know if this is also the case in other countries: if the jurors think the law is dumb, they can return a verdict of not guilty even if there is overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
- KallDrexx 8y agoI'm pretty sure there is leeway in the appeals process for handling this case if it's absolutely obvious the Jury didn't follow the law.
- IanPBann 8y agoYou can appeal against a conviction, but unless new evidence comes to light, a non-guilty verdict closes the case. At least that's my understanding.
- leephillips 8y agoThe non-guilty verdict is final, even in the face of new evidence: “[N]or shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb” (Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution). Sometimes the government gets around this by inventing a new “offence” for the same crime, often at a different political level; for example, you may be acquitted of murder at the state level, but be charged with a “hate crime” at the federal level for the same act.
- leetcrew 8y agothis isn't the jury "not following the law". it's called "jury nullification" and it has been a feature of common law for hundreds of years.
- candiodari 8y agoNOT true AT ALL. This is how it's presented to everyone but this is NOT true. A jury decides on the question if it is just/fair for this person to be convicted of that crime given the crime, the evidence, the state, and the expected punishment, or any other factor they care about. NOT just if they're guilty. A jury is perfectly free to declare someone not guilty even if they are convinced they are guilty. Seriously, give this as an answer as a first year law student and you fail. No question. Of course, it's how prosecutors present it to the jury (you might ask yourself the question: given that they misrepresent this, how badly did they misrepresent the crime in the first place ?) And, frankly, if you knew how the police and penal system worked internally, you would in nearly every last case vote not to convict. It does not fix the crime, it just creates one more victim, and the system is totally inhumane. Even if someone is a criminal and have stolen, or even raped they do not deserve to be subjected to that. Furthermore, prosecutors lie in court to get people convicted, so how trustworthy is their case, really ? Listen to a few of the dirty tricks police pull to convince juries: https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE?t=26m48s https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE?t=26m48s Still so ready to convict ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification NO ! Is the only correct answer when on a jury. Ever.
- wolfgke 8y agoFrom my very German perspective, the serious problem seems to be that the principle of "in dubio pro reo" > https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=In_dubio_pro_reo&oldid=859960701 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=In_dubio_pro_reo&... is not obeyed in the trial. This principle says that a defendant can only be convicted if the evidence is clear that the respective person is guilty. If it is not clear, the defendant is to be let free (or rather: can only be punished for the punishable acts for which the evidence is clear). As you can see in the Wikipedia article, this principle has been very central in German law for centuries.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe US ostensibly has this standard ("proof beyond a reasonable doubt"). I think the problem is related to trust of institutions and a learned blindness. Various participants in a trial all assume the others are working to ensure the correct outcome and don't make every personal effort to do the same.
- candiodari 8y agoTo be fair, even a cursory examination of how much time and effort they get to put into these cases, they cannot. I remember reading that a judge has, on average, spent 16 minutes or less on convictions for less than 1 year sentence. The state makes it impossible for people to do that, even if they were so inclined in the first place. And, of course, they have to consider that they go against part of their own organization to make this happen (meaning some of your colleagues will want a conviction and you preventing them from getting that will have costs).
- coldtea 8y agoThe people who designed the jury system had all the formal law education you ask for. The idea is that such decisions are not mere technical matters, and the law is not for some "supposedly" impartial technocrats to impose their opinion on, but to reflect what society thinks. After all it's not some god given or mathematically derived laws that need to be applied, the law is the will of the sovereign people (with some intermediaries as they can't all just draft them together). Besides the jury system works just fine in other countries. It's the: - systemic racism, - bad incentives for DAs (and political careers associated with being one), - strict adherence to the letter of the law when the spirit is clearly elsewhere (e.g. judges not freeing people for some technical BS despite full evidence that clears them) - privatization of the prison system and large interests - Old Testament-style vengefulness (e.g. death penalty? In 2018? Third world prison conditions? Long term torture-level isolation?) that breaks down the US justice system.
- pjc50 8y agoOther countries have juries. America is I think unique in having elected prosecutors, who have major incentives to commit whatever miscarriages of justice they think will help them get (re-)elected.
