5 ms·
It's interesting that people like this story because what I see is a pilot who first refused the body scanner and then refused the alternative (a pat down) and
by jgrahamc 16y ago
It's interesting that people like this story because what I see is a pilot who first refused the body scanner and then refused the alternative (a pat down) and was refused entry to the airport. I don't see this as a big deal. He wasn't arrested and appears to have been dealt with politely by all concerned. The "stands up to the TSA" in the headline makes it sound like he's frikkin' Gandhi standing up the British. And I'm probably going to burn karma for saying this but, welcome to Reddit.
- bad_user 16y agoConsidering he's a pilot that flies the airplane, do you think he would need to conceal objects from security scanning to crash that airplane into a building? Boy, those Sep 11 attacks where like a needle straight to the heart ;)
- jgrahamc 16y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1802972 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1802972
- aberkowitz 16y agoWhat it comes down to is that there is no system in place for TSA to determine whether a pilot is actually a pilot. See this essay [1] for a clear argument. [1] http://www.schneier.com/essay-130.html http://www.schneier.com/essay-130.html
- lionhearted 16y agoAgreed. I'm actually a supporter of the scanning technology, because I think it will reduce time spent in line at airports. The shoes taking off thing still seems kind of unnecessary and it's gross that everyone walks through the screening area in only their socks. On a side note, I fly a lot, and it seems like TSA and Homeland Security have gotten much more organized, fast, and polite over the last few years. It was pretty bad 3+ years ago, but the last few flights I took in the USA they were polite and calm and prompt. This piece seems like much ado about nothing - there's legitimate problems in the USA right now, but this event doesn't seem like one of them.
- lionhearted 16y agoHey, hold on guys. I'm writing that: -I'm in favor of scanners because I think they'll speed things up. -Taking shoes off seems unnecessary and counterproductive -I fly a lot, and anecdotally it seems like TSA has improved in etiquitte and service quality -In my opinion, this doesn't seem like an area worthy of much concern People who disagree are welcome to express their disagreement, ideally with a reasoned, unemotional argument instead of flicking the button because you disagree with someone's reasoned point of view.
- Rhapso 16y agoRead to the end before you downvote. It really is a matter of your goals. If your goal is to use the airport for its intended use and you do not really care about your civil rights or you trust the government wholeheartedly then the above makes sense. I think airport security exists more for the government to save face then anything else. It allows them to take an environment made unsafe in the perception of the public and make it 'safe'. Similar to stationing a squad of police officers at a shady part of town and having them harass everybody. In the short term everybody get harassed, but they have to admit in the long run the police officers 'fixed' the problem. This is also a medium of communicating this type of message that the government has practice and established methods of doing. It boils down to: They are doing their best. Yes, it is infringing on our rights. The only solution is a drastic change in the american people. All the fear and drama surrounding airports now, is the victory terrorists had in 9/11. It was their goals to make us afraid as a nation, and they succeeded.
- lionhearted 16y agoGood comment. > If your goal is to use the airport for its intended use and you do not really care about your civil rights or you trust the government wholeheartedly then the above makes sense. I'm a big civil liberties guy myself, but I really think this is pretty low on the list of things going wrong in America. If you wanted to take a stand on any of the 20 worst civil liberties violations in America, does airport scanners really come in on that list? I'm much more worried about the rampant corruption and favoritism of giving money to some banks, some activist groups, some states, according to party lines and individual favors. Then you've got companies writing regulation, and the Vice President openly calling for more internet censorship and government control over the net. No one understands the tax codes, which are ridden with loopholes and confusion and bureaucracy. There's no transparency in legislation, and new bills are frequently 10,000 pages long - that's not hyperbole. There's no way citizens can understand what's actually inside one of those bills. The airports need some security. It's a little too showy right now (liquids and taking shoes off are somewhat ridiculous, in my opinion). But the installation of scanners has got to be pretty low on the list of things that are wrong with the American government. I'm all for drawing lines and holding ground and fighting for civil liberties, but I'm hard pressed to see airport scanners as where to draw the line and fight.
- bambax 16y agoA pilot does not need concealed weapons to crash a plane...?!? He pilots the damn machine. You strip search him, find nothing, let him go, and then he takes command of the plane and can crash it anywhere, any time. How obvious is this?? The link you posted below, to the "FedEx Express Flight 705" incident is completely irrelevant since Mr. Calloway was not in charge of steering that plane. Had he been, he would not have tried to kill the crew.
- loewenskind 16y agoNot to mention there is a big axe in the cockpit.
- borism 16y agoDid you notice there are at least two people in the cockpit?
- ghurlman 16y agoErgo, the big axe.
- borism 16y agoYou find that funny?
- yread 16y agoNot at all times and even then lots of disasters happened because the first officer didn't correct (even major) mistakes by the captain (or vice versa) - EgyptAir 990 comes to mind
- borism 16y agoTrue. I thought about EgyptAir and Aeroflot cases too. Correct me if I'm wrong, but both planes didn't have FBW flight envelope protection either? That might have prevented pilot/child from upsetting planes attitude irrecoverably. And EgyptAir co-pilot actually tried to overcome captain and recover till the end. But I think those cases neither validate nor invalidate the need to screen the pilots? Certainly they validate the case to have co-pilots.
- joezydeco 16y agoHow much do you wanna bet that pilot's uniform he was wearing got him a calmer treatment than, say, a shaggy kid carrying a backpack? The backpacker would have been tasered and thrown in jail after the first "no".