5 ms·
I’m sure you are right that the Chinese cheat, but a fair and equitable free trade system must be based on rules and independent arbitration. Trump is doing eve
by simonh 8y ago
I’m sure you are right that the Chinese cheat, but a fair and equitable free trade system must be based on rules and independent arbitration. Trump is doing everything he can to undermine and destroy every vestige of a rules based independently arbitrated global trade system. His policies are explicitly stated to be purely in US interests only, by him personally. That’s not the basis for a free trade system.
Finger pointing at China doesn’t excuse any of this, even Trump’s policies against China, on the basis of free trade.
- jayalpha 8y agoI don't understand your argument. And if they Chinese tax US cars with 25% and the US taxes them with 2.5% (or was it 5%)? then it is reasonable to request equal tariffs.
- simonh 8y agoOf course it is reasonable, so do that. Pursue them through the WTO or talk to your allies about reforming the WTO if it isn't working to your satisfaction, or scrap the WTO and build something better. If you believe in a global free trade system then build one. The US isn't doing any of that. I have little to no sympathy for China, but I do believe in equitable free trade based on consensus, a common rulebook and independent arbitration. It's served us very well and even with Chinese protectionism, which they have been gradually rolling back, the US and the rest of the world has profited from it. The economic issues in the West over the last 10 years were entirely home-grown and if anything trade with China has been a resilient economic buffer that's helped us cope with the financial crisis (if unintentionally). Blaming them for all our woes is just a distraction.
- speedplane 8y agoTrump and many of his predecessors have gone through the WTO and have very little to show for it. It takes years for any decision and by the time you get the result it’s far too late (see solar panels). Why should any country submit itself to a proven broken system?
- simonh 8y agoThe WTO dispute resolution system has actually been pretty effective[1]. It typically takes about 1-2 years, but usually complainants will impose interim measures themselves anyway. This is just a smoke screen though. Suppose China does make a deal with the US and does agree various measures, what magical secret sauce does the US have to make sure they keep to them and don't violate agreements in the future? There will still need to be a dispute resolution system, a genuine open free trade system can't operate without one. The US policy right now is inimical to that - it's brazenly and explicitly stated to be partisan and based on economic strength rather than equitable free trade. Steel tariffs on close allies on 'national security' grounds? Really? [1] https://www.wto.org/english/res_e/publications_e/dispu_settlement_e.htm https://www.wto.org/english/res_e/publications_e/dispu_settl...
- speedplane 8y agoYeah, the wto dispute resolution system is so fair that multinational corporations can no longer export pollution, weak worker safety protections, and fraudulent business practices to other countries. Everyone is on a level playing field. Or not. Good dispute resolution systems are good. Bad ones provide the facade of justice and merely give credibility to those that have the power to commit injustice.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago" Trump is doing everything he can to undermine and destroy every vestige of a rules based independently arbitrated global trade system" I'm sorry but China is flagrantly violating so many of it's own agreements. The IP agreements of the WTO for one. There would be little fuss if China was sticking to it's own agreements.
- jayalpha 8y ago"There would be little fuss if China was sticking to it's own agreements. " This alone would be very "un-chinese". A signed contract in China is always a contract in negotiation. Can change any time.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt doesn't matter what's on the paper. What matters is what they do. If they don't respect IP, we shouldn't respect theirs. If they respect ours, we respect theirs.
- simonh 8y agoYou're out of date, a lot of that is in the past. They've still got a way to go, but they've been rapidly cleaning up their act, largely because so many Chinese companies are developing their own IP. They are doing what the US did. Rip of European IP until they had IP based industries of their own then get religious about it.
- 8y ago