- candiodari 8y agoActually, outside of the US, not many countries have juries for most crimes. In most of Western Europe, juries are only possible for murder (or worse). For everything else, a judge decides without any recourse for the population. There, you do not have the right to a jury trial at all.
- IIAOPSW 8y agoAnything other than random citizens would necessitate a full time profession of juror and would thus render members of this profession employees of the state in some capacity. This violates the idea of an independent judiciary. Furthermore a jury of your peers is at least as good as the society around it. A jury of self selecting professionals is almost certainly worse. How many people would choose to join the jury profession so they can enact their own personal bullying by voting guilty on everyone? How many people become small town cops because they like having a gun and barking orders? Furthermore any bias in a juror gets averaged over 12 and affects at most one trial. Furthermore prosecution and defense get to cross examine and dismiss jurors as part of the selection process. If you want a generally well educated jury you can get one. Ask your trial lawyer which jury is right for you! Furthermore it only takes one of the 12 to stop a miscarriage of justice. Furthermore in the US everyone is at least somewhat indoctrinated with an understanding of what a jury is and a respect for executing jury duty faithfully. You have a pretty good shot of getting at least one person on the jury that won't vote guilty instantly so they can still make the baseball game latter that day. Finally, a jury doesn't need law education. Their job is to judge the facts. They are informed of the definitions of the crime, and the evidence, and must reach a verdict of yes he did this or no he did not. Upon rendering a guilty verdict, the actual law part of the law is executed by the judge.
- Aaargh20318 8y ago> Anything other than random citizens would necessitate a full time profession of juror and would thus render members of this profession employees of the state in some capacity. Why have jurors at all ? Over here in the Netherlands people are judged by ... judges (what's in a name).
- cimmanom 8y agoBecause at the time the US split from England, there were myriad concerns about judges being influenced by authorities to convict innocent people for political (or personal) reasons.
- 8y ago
- Amezarak 8y agoNot only are you almost always free to waive your right to a jury trial and have a bench trial before a judge instead, the state strongly encourages you to do so, since jury trials are expensive and time consuming. I would not be surprised if they also had a lower conviction rate.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou seem to assume all jurors are high school dropouts or something. They can come from all kinds of backgrounds and this means that specific jurors can be quite knowledgeable. The idea is a "jury of your peers." Part of the point of this set-up is so that The Haves are not the only ones in positions to make life-altering decisions about people's lives. Jury Nullification is a thing. There is some degree to which jurors, knowledgeable about how the system has consistently and intentionally screwed over "their people," decide to not go along with railroading yet another person of the wrong color or whatever. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification Any time a government is overthrown, one of the first things that happens is they release all the prisoners on the assumption that, regardless of what their conviction is for, these are actually political prisoners. This is a not unreasonable conclusion in most cases.
- Spooky23 8y agoHave you served on a jury? Frankly it gave me a good appreciation for the process and how well it actually works. The “problem” is that few cases go to trial, and many of those lack competent counsel. The other thing to keep in mind is that the law itself and rules of procedure creates many of the social issues that come up in these discussions. Jurors have the benefit of handicap of weighing evidence presented to them against statute as interpreted by a judge.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoBecause we, the people, are the law. And we are free to judge one another as we ought like to be judged. And this tends to be a very good thing. If a law is so absurd as to require a law degree to begin to be able to grasp it, then it's not one anybody should ever be prosecuted for not abiding. A related issue is jury nullification [1]. Juries cannot be forced to convict, regardless of the weight of evidence against an individual. This gives juries the ability, whether defacto or dejure, to determine whether or not a law is just. So for instance in the early 18th century New York passed a law making it a crime to criticize public officials. But with juries being unwilling to hold up the law, it had no effect. In more recent times nullification has been invoked, even if not by name, countless times in statutory rape, drug charges, etc. As wiki mentions, the recent sharp rise in hung juries (going from ~5% to 20% in recent years) has also been seen as possible evidence of a rise in jurors considering the validity or fairness of the laws they're being asked to convict others under. Trial by jury enables a nation to express its own value system, regardless of whether or not those who happen be on top agree. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_Unit...