7 ms·
No one is excluded though. A woman can buy Men's Health; a man can buy Cosmopolitan. What Facebook is doing is enabling straight up exclusion of genders from ad
by bobthepanda 8y ago
No one is excluded though. A woman can buy Men's Health; a man can buy Cosmopolitan. What Facebook is doing is enabling straight up exclusion of genders from advertising, which is completely different in the eyes of the law.
- maccio92 8y agoSo Victoria's secret should be forced to advertise to men too?
- jwassil 8y agoPretty sure it does already :)
- colechristensen 8y agoNo? How does that follow?
- wtvanhest 8y agoYou can segment product advertising, but not housing or jobs or any other categories where there are 'protected classes' (US)
- notyourday 8y agoI cannot wait until some enterprising man decides to apply to be a VS angel. It would be so glorious.
- Angostura 8y agoI imagine they make up a fair proportion of the customer base.
- chrisoverzero 8y agoMen buy lingerie.
- SilasX 8y agoMan, what an unimaginable dystopia, where VS’s hand were forced to the point where they made ads that played on men’s desires and were visually appealing to them ... /s If you mean, “what if they had to make ads that promoted men wearing their products”, I get your point, but I thought it was a funny ambiguity.
- eappleby 8y agoWhat about recruiting from all-female schools like Barnard?
- obmelvin 8y agoIf you were to only recruit from single gender schools then I personally would have an issue with it, same as this issue. However, if you are recruiting from many universities and some happen to be single gender, that is not discriminating.
- eappleby 8y agoWhat if the companies that were placing job ads on Facebook were also placing job ads on other platforms that weren't targeted to men only? Playing devils advocate here...
- lovich 8y agoWell if Facebook wasn't a large portion of the online advertising market then there might be an argument. When you try to become a monopoly you get extra responsibilities as you gain market share
- bduerst 8y agoI think the previous question was about the institution. In this case, Facebook has people of all genders, not just one. It only be an apt analogy to the Universities if Facebook were some single-gender social network. Or if an all-gender University let you only recruit one gender.
- ubernostrum 8y agoThe devil probably has enough advocates at this point and doesn't need your contribution. But in general, there are classes of ads that you just can't target based on certain classes, period. Even if you hypothetically might have the ability to target a counterbalancing ad somewhere else. Facebook repeatedly has been in hot water over this, and both they and the people using their ad platform to do this stuff need to get more than a slap on the wrist, in order to deter others from trying the same in the future.
- busterarm 8y agoThat's not really how digital advertising targeting works though. In fact, they go to great lengths to make sure you illegally exclude by a class (Google is especially strict about this) and don't transmit anything that is considered PII or "potentially PII". Gender, like IP address, is in the potentially PII realm. What this actually is going to do is target "people interested in typically male interests". That is going to end up including men, women and trans men. More importantly, the hit rate of gender-targeted ad spend trends towards 50% regardless of gender. It is not an effective tactic. This is totally overblown. /signed someone who used to be a digital advertiser in the legal space with a yearly budgeted spend north of $100 million.
- SpaceManNabs 8y ago100 million????? Is this normal? Did it actually work? I always wondered on the ROI of ads. It must be high if spending $100 million has no one but me replying...
- busterarm 8y agoEvery industry is different. As far as legal advertising goes, in many states it's heavily regulated (especially Florida); traditional spend still outperforms digital as far as lead quantity. Depending on the campaign/type of spend, digital advertising tends to convert leads in a range somewhere between 0.02% and 10%. 10% is extraordinarily good. Lead quality largely depends on the type of case, but ROI on the good cases is anywhere from low 5/6-digit auto injury cases which require little effort from a lawyer to hundred-million and even billion dollar judgements/settlements.
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> budgeted spend Does that just mean "budget"?
- dmoy 8y agoSpecifically means the budget that will be spent on the ads, vs any kind of personnel, agency, etc cost. Budget alone would be more ambiguous. At least that's my recollection, though I've been out of ads for like a couple years now.
- caseysoftware 8y agoIf someone - anyone buys Men's Health then they're probably interested in the topics they cover. If someone has a browsing profile and Likes that relate to those topics, they will get categorized very similarly. As a result, they are likely to see the ads accordingly. Right now, Google thinks I'm a 65yo+ woman with high income. When I turn off my ad blocker (rarely!), I see ads related to retirement, AARP, etc.
- mynewtb 8y agoI would love to be excluded from advertisements! Love, with an exclamation mark and sprinkles on top. How is this not seen as a good thing, not to be subjected to mind manipulation?
- PeterisP 8y agoIt's not entirely different in the eyes of law - in fact, advertising a job solely in men-targeted magazines would be considered as a discriminatory recruitment practice and be just as illegal as these targeted Facebook ads.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]